文献速递运动医学手外科与足踝外科

外侧踝关节稳定术的中期结局在军人与平民人群之间是否存在差异?

Do Mid-term Outcomes of Lateral Ankle Stabilization Procedures Differ Between Military and Civilian Populations?
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2021-01-01

该回顾性研究纳入125例现役军人外侧踝关节稳定术患者,至少随访2年(平均7年),67%获良好至优秀FADI评分,与平民文献报道的85%以上相比明显偏低;腓骨骨膜增强与否及术者专业(骨科医生与足病医生)均与结局无关;作者建议术前告知军人患者约三分之一可能需永久限制或离队。

要点

  • 现役军人外侧踝关节稳定术后至少2年,67%(84/125)获良好至优秀FADI评分,33%(41/125)为极差至一般。
  • 腓骨骨膜增强组与未增强组良好至优秀比例无显著差异(68%[67/99] vs 65%[17/26];OR 1[95%CI 0至2];p=0.81)。
  • 骨科医生与足病医生手术者的良好至优秀比例无显著差异(66%[62/94] vs 71%[22/31];OR 1[95%CI 1至2];p=0.66)。

核心结论

  • 现役军人外侧踝关节稳定术后至少2年、平均7年的患者报告结局评分远低于平民人群研究报道。
  • 作者认为本研究可能代表最佳情况,因为失访患者多于纳入分析者,且失访患者的手术结果通常更差。
  • 腓骨骨膜增强的添加及术者为骨科医生或足病医生均不能解释上述发现。
  • 鉴于三分之一患者报告极差至一般结果且大量失访,作者推荐术前应据此告知军人患者:术后有三分之一概率需要永久限制或离开军队。
  • 作者认为该发现可能适用于军队外类似活动水平的患者,并质疑这些手术对该类患者的服务效果可能不如既往认为的那样好。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性研究,纳入2007年至2017年间15名术者(6名骨科医生、9名足病医生)实施的502例外侧踝关节稳定术。
  • 排除18例(4%)非现役军人及56例(12%)合并其他可能混杂的足踝手术者;303例(60%)因无法联系、拒绝参与或未完整作答被认定为失访。
  • 最终125例纳入分析,其中99例(79%)行腓骨骨膜增强、26例(21%)未增强;骨科医生完成94例(75%),足病医生完成31例(25%)。
  • 至少随访2年,总体平均随访7年;腓骨骨膜增强组平均7±4年,未增强组6±3年;骨科医生组7±3年,足病医生组7±3年。
  • 通过电话访谈获取术后FADI评分及术后军事能力数据,无术前FADI评分;证据等级为III级治疗性研究。

主要发现

  • 合并两种手术方式,67%(84/125)患者报告良好至优秀结果,33%(41/125)报告极差至一般结果。
  • 腓骨骨膜增强组与未增强组达到FADI良好或优秀的比例无显著差异(68%[67/99] vs 65%[17/26];OR 1[95%CI 0至2];p=0.81)。
  • 骨科医生与足病医生手术者达到FADI良好或优秀的比例无显著差异(66%[62/94] vs 71%[22/31];OR 1[95%CI 1至2];p=0.66)。

临床怎么用

  • 作者推荐术前应告知军人患者:术后有三分之一概率需要永久限制或离开军队。
  • 作者认为该发现可能适用于军队外类似活动水平的患者,并质疑这些手术对该类患者的服务效果可能不如既往认为的那样好。

局限性

  • 失访患者多于纳入分析者(303/502被认定为失访),且失访患者的手术结果通常更差,本研究可能代表最佳情况。
  • 无术前FADI评分。
  • 腓骨骨膜增强与术者专业存在混杂:骨科医生倾向行增强(5名增强 vs 1名未增强),足病医生倾向不行增强(2名增强 vs 7名未增强)。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Ankle instability is common and previous studies have documented greater than 85% good-to-excellent outcomes based upon both patient-reported outcome measures and subjective evaluation of ability to return to previous activity levels after lateral ankle stabilization in the civilian population. However, patient-reported outcomes and performance may differ in the military population. The military oftentimes requires servicemembers to navigate uneven terrain and ladderwells, which can stress ankles differently than in their civilian counterparts. There has been limited evidence regarding patient outcomes after lateral ankle stabilization within a military population and its elucidation is important in optimizing outcomes for our servicemembers. Furthermore, the potential benefit of fibular periosteum augmentation with lateral ankle stabilization procedures in a military population has not been described. The results of using this extra tissue to reinforce the repair are important in determining whether its routine incorporation is indicated in the military. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: In an active-duty military population, we asked: (1) What proportion of patients who underwent lateral ankle stabilization using anatomic repair techniques with or without fibular periosteum augmentation achieved good-to-excellent outcomes based on the Foot and Ankle Disability Index (FADI) score at a minimum follow-up interval of 2 years? (2) Was the proportion of patients who achieved a good-to-excellent FADI score higher among those treated with fibular periosteum augmentation than those treated without? (3) Did the likelihood of achieving a good-to-excellent outcome after lateral ankle stabilization vary based on whether the procedure was performed by a fellowship-trained sports or foot and ankle orthopaedic surgeon versus a podiatrist? METHODS: Between 2007 and 2017, 15 surgeons (six orthopaedic surgeons and nine podiatrists) performed 502 lateral ankle stabilizations. We excluded 4% (18 of 502) of patients because they were not active-duty at the time of surgery, and we excluded 12% (56 of 502) of lateral ankle stabilizations because they were performed as part of other potentially confounding foot or ankle procedures. We considered 60% (303 of 502) as lost to follow-up because the patients could not be contacted at least 2 years after surgery, they declined to participate, or they did not fully answer the questionnaires. This left 125 patients for analysis. Of those, 79% (99 of 125) had a procedure with fibular periosteum augmentation and 21% (26 of 125) had a procedure without augmentation. During the study period, five fellowship-trained orthopaedic foot and ankle surgeons and two podiatrists always used fibular periosteum augmentation. Orthopaedic surgeons performed 75% (94 of 125) of the procedures, and the other 25% (31 of 125) were performed by podiatrists. Whether a servicemember was treated by one specialty or the other was simply based upon whom they were referred to for care. Orthopaedic surgeons tended to perform procedures with augmentation (five with versus one without) and podiatrists tended to perform procedures without augmentation (two with versus seven without). To help account for this confounding factor, we performed separate analyses for procedures performed with versus without augmentation in addition to procedures performed by orthopaedic surgeons versus podiatrists. We retrospectively contacted each patient to obtain their self-reported overall result, FADI outcome score, and postoperative military capabilities. The minimum follow-up duration was 2 years; overall mean follow-up duration was 7 years. The fibular periosteum augmentation group mean follow-up was 7 ± 4 years and without augmentation was 6 ± 3 years. The orthopaedic surgeons group mean follow-up was 7 ± 3 years and the podiatrists group was 7 ± 3 years. We obtained postoperative FADI scores via phone interview along with data regarding the patients' postoperative military capabilities, but did not have preoperative FADI scores. RESULTS: Pooling both surgical treatments, 67% (84 of 125) of the patients reported good-to-excellent results and 33% (41 of 125) reported very poor-to-fair results. We found no difference in the proportion of patients treated with fibular periosteal augmentation who achieved a good or excellent score on the FADI than was observed among the patients treated without periosteal augmentation (68% [67 of 99] versus 65% [17 of 26]; odds ratio 1 [95% CI 0 to 2]; p = 0.81). The proportion of patients who achieved a good or excellent score on the FADI did not differ depending on whether the procedure was performed by an orthopaedic surgeon or a podiatric surgeon (66% [62 of 94] versus 71% [22 of 31]; OR 1 [95% CI 1 to 2]; p = 0.66). CONCLUSION: The patient-reported outcome scores after lateral ankle stabilization in our study of military servicemembers at a minimum of 2 years and a mean of 7 years were far lower than have been reported in studies on civilians. Indeed, our findings may represent a best-case scenario because more patients were lost to follow-up than were accounted for, and in general, surgical results among missing patients are poorer than among those who return for follow-up. Variability in the addition of fibular periosteum augmentation and whether an orthopaedic surgeon or podiatrist performed the procedure did not account for these findings. With one third of patients reporting very-poor-to-fair results after these reconstructions, and many patients lost to follow-up, we recommend surgeons counsel their servicemember patients accordingly before surgery. Specifically, that there is a one third chance they will need permanent restrictions or have to leave the military postoperatively; analogously, we believe that our findings may apply to similarly active patients outside the military, and we question whether these procedures may not be serving such patients as well as previously believed. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Lee C, McQuade MG, Ostrofe AA, et al. Do Mid-term Outcomes of Lateral Ankle Stabilization Procedures Differ Between Military and Civilian Populations? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2021. PMID: 32965094. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000001488

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。