ACGME认证的肌肉骨骼肿瘤学专科培训医师报告的手术量和变异性随时间是否发生变化?
该研究基于2010至2017年ACGME认证的肌肉骨骼肿瘤学专科培训手术记录,评估每名培训医师的手术量变化、2017年不同培训医师间手术量的变异性,以及达到肌肉骨骼肿瘤学会(MSTS)最低手术量阈值的比例。结果显示每名培训医师的中位手术量从2010年的292例(范围131至634例)到2017年的312例(范围174至479例)无变化(p=0.58),但2017年不同培训医师间在小儿肿瘤、保肢并发症、软组织切除重建、骨肉瘤切除保肢及脊柱骶骨骨盆手术方面存在3至10倍的差异,且部分培训医师未达到MSTS推荐的最低手术量标准。
要点
- 2010年至2017年每名培训医师的中位手术量无显著变化(p=0.58)。
- 2017年不同培训医师间手术量差异可达3至10倍。
- 部分培训医师未达到MSTS推荐的最低手术量标准。
核心结论
- 尽管肌肉骨骼肿瘤学培训医师的中位手术量随时间无变化,但在小儿肉瘤、软组织切除重建、保肢手术和脊柱手术方面,培训医师间手术量存在广泛变异性。
研究设计与样本
- 研究检索了2010至2017年ACGME认证的肌肉骨骼肿瘤学专科培训手术记录,所有ACGME认证培训医师均须在毕业前完成病例记录,本研究未纳入非ACGME认证培训项目的手术操作。
- 使用2010至2016年基于解剖部位的手术记录数据,通过描述性统计评估培训医师总体及部位特异的中位手术或患者量,并采用线性回归分析评估中位手术量随时间的变化。
- 使用2017年分类手术记录数据评估培训医师手术量在第10百分位与第90百分位之间的变异性,并将MSTS定义的最低手术量标准与培训医师在第10、30、50(中位)、70和90百分位的手术量进行比较。
主要发现
- 每名培训医师的中位手术量从2010年的292例(范围131至634例)到2017年的312例(范围174至479例)无变化(p=0.58)。
- 基于2017年分类手术记录,不同培训项目间第10百分位与第90百分位培训医师的手术量存在差异:小儿肿瘤手术相差10倍,保肢手术并发症的外科处理相差7倍,软组织切除或重建相差4倍,骨肉瘤切除或保肢手术相差4倍,脊柱、骶骨和骨盆手术相差3倍。
关键数值与推荐
- 对于脊柱和骨盆手术(最低标准=10例),第10百分位培训医师仅完成6例。
- 对于骨肉瘤或保肢手术(最低标准=20例),第10百分位培训医师仅完成14例。
- 对于小儿肿瘤患者(最低标准=15例),第50百分位(13例)及以下的培训医师未达到阈值。
- 对于保肢手术并发症的外科处理(最低标准=5例),第10百分位培训医师仅完成3例。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,尽管认识到培训医师的教育远不止于实施手术,但国家学会已认识到需要使肌肉骨骼肿瘤学培训更加统一或标准化。
- 作者提出,将骨科肿瘤学专科培训限制在高手术量机构、延长培训时间 period 和/或引入亚专科认证可能是定义培训标准化的可能途径。
局限性
- 研究未纳入非ACGME认证培训项目的手术操作,因此无法与这些项目培训的医师进行比较。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: There has been a considerable rise in the number of musculoskeletal/orthopaedic oncology fellowships and subsequently, orthopaedic oncologists, in the nation. National societies have been concerned that the increasing number of orthopaedic oncologists, coupled with a limited number of patients with bone and soft-tissue sarcomas in the country, may have led to an unintended impact on the training spectrum and/or exposure of orthopaedic oncology fellows-in-training over time. Fellows who are unable to gain exposure by operating on varied cancer presentations during training may be less confident in dealing with a wide array of patients in their practice. Despite these concerns, the volume and variability of procedures performed by fellows-in-training remains unknown. Understanding these parameters will be helpful in establishing policies for standardizing training of prospective fellows to ensure they are well-equipped to care for patients with bone and/or soft-tissue sarcomas in the beginning of their career. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Has the median surgical procedure volume per fellow changed over time? (2) How much variability in procedural volume exists between fellows, based on the most recent (2017) Accreditation Council on Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) procedure log data? (3) What proportion of fellows are meeting the minimum procedure volume thresholds, as recommended by the Musculoskeletal Tumor Society (MSTS)? METHODS: The 2010 to 2017 ACGME fellowship procedure logs for musculoskeletal oncology fellowships were retrieved from the council's official website. All fellows enrolled in ACGME-accredited fellowships are mandated to complete case logs before graduation. This study did not include operative procedures performed by fellows in nonACGME-approved fellowship programs. The 2010 to 2016 anatomic site-based procedure log data were used to evaluate fellows' overall and location-specific median operative or patient volume, using descriptive statistics. Linear regression analyses were used to assess changes in the median procedure volume over time. The 2017 categorized procedure log data were used to assess variability in procedure volume between the lowest (10th percentile) and highest (90th percentile) of all fellows. Using 2017 procedure logs, we compared the minimum procedure volume standards, as defined by the MSTS, against the number of procedures performed by fellows across the 10th, 30th, 50th (median), 70th, and 90th percentiles. RESULTS: There was no change in the median (range) procedural volume per fellow from 2010 (292 procedures [131 to 634]) to 2017 (312 procedures [174 to 479]; p = 0.58). Based on 2017 categorized procedure log data, there was considerable variability in procedural volume between the lowest (10th) percentile and highest (90th) percentile of fellows across programs: pediatric oncologic procedures (10-fold difference), surgical management of complications from limb-salvage surgery (sevenfold difference), soft-tissue resections or reconstructions (fourfold difference), bone sarcoma resections or limb-salvage surgery (fourfold difference), and spine, sacrum, and pelvis procedures (threefold difference). A fair proportion of fellows did not meet the minimum procedure volume standards, as recommended by the MSTS across certain categories. For the spine and pelvis (minimum = 10 procedures), fellows in the lowest 10th percentile performed only six procedures. For patients with bone sarcomas or limb salvage (minimum = 20 procedures), fellows in the lowest 10th percentile performed only 14 procedures. For pediatric patients with oncologic conditions (minimum = 15 procedures), fellows in the 50th percentile (13 procedures) and below failed to meet the thresholds. For surgical management of complications from limb-salvage procedures (minimum = five procedures), fellows in the lowest 10th percentile performed only three procedures. CONCLUSION: Although we were encouraged to observe that the median number of procedures performed by musculoskeletal oncology fellows over this time has not changed, we observed wide variability in the procedure volume among fellows for pediatric sarcomas, soft-tissue resection and reconstruction, limb salvage procedures, and spine procedures. We do not know how this compares with fellows trained in nonaccredited fellowship programs. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Although we recognize that the education of fellows entails much more than performing operations, national societies have recognized a need to bring about more uniformity or standardization of training in musculoskeletal oncology. Limiting the number of orthopaedic oncology fellowships to high-volume institutions, expanding the training time period, and/or introducing subspecialty certification may be possible avenues through which standardization of training can be defined.
引用
- Malik AT, Voskuil RT, Baek J, et al. Has the Volume and Variability of Procedures Reported by Fellows in ACGME-accredited Musculoskeletal Oncology Fellowship Programs Changed Over Time? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2021. PMID: 32732738. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000001413
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。