内侧稳定型与非内侧稳定型假体在全膝关节置换术中的临床与患者报告结局:系统综述与Meta分析
该系统综述与Meta分析比较内侧稳定型与非内侧稳定型全膝关节置换术的临床和患者报告结局指标。共纳入21项研究,其中13项用于定量分析。内侧稳定型组遗忘关节评分平均比非内侧稳定型组高13.8分(MD 13.83,P≤.0001,95%CI 8.90-18.76,I²=0%),低于最小临床重要差异14分;术后活动度和牛津膝关节评分差异有统计学意义但无临床意义;膝关节协会评分、膝关节功能评分和WOMAC评分无统计学或临床显著差异。
要点
- 内侧稳定型组遗忘关节评分平均比非内侧稳定型组高13.8分(MD 13.83,95%CI 8.90-18.76),低于最小临床重要差异14分。
- 术后活动度(MD=2.52,P=.05,95%CI -0.03至5.07,I²=85%)和牛津膝关节评分(MD=1.25,P=.02,95%CI 0.17-2.33,I²=27%)差异有统计学意义但无临床意义。
- 膝关节协会评分、膝关节功能评分和WOMAC评分无统计学或临床显著差异。
核心结论
- 内侧稳定型膝关节假体在活动度、牛津膝关节评分、WOMAC、膝关节协会评分和膝关节功能评分方面无临床显著差异。
- 遗忘关节评分显示最大平均差异,需进一步研究。
- 未来研究需使用天花板效应较低的患者报告结局指标如遗忘关节评分。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与Meta分析,2019年10月对多个数据库进行系统检索。
- 共857篇文章,21项研究符合纳入标准,其中13项用于定量分析。
主要发现
- 内侧稳定型组遗忘关节评分平均比非内侧稳定型组高13.8分(MD 13.83,P≤.0001,95%CI 8.90-18.76,I²=0%),低于最小临床重要差异14分。
- 内侧稳定型组与非内侧稳定型组术后活动度差异有统计学意义(MD=2.52,P=.05,95%CI -0.03至5.07,I²=85%),但无临床意义。
- 内侧稳定型组与非内侧稳定型组牛津膝关节评分差异有统计学意义(MD=1.25,P=.02,95%CI 0.17-2.33,I²=27%),但无临床意义。
- 膝关节协会评分、膝关节功能评分和WOMAC评分无统计学或临床显著差异。
局限性
- 遗忘关节评分平均差异13.8分低于最小临床重要差异14分。
- 活动度分析异质性I²=85%。
- 遗忘关节评分显示最大平均差异,需进一步研究。
- 未来研究需使用天花板效应较低的患者报告结局指标如遗忘关节评分。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The aim of this systematic review and meta-analysis was to compare the clinical and patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) of medial stabilized total knee arthroplasty (TKA) with non-medial stabilized TKAs. METHODS: A systematic search of multiple databases was conducted in October 2019. A meta-analysis was conducted for the Knee Society Score (KSS), Knee Society Functional Score (KFS), range of motion (ROM), Oxford Knee Score (OKS), Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index (WOMAC), and Forgotten Joint Score (FJS). RESULTS: A total of 857 articles yielded 21 studies eligible for inclusion with 13 studies used for quantitative analysis. The meta-analysis revealed that the medial stabilized group had a mean FJS that was 13.8 points higher than that of the non-medial stabilized TKA (mean difference [MD]: 13.83, P ≤ .0001, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 8.90-18.76, I2 = 0%) which was less than the minimal clinically important difference of 14. The medial stabilized group also demonstrated a statistically significant difference in the postoperative ROM (MD = 2.52, P = .05, 95% CI: -0.03 to 5.07, I2 = 85%) and OKS when compared with the non-medial stabilized group (MD = 1.25, P = .02, 95% CI: 0.17-2.33, I2 = 27%), but these were not clinically significant. There was no statistically or clinically significant difference in the KSS, KFS, and WOMAC scores. CONCLUSION: Medial stabilized knee prostheses demonstrated no clinically significant differences for the ROM, OKS, WOMAC, KSS, and KFS. The FJS demonstrated the greatest MD and warrants further investigation. Future research is required using patient-reported outcome measures with a lower ceiling effect such as the FJS.
引用
- Tso R, Smith J, Doma K, et al. Clinical and Patient-Reported Outcomes of Medial Stabilized Versus Non-Medial Stabilized Prostheses in Total Knee Arthroplasty: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J Arthroplasty. 2020. PMID: 32978025. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2020.07.086
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。