放射学方法在侧半月板移植术前移植物尺寸测量中与磁共振成像同样准确
该对照实验室研究对10例新鲜冷冻人尸体膝关节行X线及MRI检查后解剖测量侧半月板实际尺寸,比较人体测量、Pollard法、Yoon法和MRI预测侧半月板长宽的准确性。结果显示MRI和Yoon放射学法准确性相当,均优于Pollard法和人体测量法;作者推荐Yoon放射学法,不推荐原始Pollard技术和人体测量法。
要点
- MRI在65%的测量中能将侧半月板尺寸预测在解剖尺寸10%以内,Yoon法为54%,Pollard法为20%(P=0.01)。
- 宽度方面,人体测量法与解剖测量的绝对差值显著大于Pollard技术和MRI(P=0.002)。
- 长度方面,Pollard法的绝对差值显著大于所有其他技术(P=0.003)。
核心结论
- MRI和Yoon放射学法在侧半月板移植术前移植物尺寸测量方面准确性相当。
- MRI虽然有用,但需要对侧MRI;鉴于Yoon放射学法简便且成本更低,作者推荐Yoon放射学法。
- 作者不推荐原始Pollard技术和人体测量法。
研究设计与样本
- 受控实验室研究,纳入10例无半月板或韧带损伤证据的新鲜冷冻人尸体膝关节。
- 先对标本行X线和MRI成像,随后解剖评估每个半月板的解剖尺寸。
- 采用人体测量、放射学(Pollard法和Yoon法)及MRI四种方法预测侧半月板尺寸,计算预测尺寸与实际尺寸在长度和宽度上的绝对差值。
主要发现
- 侧半月板解剖宽度为33.01 ± 4.25 mm(均值 ± 标准差;范围24.84-40.18 mm),长度为31.41 ± 5.06 mm(范围25.2-40.05 mm)。
- 宽度方面,人体测量法与解剖测量的绝对差值显著大于Pollard技术和MRI(P=0.002)。
- 长度方面,Pollard法的绝对差值显著大于所有其他技术(P=0.003)。
- MRI在65%的测量中能将侧半月板尺寸预测在解剖尺寸10%以内,Yoon法为54%,Pollard法为20%(P=0.01)。
- X线倾向于高估侧半月板真实尺寸,而人体测量技术在全部标本中均高估宽度。
临床怎么用
- 作者推荐Yoon放射学法用于侧半月板移植术前移植物尺寸测量,因其简便且具成本优势。
- 作者认为MRI有用,但需要行对侧MRI。
- 作者不推荐原始Pollard技术和人体测量法。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Accurate allograft matching is deemed critical for meniscal transplantation; thus, precise measurements are essential to correctly calculate meniscal size. Several methods for meniscal sizing have been described, but there remains a discussion on which is the most accurate for the lateral meniscus. PURPOSE: To compare the accuracy of radiographic, anthropometric, and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) methods of determining width and length of the lateral meniscus with actual dimensions after anatomic dissection. STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: Ten fresh-frozen human cadaveric knees without any evidence of meniscal or ligamentous injury were primarily imaged using radiography and MRI and subsequently underwent dissection to assess the anatomic size of each meniscus. Four methods were used to predict the size of the lateral menisci: anthropometric, radiographic (Pollard and Yoon), and MRI. Absolute differences in length and width between actual and predicted sizes were determined. RESULTS: The anatomic lateral meniscal width and length were 33.01 ± 4.25 mm (mean ± SD; range, 24.84-40.18 mm) and 31.41 ± 5.06 mm (range, 25.2-40.05 mm), respectively. Regarding width, the anthropometric method demonstrated an absolute difference from anatomic measurement significantly greater when compared with the Pollard technique and MRI (P = .002). Regarding length, the Pollard method presented an absolute difference significantly greater than all other techniques (P = .003). In terms of the ability to measure width and length, MRI accurately predicted meniscal size within 10% of the anatomic size in 65% of measurements, the Yoon method in 54%, and the Pollard method in 20% (P = .01). Radiographs tended to overestimate the true size of the lateral meniscus, while the anthropometric technique overestimated width in all specimens. CONCLUSION: This study demonstrated that MRI and the Yoon radiographic method are comparable in terms of accuracy for graft sizing before lateral meniscal transplantation. While MRI is useful, a contralateral MRI is required, which makes the Yoon radiographic method recommended given the ease and cost advantage. The original Pollard technique and the anthropometric method are not recommended. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Over- and undersizing of meniscal transplants has been implicated in graft failure. Therefore, increasing the reliability of preoperative meniscal measurements is deemed important for the success of meniscal allograft transplantation.
引用
- Ambra LF, Kaleka CC, Debieux P, et al. Radiographic Methods Are as Accurate as Magnetic Resonance Imaging for Graft Sizing Before Lateral Meniscal Transplantation. Am J Sports Med. 2020. PMID: 33108216. doi:10.1177/0363546520963095
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。