翻修全膝关节置换术中中度胫骨骨缺损不同胫骨重建结构的微动分析
研究在双密度聚氨酯测试块上模拟中度胫骨骨缺损,比较四种胫骨重建结构在模拟下楼梯加载曲线下10000次循环的微动。结果显示带锥形垫块短柄骨水泥结构与不带锥形垫块长柄非骨水泥压配结构微动相似,胫骨锥形垫块可改善骨水泥和非骨水泥结构的压缩和抬升微动。
要点
- 带锥形垫块的短柄骨水泥胫骨结构与不带锥形垫块的长柄非骨水泥压配结构在模拟下楼梯时微动相似。
- 胫骨锥形垫块可改善骨水泥和非骨水泥结构的压缩和抬升微动。
- 带锥形垫块的50毫米短柄骨水泥结构在前方SI位置的微动低于不带胫骨锥形垫块的150毫米非骨水泥压配柄。
核心结论
- 在中度胫骨骨缺损情况下,带锥形垫块的短柄骨水泥胫骨组件在模拟下楼梯过程中实现的微动与不带锥形垫块的非骨水泥胫骨骨干压配植入物相似。
研究设计与样本
- 研究在双密度聚氨酯测试块上铣削出中度胫骨骨缺损,对四种测试结构进行机械测试:单纯短柄骨水泥柄(总长75毫米)、短柄骨水泥柄联合对称型干骺端锥形垫块、无锥形垫块的压配式(总长175毫米)胫骨骨干接合结构、以及带干骺端锥形垫块的同一压配式胫骨结构。
- 在模拟下楼梯加载曲线下进行10000次循环,测量基板/锥形垫块结构相对于胫骨块的微动,采用非配对t检验比较各胫骨结构的峰对峰微动,并进行方差分析作为最终验证。
主要发现
- 骨水泥短柄在加载下表现出与无骨水泥长柄相似的的内翻/外翻位移、内旋/外旋、压缩和抬升微动值。
- 胫骨锥形垫块改善了骨水泥和非骨水泥结构的压缩和抬升微动。
- 带锥形垫块的50毫米短柄骨水泥结构在前方SI位置的微动低于不带胫骨锥形垫块的150毫米非骨水泥压配柄。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The purpose of this study is to compare the micromotion of various tibial reconstruction strategies including short cemented and long cementless stems with or without metaphyseal augmentation. METHODS: A moderate tibial bone defect was milled into dual density polyurethane test blocks. Mechanical testing was performed on 4 test constructs: (1) short cemented stem (75-mm total length) alone; (2) short cemented stem with a symmetric metaphyseal cone; (3) a press-fit (175-mm total length) diaphyseal engaging tibial construct without a cone, and (4) the same press-fit tibial construct with a metaphyseal cone augment. Micromotion of the baseplate/cone construct with respect to the tibia block was measured during a stair descent loading profile for 10,000 cycles. The peak-to-peak micromotion of these various tibial constructs was compared. Unpaired t-tests were used to evaluate differences in peak-to-peak micromotion among the various tibial constructs tested. An analysis of variance was performed for final validation. RESULTS: The cemented short stem demonstrated similar varus/valgus displacement, internal/external rotation, compression, and lift-off micromotion values under loading compared to a cementless long stem. A tibial cone improved compression and lift-off micromotion for both cemented and cementless constructs. A short 50-mm cemented stem with a cone demonstrated a lower micromotion at the anterior SI location compared to a press-fit 150-mm cementless stem without a tibial cone. CONCLUSIONS: A short cemented tibial component with a cone achieved similar micromotion during simulated stair descent compared to a cementless diaphyseal press-fit implant in cases of moderate tibial defects.
引用
- Alipit V, Kirk A, Scholl D, et al. Micromotion Analysis of Various Tibial Constructs in Moderate Tibial Defects in Revision Total Knee Arthroplasty. J Arthroplasty. 2020. PMID: 32798182. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2020.07.013
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。