可能影响全髋关节置换术中髋臼杯位置的全髋关节置换术脊柱骨盆测量的可靠性
本研究评估关节置换外科医生进行脊柱骨盆测量的可靠性。五位关节置换外科医生分两次审阅44张腰椎侧位X线片,测量传统参数(骨盆倾斜角、骨盆入射角、骶骨倾斜角)和新参数(髋臼前倾角、骨盆股骨角),并与经验丰富的工程师测量结果比较。结果显示传统参数观察者间信度好至优(骨盆入射角ICC=0.939),髋臼前倾角仅中等(ICC=0.559);外科医生测量骨盆倾斜角和骶骨倾斜角与工程师测量的相关性极差(ICC均<0)。
要点
- 传统参数中骨盆入射角观察者间信度最高(ICC=0.939),髋臼前倾角仅中等(ICC=0.559)。
- 骨盆倾斜角和骶骨倾斜角外科医生测量与工程师测量相关性极差(ICC均<0)。
- 骨盆股骨角观察者内信度范围0.035至0.828,髋臼前倾角观察者内信度范围0.026至0.545。
核心结论
- 外科医生进行新式放射学测量(髋臼前倾角、骨盆股骨角)的观察者内和观察者间信度低于传统测量。
- 外科医生测量骨盆倾斜角和骶骨倾斜角的可靠性相比使用软件测量的经验丰富评估者极差。
研究设计与样本
- 五位接受过 fellowship 培训或正在培训的关节置换外科医生分两次审阅44张腰椎侧位X线片。
- 所有评估者接受了测量方法指导,但操作经验很少。
- 外科医生测量结果与经验丰富的工程师测量结果进行比较,计算并解释组内相关系数(ICC)。
主要发现
- 5个脊柱骨盆参数中4个的观察者间信度好至优(ICC>0.75),最高为骨盆入射角(ICC=0.939)。
- 髋臼前倾角观察者间信度仅中等(ICC=0.559)。
- 骨盆入射角和骶骨倾斜角的观察者内信度最高,范围从中等到好(ICC=0.718至0.896)。
- 髋臼前倾角的观察者内信度最低(ICC范围0.026至0.545),骨盆股骨角观察者内信度范围0.035至0.828。
- 外科医生测量骨盆倾斜角和骶骨倾斜角与工程师测量比较,相关性极差(ICC均<0)。
关键数值与推荐
- 传统测量包括骨盆倾斜角、骨盆入射角和骶骨倾斜角,新式测量包括髋臼前倾角和骨盆股骨角。
- 观察者间信度:4个参数ICC>0.75,骨盆入射角ICC=0.939,髋臼前倾角ICC=0.559。
- 观察者内信度:骨盆入射角和骶骨倾斜角ICC范围0.718至0.896。
- 观察者内信度:髋臼前倾角ICC范围0.026至0.545,骨盆股骨角ICC范围0.035至0.828。
- 外科医生测量骨盆倾斜角和骶骨倾斜角与工程师测量比较,ICC均<0。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Spinopelvic pathology has been identified as a potential risk factor for instability after total hip arthroplasty. Spinopelvic radiographic parameters used to diagnose spinopelvic disease may also impact optimal cup placement. The purpose of this study was to assess the arthroplasty surgeon accuracy in making spinopelvic measurements. METHODS: Five fellowship-trained or in-training arthroplasty surgeons reviewed 44 lateral lumbar radiographs in two sessions. All evaluators were instructed how to perform measurements but had little experience in doing so. Traditional measurements included the pelvic tilt (PT), pelvic incidence (PI), and sacral slope (SS), and novel measurements included the acetabular ante-inclination (AI) and pelvic femoral angle. Surgeon measurements were compared with those made by experienced engineers. intraclass coefficients (ICCs) were calculated and interpreted. RESULTS: The interobserver reliability for 4 of 5 of the spinopelvic parameters was good to excellent (ICC >0.75) with the highest reliability seen for PI measurement (ICC = 0.939). Only moderate interobserver reliability was observed for AI measurement (ICC = 0.559). Intraobserver reliability was the highest for the PI and SS, ranging from moderate to good (ICC, 0.718 to 0.896). The lowest intraobserver reliability was seen for the AI (ICC range, 0.026 to 0.545) and pelvic femoral angle (ICC range, 0.035 to 0.828). Surgeon measurements of PT and SS were compared with engineer measurements with extremely poor correlation observed (ICC <0 for all). CONCLUSION: Surgeon intraobserver and interobserver reliability in making novel radiographic measurements was low compared with traditional radiographic measurements. Surgeon reliability in making traditional measurements of the PT and SS was very poor compared with experienced assessors using software-based measurements.
引用
- Kleeman-Forsthuber LT, Elkins JM, Miner TM, et al. Reliability of Spinopelvic Measurements That May Influence the Cup Position in Total Hip Arthroplasty. J Arthroplasty. 2020. PMID: 32888750. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2020.06.056
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。