文献速递创伤骨科关节外科运动医学

新冠疫情期间骨科远程医疗中患者与外科医生满意度如何:系统综述与Meta分析

How Satisfied Are Patients and Surgeons with Telemedicine in Orthopaedic Care During the COVID-19 Pandemic? A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2021-01-01

本系统综述与Meta分析纳入8项随机对照试验共1008例患者(远程医疗组511例,对照组497例),评估骨科远程医疗与面对面诊疗的患者及外科医生满意度、患者报告结局和时间投入差异。结果显示两组满意度无差异(合并OR 0.89,95%CI 0.40-1.99,p=0.79),患者报告结局无差异,远程医疗组患者报告节省时间。

要点

  • 骨科远程医疗与面对面诊疗的患者满意度无差异(合并OR 0.89,95%CI 0.40-1.99,p=0.79)。
  • 外科医生满意度两组无差异(合并OR 0.38,95%CI 0.07-2.19,p=0.28)。
  • 远程医疗组患者报告时间节省:排除交通时间缩短17分钟(95%CI 2-32,p=0.03),包含交通时间缩短180分钟(95%CI 78-281,p<0.001)。

核心结论

  • 异质性随机研究证据表明,与面对面评估相比,骨科远程医疗评估在患者或外科医生满意度方面未发现可识别的差异。
  • 本综述的原始研究未充分捕获或报告安全性终点,如并发症或漏诊。
  • 未来研究必须有足够的把握度来检测这些差异,以确保远程医疗的使用不会损害患者安全。
  • 尽管远程医疗可能带来相似的患者体验,在缺乏进一步安全性数据的情况下,外科医生应保持低阈值,尽可能进行面对面评估随访。

研究设计与样本

  • 遵循PRISMA指南开展系统综述与Meta分析,检索MEDLINE、Embase和Cochrane Library三个医学数据库,并辅以手工检索。
  • 纳入标准为评估远程医疗与面对面骨科评估结局的随机对照试验,远程医疗包括视频、电话或基于互联网的诊疗等形式,对照组为骨科医生面对面评估,且为Level I原始证据报告。
  • 排除评估物理治疗或康复干预的研究。
  • 共筛选133篇已发表文章,12篇文章(代表8项随机对照试验)符合纳入标准。
  • 共1008例患者随机分组(远程医疗组511例,对照组497例);亚专业包括髋膝关节置换(2项试验)、上肢(2项试验)、儿童创伤(1项试验)、成人创伤(1项试验)和普通骨科(2项试验)。

主要发现

  • 接受远程医疗照护的患者与接受面对面照护的患者之间,满意度比值无差异(合并OR 0.89,95%CI 0.40-1.99,p=0.79)。
  • 外科医生满意度无差异(合并OR 0.38,95%CI 0.07-2.19,p=0.28)。
  • 评估疼痛和功能的多个患者报告结局指标之间无差异。
  • 患者报告时间节省:排除交通时间时缩短17分钟(95%CI 2-32,p=0.03),包含交通时间时缩短180分钟(95%CI 78-281,p<0.001)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 患者满意度合并OR 0.89(95%CI 0.40-1.99,p=0.79),远程医疗组与面对面组比较无差异。
  • 外科医生满意度合并OR 0.38(95%CI 0.07-2.19,p=0.28),两组比较无差异。
  • 排除交通时间的时间节省为缩短17分钟(95%CI 2-32,p=0.03)。
  • 包含交通时间的时间节省为缩短180分钟(95%CI 78-281,p<0.001)。
  • 证据等级为Level I,治疗性研究。

临床怎么用

  • 原文结论指出,尽管远程医疗可能带来相似的患者体验,外科医生应保持低阈值,尽可能进行面对面评估随访(在缺乏进一步安全性数据的情况下)。

局限性

  • 纳入研究为异质性随机研究。
  • 原始研究未充分捕获或报告安全性终点,如并发症或漏诊。
  • 未来研究必须有足够的把握度来检测这些差异,以确保远程医疗的使用不会损害患者安全。
  • 所有纳入试验在盲法类别(实施者、患者和结局评估者盲法)均评为高偏倚风险。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic has resulted in a rapid pivot toward telemedicine owing to closure of in-person elective clinics and sustained efforts at physical distancing worldwide. Throughout this period, there has been revived enthusiasm for delivering and receiving orthopaedic care remotely. Unfortunately, rapidly published editorials and commentaries during the pandemic have not adequately conveyed findings of published randomized trials on this topic. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: In this systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized trials, we asked: (1) What are the levels of patient and surgeon satisfaction with the use of telemedicine as a tool for orthopaedic care delivery? (2) Are there differences in patient-reported outcomes between telemedicine visits and in-person visits? (3) What is the difference in time commitment between telemedicine and in-person visits? METHODS: In accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines, we conducted a systematic review with the primary objective to determine patient and surgeon satisfaction with telemedicine, and secondary objectives to determine differences in patient-reported outcomes and time commitment. We used combinations of search keywords and medical subject headings around the terms "telemedicine", "telehealth", and "virtual care" combined with "orthopaedic", "orthopaedic surgery" and "randomized." We searched three medical databases (MEDLINE, Embase, and the Cochrane Library) in duplicate and performed manual searches to identify randomized controlled trials evaluating the outcomes of telemedicine and in-person orthopaedic assessments. Trials that studied an intervention that was considered to be telemedicine (that is, any form of remote or virtual care including, but not limited to, video, telephone, or internet-based care), had a control group that comprised in-person assessments performed by orthopaedic surgeons, and were reports of Level I original evidence were included in this study. Studies evaluating physiotherapy or rehabilitation interventions were excluded. Data was extracted by two reviewers and quantitative and qualitive summaries of results were generated. Methodological quality of included trials was assessed using the Cochrane Risk of Bias tool, which uniformly rated the trials at high risk of bias within the blinding categories (blinding of providers, patients, and outcome assessors). We screened 133 published articles; 12 articles (representing eight randomized controlled trials) met the inclusion criteria. There were 1008 patients randomized (511 to telemedicine groups and 497 to control groups). Subspecialties represented were hip and knee arthroplasty (two trials), upper extremity (two trials), pediatric trauma (one trial), adult trauma (one trial), and general orthopaedics (two trials). RESULTS: There was no difference in the odds of satisfaction between patients receiving telemedicine care and those receiving in-person care (pooled odds ratio 0.89 [95% CI 0.40 to 1.99]; p = 0.79). There were also no differences in surgeon satisfaction (pooled OR 0.38 [95% CI 0.07 to 2.19]; p = 0.28) or among multiple patient-reported outcome measures that evaluated pain and function. Patients reported time savings, both when travel time was excluded (17 minutes shorter [95% CI 2 to 32]; p = 0.03) and when it was included (180 minutes shorter [95% CI 78 to 281]; p < 0.001). CONCLUSION: Evidence from heterogeneous randomized studies demonstrates that the use of telemedicine for orthopaedic assessments does not result in identifiable differences in patient or surgeon satisfaction compared with in-person assessments. Importantly, the source studies in this review did not adequately capture or report safety endpoints, such as complications or missed diagnoses. Future studies must be adequately powered to detect these differences to ensure patient safety is not compromised with the use of telemedicine. Although telemedicine may lead to a similar patient experience, surgeons should maintain a low threshold for follow-up with in-person assessments whenever possible in the absence of further safety data. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level I, therapeutic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Chaudhry H, Nadeem S, Mundi R, et al. How Satisfied Are Patients and Surgeons with Telemedicine in Orthopaedic Care During the COVID-19 Pandemic? A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2021. PMID: 33009231. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000001494

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。