成人症状性腰椎侧凸手术与非手术治疗患者功能跑步机测试的差异
前瞻性纵向队列研究纳入187例成人症状性腰椎侧凸患者(非手术88例、手术99例),比较基线及治疗后2年功能跑步机测试参数与患者报告结局。基线时手术组跑步机测试后背痛更重;2年随访时非手术组步行时间恶化而手术组改善,手术组跑步机测试后背痛和腿痛改善程度显著大于非手术组。
要点
- 基线时手术组跑步机测试后背痛评分4.39 vs 非手术组3.45(P=0.032),尽管ODI、SRS-22疼痛和活动域评分相似。
- 2年随访时步行时间变化手术组+2.15 vs 非手术组-1.20(P=0.001),非手术组恶化而手术组改善。
- 2年随访时跑步机测试后背痛改善手术组-0.53 vs 非手术组-2.64(P<0.000),手术组改善显著更大。
核心结论
- 基线时手术治疗患者的跑步机测试结果比非手术治疗患者更差。
- 2年随访时非手术治疗患者步行时间恶化而手术治疗患者改善。
- 尽管两组2年时跑步机测试后背痛和腿痛均改善,手术组改善程度大于非手术组。
- 功能跑步机测试可能是评估成人症状性腰椎侧凸治疗结局的有用辅助工具,并可能帮助外科医生就手术或非手术治疗后2年的预期对患者进行咨询。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性纵向队列研究。
- 纳入187例成人症状性腰椎侧凸患者,非手术治疗88例、手术治疗99例,均有完整基线和治疗后2年功能跑步机测试及同期患者报告结局。
- 功能跑步机测试参数包括最大速度、症状出现时间、步行距离、步行时间以及测试前后的背痛和腿痛严重程度。
主要发现
- 基线时手术组跑步机测试后背痛评分4.39 vs 非手术组3.45(P=0.032),手术组更差,尽管两组ODI、SRS-22疼痛和活动域评分相似。
- 步行时间变化手术组+2.15 vs 非手术组-1.20(P=0.001),手术组改善而非手术组恶化。
- 测试前背痛变化手术组+0.19 vs 非手术组-1.60(P<0.000),手术组改善而非手术组恶化。
- 测试前腿痛变化手术组+0.25 vs 非手术组-0.54(P=0.024),手术组改善而非手术组恶化。
- 2年随访时跑步机测试后背痛改善手术组-0.53 vs 非手术组-2.64(P<0.000),腿痛改善手术组-0.13 vs 非手术组-1.54(P=0.001),手术组改善显著大于非手术组。
关键数值与推荐
- 证据等级为2级。
临床怎么用
- 功能跑步机测试可能是评估成人症状性腰椎侧凸治疗结局的有用辅助工具。
- 功能跑步机测试可能帮助外科医生就手术或非手术治疗后2年的预期对患者进行咨询。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY DESIGN: Prospective longitudinal cohort. OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to determine whether functional treadmill testing (FTT) demonstrates differences between patients treated operatively and nonoperatively for adult symptomatic lumbar scoliosis (ASLS). SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: ASLS has become increasingly prevalent as the population ages. ASLS can be accompanied by neurogenic claudication, leading to difficulty walking. FTT may provide a functional tool to evaluate patients with ASLS. METHODS: One hundred and eighty-seven patients who underwent nonoperative (n = 88) or operative treatment (n = 99) of ASLS with complete baseline and 2-year post-treatment FTTs and concurrent patient-reported outcomes were identified. FTT parameters included maximum speed, time to onset of symptoms, distance ambulated, time ambulated, and Back and Leg pain severity before and after testing. RESULTS: At baseline, patients treated operatively reported worse post-FTT back pain (4.39 vs. 3.45, P = 0.032) than those treated nonoperatively, despite similar ODI, SRS-22 Pain and Activity domain scores. Mean time ambulated (+2.15 vs. -1.20 P = 0.001), pre-FTT back pain (+0.19 vs. -1.60, P < 0.000) and leg pain (+0.25 vs. -0.54, P = 0.024) improved in the operative group but deteriorated in the nonoperative group. On the 2-year follow-up FTT, both groups showed improvement in post-FTT back pain (-0.53 vs. -2.64, P < 0.000) and leg pain (-0.13 vs. -1.54, P = 0.001) severity but the improvement was statistically significantly greater in the operative compared to the nonoperative group. CONCLUSION: FTT results at baseline were worse in patients treated operatively than those treated non-operatively. FTT may be a useful adjunct to assess treatment outcomes in patients with ASLS and may help surgeons counsel patients regarding expectations 2 years after operative or nonoperative treatment for ASLS. At 2-year follow-up, time ambulated deteriorated in patients treated nonoperatively but improved in patients treated operatively. Although both groups showed improvement in post-FTT Back and Leg pain at 2 years, the improvement was greater in the operative compared to the nonoperative group. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 2.
引用
- Carreon LY, Glassman SD, Yanik EL, et al. Differences in Functional Treadmill Tests in Patients With Adult Symptomatic Lumbar Scoliosis Treated Operatively and Nonoperatively. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2020. PMID: 33122605. doi:10.1097/BRS.0000000000003640
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。