术中X线片的放射科医师复核:价值还是浪费?
该研究回顾了391例髋膝关节置换病例中6个月内生成的200份术中X线报告,评估放射科医师复核的延迟时间、准确性和费用。结果显示报告中位延迟45分钟,仅31.5%在手术结束前归档,18.0%(36/200)被判定为不准确;髋、膝关节阅片费分别为52.00美元和38.00美元,本系列总费用10,182美元,预计本院年费用43,614美元。作者认为复核对实时决策无影响,建议支付方停止为此付费。
要点
- 术中X线报告的中位延迟为45分钟,仅31.5%在手术结束前归档。
- 按宽松标准仍有18.0%(36/200)的复核报告被判定为不准确。
- 本系列复核总费用10,182美元,预计本院年费用43,614美元。
核心结论
- 放射科医师对术中X线片的复核对实时决策没有影响。
- 在价值医疗时代,支付方应停止为复核付费,并补偿真正在术中阅片的提供者。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入6个月内391例髋膝关节置换病例中生成的200份髋、膝关节X线报告。
- 将报告口述时间与手术结束时间比较,并将每份复核报告评为准确或不准确。
- 复核费用通过X线数量乘以放射科费用减去技术费用计算。
主要发现
- 从拍摄X线片到报告归档的中位延迟为45分钟(范围0-9778分钟)。
- 仅31.5%的报告在手术结束前归档。
- 18.0%(36/200)的复核报告在宽松标准下仍被判定为不准确。
- 髋关节X线阅片费为52.00美元,膝关节为38.00美元,本系列总费用为10,182美元。
- 预计本院年费用为43,614美元。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为支付方应停止为术中X线片的放射科复核付费。
- 作者认为应补偿真正在术中阅片的提供者。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: All aspects of the arthroplasty pathway must be scrutinized to maximize value and eliminate unnecessary cost. Radiology providers' contracts with hospitals often call for readings of all radiographs. This policy has little effect on patient care when intraoperative radiographs are taken and used to make real-time decisions. In order to determine the value of radiologist overreads, we asked 3 questions: what was the delay between the time an intraoperative radiograph was taken and time the report was generated, were the overreads accurate, and what is the associated cost? METHODS: Two hundred hip and knee radiograph reports generated over 6 months during 391 cases were reviewed. The time the report was dictated was compared to the time taken and time of surgery completion. To determine accuracy, each overread was rated as accurate or inaccurate. The cost of the overread was determined by multiplying the number of radiographs times the radiology fee less the technical fee. RESULTS: Median delay between taking the radiograph and filing the report was 45 minutes (range, 0-9778 minutes). Only 31.5% were filed before completion of the procedure. And 18.0% (36/200) were considered inaccurate despite lenient criteria. The reading fee for hip radiographs was $52.00, and for knee radiographs was $38.00, representing a total cost of $10,182 in our select series. This cost projects to $43,614 annually at our facility. CONCLUSION: Radiology overreads of intraoperative radiographs have no effect on real-time decision-making. In the era of value-based care, payors should stop paying for overreads and reimburse providers who actually read the films intraoperatively.
引用
- Braswell MJ, Fehring KA, Barry JJ, et al. Radiologist Overreads of Intraoperative Radiographs-Value or Waste? J Arthroplasty. 2020. PMID: 33051120. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2020.09.013
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。