后外侧入路与前外侧入路全髋关节置换术后中期运动参与及功能评分无差异
研究比较后外侧入路(PLA)与前外侧入路(ALA)全髋关节置换术后中期运动参与和功能评分,匹配后每组259例。两组遗忘关节评分(P=0.057)、牛津髋关节评分(P=0.685)、满意度(P=0.369)及轻、中、剧烈运动参与率均无显著差异。结论认为几乎没有证据支持基于运动参与或功能改善来选择入路。
要点
- 匹配后PLA组与ALA组各259例,遗忘关节评分P=0.057、牛津髋关节评分P=0.685、满意度P=0.369均无显著差异。
- 轻(P=0.999)、中(P=0.632)、剧烈运动(P=0.284)参与率两组无显著差异。
- 剧烈运动参与:PLA组50例(19%)vs ALA组61例(24%),下降滑雪22 vs 39、跑步10 vs 19、越野滑雪18 vs 10。
核心结论
- PLA与ALA患者在牛津髋关节评分、遗忘关节评分、满意度或运动参与率方面无显著差异。
- 几乎没有证据支持基于运动参与或功能改善来选择手术入路。
研究设计与样本
- 比较性研究,证据等级III级。
- 1381例因原发性骨关节炎行非骨水泥陶瓷对陶瓷全髋关节置换术的患者中,排除术前或术后下肢手术者503例,余594例经PLA、284例经ALA手术。
- 收集遗忘关节评分、牛津髋关节评分、满意度及22项运动的动机、参与和不适情况,按年龄、性别、体重指数和运动动机进行1:1匹配,得到两组各259例。
主要发现
- 匹配后两组各259例,遗忘关节评分P=0.057、牛津髋关节评分P=0.685、满意度P=0.369均无显著差异。
- 轻(P=0.999)、中(P=0.632)、剧烈运动(P=0.284)参与率两组无显著差异。
- 剧烈运动参与:PLA组50例(19%)vs ALA组61例(24%),其中下降滑雪PLA组22例 vs ALA组39例、跑步PLA组10例 vs ALA组19例、越野滑雪PLA组18例 vs ALA组10例。
- 超过50%有动机的患者参与了其大多数运动项目。
- 严重不适在两组报告相似,主要在跑步(PLA组13例 vs ALA组11例)、团队球类运动(PLA组9例 vs ALA组7例)和下降滑雪(PLA组7例 vs ALA组8例)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Patients undergoing total hip arthroplasty (THA) frequently question surgeons on return to sports. We compared midterm sports participation and functional scores after THA by posterolateral approach (PLA) vs anterolateral approach (ALA). METHODS: Of 1381 patients who underwent uncemented ceramic-on-ceramic THA for primary osteoarthritis, 503 were excluded because of preoperative or postoperative lower limb surgery, leaving 594 operated by PLA and 284 by ALA. Forgotten Joint Score (FJS), Oxford Hip Score (OHS), satisfaction, as well as motivation, participation, and discomfort regarding 22 sports were collected. A 1:1 matching was performed to obtain 2 groups of PLA and ALA patients with similar age, gender, body mass index, and sports motivation. RESULTS: Matching yielded 2 equal groups of 259 patients. There were no significant differences in FJS (P = .057), OHS (P = .685), satisfaction (P = .369), or rates of participation in light (P = .999), moderate (P = .632), or strenuous sports (P = .284). Participation in strenuous sports was reported by 50 PLA (19%) and 61 ALA (24%) patients, with differences for downhill skiing (22 vs 39), running (10 vs 19), and cross-country skiing (18 vs 10). More than 50% of motivated patients practiced most of their sports. Severe discomfort was reported similarly in PLA and ALA patients, mainly during running (13 vs 11), team ball games (9 vs 7), and downhill skiing (7 vs 8). CONCLUSION: There were no significant differences between PLA and ALA patients in terms of OHS, FJS, satisfaction, or sports participation rates. There is little or no evidence to promote an approach based on sports participation or functional improvement. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, comparative study.
引用
- Bonnin MP, Fessy MH, Van Rooij F, et al. No Differences in Midterm Sports Participation or Functional Scores After Total Hip Arthroplasty by Posterolateral Vs Anterolateral Approach. J Arthroplasty. 2020. PMID: 32768259. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2020.07.009
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。