接受初次单间室膝关节置换术的患者翻修风险高于全膝关节置换术,但死亡率低于若接受全膝关节置换术的预测值:来自英格兰、威尔士、北爱尔兰和马恩岛国家关节登记处的数据
该研究利用国家关节登记处数据,比较单间室膝关节置换术(UKR)与全膝关节置换术(TKR)的翻修率和90天死亡率,并通过灵活参数生存模型估算UKR患者若接受TKR的预测翻修率。结果显示UKR十年翻修率是TKR预测值的2.5倍,但90天死亡率低于TKR(0.08% vs 0.33%),且低于UKR患者若接受TKR的预测死亡率(0.18%)。
要点
- UKR十年翻修率为TKR预测值的2.5倍,相当于每1000例多70例翻修。
- UKR术后90天死亡率为0.08%,低于TKR的0.33%,也低于预测的0.18%。
- 翻修后的UKR与翻修后的TKR再翻修率相似,但均高于初次TKR。
核心结论
- 在考虑人口学和病例量差异后,UKR的翻修率仍显著高于TKR,但UKR术后死亡更少。
- 翻修后的UKR与翻修后的TKR再翻修率相似,但远高于初次TKR,因此UKR不能被视为中间手术。
研究设计与样本
- 基于英格兰、威尔士、北爱尔兰和马恩岛国家关节登记处的数据,估计UKR和TKR的翻修率与死亡率。
- 使用灵活参数生存模型(FPM)对TKR的失败进行建模,并据此对UKR进行估计。
- 采用Kaplan-Meier估计比较翻修后的UKR和TKR的累积再翻修率。
主要发现
- UKR十年翻修率是TKR预测值的2.5倍,相当于10年内每1000例多70例翻修,本队列中多5861例翻修。
- 手术量最高四分位UKR外科医生的翻修率是同一四分位TKR的2.5倍,最低四分位分别为3.9倍。
- 翻修后TKR的再翻修率(10年=17.5%,95%CI 16.4-18.7)与翻修后UKR(15.2%,95%CI 13.4-17.1)相似,且高于初次TKR后的翻修率(3.3%,95%CI 3.1-3.5)。
- UKR术后90天死亡率为0.08%,低于TKR的0.33%,也低于UKR患者若接受TKR的预测死亡率0.18%,相当于每1000例少1例死亡。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: To determine unicompartmental (UKR) and total knee replacement (TKR) revision rates, compare UKR revision rates with what they would have been had they received TKR instead, and assess subsequent re-revision and 90-day mortality rates. METHODS: Using National Joint Registry data, we estimated UKR and TKR revision and mortality rates. Flexible parametric survival modeling (FPM) was used to model failure in TKR and make estimates for UKR. Kaplan-Meier estimates were used to compare cumulative re-revision for revised UKRs and TKRs. RESULTS: Ten-year UKR revision rates were 2.5 times higher than expected from TKR, equivalent to 70 excess revisions/1000 cases within 10 years (5861 excess revisions in this cohort). Revision rates were 2.5 times higher for the highest quartile volume UKR surgeons compared to the same quartile for TKR and 3.9 times higher for the lowest quartiles respectively. Re-revision rates of revised TKRs (10 years = 17.5%, 95% confidence interval [CI] 16.4-18.7) were similar to revised UKRs (15.2%, 95% CI 13.4-17.1) and higher than revision rates following primary TKR (3.3%, 95% CI 3.1-3.5). Ninety-day mortality rates were lower after UKR compared with TKR (0.08% vs 0.33%) and lower than predicted had UKR patients received a TKR (0.18%), equivalent to 1 fewer death per 1000 cases. CONCLUSION: UKR revision rates were substantially higher than TKR even when demographics and caseload differences were accounted for; however, fewer deaths occur after UKR. This should be considered when forming treatment guidelines and commissioning services. Re-revision rates were similar between revised UKRs and TKRs, but considerably higher than for primary TKR, therefore UKR cannot be considered an intermediate procedure.
引用
- Hunt LP, Blom AW, Matharu GS, et al. Patients Receiving a Primary Unicompartmental Knee Replacement Have a Higher Risk of Revision but a Lower Risk of Mortality Than Predicted Had They Received a Total Knee Replacement: Data From the National Joint Registry for England, Wales, Northern Ireland, and the Isle of Man. J Arthroplasty. 2020. PMID: 33011013. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2020.08.063
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。