2009年至2017年 Medicare 受益人全关节置换术使用的地理差异与差异
该研究使用2009至2017年 Medicare 参保与理赔数据,分析医院转诊区域层面全髋与全膝关节置换利用率的种族和社会经济差异。结果显示全髋置换率在仅 Medicare 的白人及黑人中分别升高32%和48%,但双重资格者手术率未变,导致差异扩大;全膝置换差异无变化。
要点
- 2017年医院转诊区域层面平均全髋置换率为每千受益人4.64例,全膝置换率为9.66例,区域间差异达三倍。
- 仅 Medicare 白人全髋置换率较2009年升高32%,仅 Medicare 黑人升高48%(p<0.001)。
- 白人双重资格者与仅 Medicare 者差距增加0.75例/千人(增幅40.98%,p=0.03),黑人差距增加1.13例/千人(增幅297.37%,p<0.001)。
核心结论
- 仅 Medicare 的两种族受益人全髋置换使用增加,但白人和黑人双重资格者相对仅 Medicare 者的差异在扩大。
- 改善公平需识别并解决种族和社会经济障碍,并聚焦弱势受益人集中的地区。
研究设计与样本
- 使用2009至2017年 Medicare 参保与理赔数据,分析医院转诊区域层面按种族(非西班牙裔白人和黑人)和社会经济地位(仅 Medicare 与同时符合 Medicare 和 Medicaid 双重资格)的差异。
- 构建多水平混合效应线性回归模型估计全髋和全膝置换率趋势,并检验黑人受益人或双重资格受益人比例高的医院转诊区域手术率是否更低。
- 研究纳入924,844例全髋置换和2,075,968例全膝置换。
主要发现
- 2017年医院转诊区域层面平均全髋置换率为每千受益人4.64例,全膝置换率为9.66例,区域间差异达三倍。
- 2017年全髋置换率在仅 Medicare 白人中较2009年高32%,在仅 Medicare 黑人中高48%(p<0.001)。
- 白人双重资格者与仅 Medicare 者差距增加0.75例/千人(增幅40.98%,p=0.03),黑人差距增加1.13例/千人(增幅297.37%,p<0.001)。
- 全膝置换差异保持不变;白人双重资格者手术率显著低于黑人仅 Medicare 者(全髋和全膝置换 p<0.001)。
- 黑人受益人或双重资格受益人密度较高的医院转诊区域手术量较少。
关键数值与推荐
- 全髋置换率:仅 Medicare 白人升高32%,仅 Medicare 黑人升高48%(均较2009年,p<0.001)。
- 白人仅 Medicare 与双重资格者差距增加0.75例/千人(增幅40.98%,p=0.03)。
- 黑人仅 Medicare 与双重资格者差距增加1.13例/千人(增幅297.37%,p<0.001)。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论指出,改善公平的努力必须识别并解决种族和社会经济障碍,并聚焦弱势受益人集中的地区。
- 原文临床相关性指出,这些证据对于设计和实施针对患者、提供者和地理区域的差异缩减策略至关重要,可能改善关节置换护理的公平性。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Little is known about how the geographic variation and disparities in use of elective primary total hip and knee replacements for Medicare beneficiaries have evolved in recent years. The study objectives are to determine these variations and disparities, whether Black Medicare beneficiaries have continued to undergo fewer total hip replacements and total knee replacements across regions, and whether disparities affected all Black beneficiaries or mainly affected socioeconomically disadvantaged Black beneficiaries. METHODS: We used 2009 to 2017 Medicare enrollment and claims data to examine Hospital Referral Region (HRR)-level variation and disparities by race (non-Hispanic White and Black) and socioeconomic status (Medicare-only and dual eligibility for both Medicare and Medicaid). The outcomes were HRR-level age and sex-standardized total hip replacement and total knee replacement utilization rates for White Medicare-only beneficiaries, White dual-eligible beneficiaries, Black Medicare-only beneficiaries, and Black dual-eligible beneficiaries, and the differences in rates between these groups as a representation of disparities. The key exposure variables were race-socioeconomic group and year. We constructed multilevel mixed-effects linear regression models to estimate trends in total hip replacement and total knee replacement rates and to examine whether rates were lower in HRRs with high percentages of Black beneficiaries or dual-eligible beneficiaries. RESULTS: The study included 924,844 total hip replacements and 2,075,968 total knee replacements. In 2017, the mean HRR-level total hip replacement rate was 4.64 surgical procedures per 1,000 beneficiaries, and the mean HRR-level total knee replacement rate was 9.66 surgical procedures per 1,000 beneficiaries, with a threefold variation across HRRs. In 2017, the total hip replacement rate was 32% higher for White Medicare-only beneficiaries and 48% higher for Black Medicare-only beneficiaries than in 2009 (p < 0.001). However, because the surgical rates for White and Black dual-eligible beneficiaries remained unchanged over the study period, the 2017 Medicare-only and dual-eligible disparity for White beneficiaries increased by 0.75 surgical procedures per 1,000 from 2009 (40.98% increase; p = 0.03), and the disparity for Black beneficiaries by 1.13 surgical procedures per 1,000 beneficiaries (297.37% increase; p < 0.001). The total knee replacement disparities remained unchanged. Notably, the rates for White dual-eligible beneficiaries were significantly lower than those for Black Medicare-only beneficiaries (p < 0.001 for both total hip replacements and total knee replacements), and fewer surgical procedures were conducted in HRRs with a higher density of Black or dual-eligible beneficiaries. CONCLUSIONS: Although the total hip replacement use for Medicare-only beneficiaries of both races increased, disparities for White and Black dual-eligible beneficiaries (compared with their Medicare-only counterparts) are increasing. Efforts to improve equity must identify and address both racial and socioeconomic barriers and focus on regions with high concentrations of disadvantaged beneficiaries. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Although total hip replacements and total knee replacements are highly successful surgical procedures for end-stage osteoarthritis, our findings show that, as recently as 2017, Black beneficiaries and those dual eligible for Medicaid (a proxy for socioeconomic status) are less likely to undergo these surgical procedures and that there is profound geographic variation in the use of these surgical procedures. This evidence is essential for the design and implementation of disparity-reduction strategies focused on patients, providers, and geographic areas that can potentially improve the equity in joint replacement care.
引用
- Thirukumaran CP, Cai X, Glance LG, et al. Geographic Variation and Disparities in Total Joint Replacement Use for Medicare Beneficiaries: 2009 to 2017. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2020. PMID: 33079898. doi:10.2106/JBJS.20.00246
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。