全膝关节置换术后沐浴时最佳伤口敷料的选择
研究将Aquacel、Opsite、Acticoat和Tegaderm四种敷料应用于17名受试者的膝关节,通过称量敷料下纱布海绵沐浴前后的重量变化评估防水渗透能力,并以海绵重量变化超过3.9克定义为失败。结果显示Tegaderm在淋浴时无失败且防水渗透显著优于除Aquacel外的其他敷料,浸浴时防水渗透显著优于除Acticoat外的其他敷料且失败显著更少,同时最为舒适、单次成本最低。
要点
- Tegaderm淋浴时无失败,防水渗透显著优于除Aquacel外的其他敷料。
- Tegaderm浸浴时防水渗透显著优于除Acticoat外的其他敷料且失败显著更少。
- Tegaderm最舒适且单次敷料成本最低;Aquacel淋浴防水效果相当但总体渗水更多、失败更多、更不舒适且更贵。
核心结论
- Tegaderm在防止水渗透方面总体最有效、最舒适且最具成本效益。
- Aquacel在淋浴时防止水渗透的效果与Tegaderm相当,但总体水渗透更多、失败更多、引起更多不适且更昂贵。
研究设计与样本
- 研究将四种不同敷料应用于17名受试者的膝关节:Aquacel、Opsite、Acticoat和Tegaderm。
- 在淋浴和浸浴(水中浸泡)前后称量置于每种敷料下的折叠Medline纱布海绵重量,以测量水渗透(海绵重量变化,单位克)。
- 失败定义为任何敷料允许海绵重量变化大于1个标准差,即3.9克。
- 所有参与者在测试后还被要求完成一份关于敷料的简短调查。
主要发现
- Tegaderm的水渗透显著少于除Aquacel外的所有其他敷料,且在淋浴时无失败,失败显著少于所有其他敷料。
- Tegaderm在浸浴时水渗透显著少于除Acticoat外的所有其他敷料,且失败显著少于所有其他敷料。
- Tegaderm被认为最舒适且单次敷料成本最低。
关键数值与推荐
- 失败定义为海绵重量变化大于1个标准差,即3.9克。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Many surgical dressings claim to be waterproof and safe for bathing postoperatively. The purpose of this study is to evaluate and compare the effectiveness of commonly used dressings' ability to prevent water penetration while bathing. Additionally, a survey was used to determine satisfaction and cost analysis performed. METHODS: Four different dressings were applied to 17 subjects' knees: Aquacel, Opsite, Acticoat, and Tegaderm. A folded Medline Gauze Sponge was weighed and placed under each dressing before and after showering and bathing (submergence under water) in order to measure water penetration (change in weight of sponge in grams). A failure was defined as any dressing that allowed a sponge weight change greater than 1 standard deviation, or 3.9 g. All participants were additionally asked to complete a short survey after testing about the dressings. RESULTS: Tegaderm was found to have significantly less water penetration than all other dressings except Aquacel and demonstrated no failures with showering, significantly less than all other dressings. Tegaderm was also found to have significantly less water penetration than all other dressings except Acticoat with bathing and had significantly less failures than all other dressings. Furthermore, Tegaderm was found to be the most comfortable and lowest cost per dressing. CONCLUSION: Tegaderm was overall the most effective at preventing water penetration, most comfortable, and most cost-effective. Aquacel was found to be equally as effective at preventing water penetration while showering but overall had more water penetration, had more failures, caused more discomfort, and was more expensive.
引用
- Michelin RM, Ahdoot E, Zakhary BL, et al. Choosing the Optimal Wound Dressing for Bathing After Total Knee Arthroplasty. J Arthroplasty. 2020. PMID: 33046327. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2020.09.023
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。