文献速递脊柱外科骨肿瘤

放射线破坏肿瘤诱导脊髓压迫小鼠模型中脊膜的保护功能

Radiation Disrupts the Protective Function of the Spinal Meninges in a Mouse Model of Tumor-induced Spinal Cord Compression.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2021-01-01

研究用84只10周龄雌性ddY小鼠建立乳腺癌和骨肉瘤诱导的脊髓压迫模型,评估20 Gy照射后6周和12周脊膜屏障抗肿瘤浸润能力及硬脊膜微结构变化。照射后12周,两种肿瘤的硬膜内侵犯评分均高于未照射组;扫描电镜显示照射小鼠硬膜表面缺陷数更多,透射电镜显示胶原纤维排列紊乱。

要点

  • 照射后12周,乳腺癌和骨肉瘤的硬膜内侵犯评分均高于未照射组。
  • 照射后6周,两种肿瘤的硬膜内侵犯评分与未照射组无显著差异。
  • 扫描电镜显示照射小鼠硬膜表面缺陷数中位数2个/图像,高于未照射组的0个。

核心结论

  • 照射后12周可在乳腺癌和骨肉瘤模型中观察到硬膜内肿瘤侵犯及硬脊膜微结构破坏。

研究设计与样本

  • 84只10周龄雌性ddY小鼠随机分为8组,每组计划10至11只,最终每组10只、共80只纳入评估,分别在小鼠乳腺癌(MMT)或小鼠骨肉瘤(LM8)植入前6周或12周接受0 Gy或20 Gy照射。
  • 小鼠在肿瘤生长导致截瘫时被处死,进行组织学评估硬膜内侵犯分级(0至2级),另取12只小鼠行扫描电镜和透射电镜分析硬脊膜微结构。

主要发现

  • MMT植入各组截瘫时间中位数无差异:未照射6周组16天(范围14至17天)vs 照射6周组14天(范围12至18天)vs 未照射12周组16天(范围14至17天)vs 照射12周组14天(范围12至15天),χ2=4.7,p=0.19。
  • LM8植入各组截瘫时间中位数无差异:未照射6周组12天(范围9至13天)vs 照射6周组10天(范围8至13天)vs 未照射12周组11天(范围8至13天)vs 照射12周组9天(范围6至12天),χ2=2.4,p=0.50。
  • MMT植入后6周,照射组与未照射组硬膜内侵犯评分无差异:照射组10只中8只Grade 0、2只Grade 1 vs 未照射组10只全部Grade 0,p=0.17。
  • MMT植入后12周,照射组硬膜内侵犯评分高于未照射组:照射组10只中5只Grade 0、3只Grade 1、2只Grade 2 vs 未照射组10只全部Grade 0,p=0.02。
  • LM8植入后12周,照射组硬膜内侵犯评分高于未照射组:照射组10只中3只Grade 0、3只Grade 1、4只Grade 2 vs 未照射组10只中8只Grade 0、2只Grade 1,p=0.04。

关键数值与推荐

  • 硬膜内侵犯分级:Grade 0为无硬膜内侵犯且硬脊膜完整,Grade 1为硬膜内侵犯但硬脊膜线性连续,Grade 2为硬膜内侵犯且硬脊膜连续性中断。
  • 扫描电镜显示照射小鼠硬膜表面缺陷数中位数2个/图像(范围1至3),大于未照射组的0个,中位数差2个/图像,p=0.002;缺陷大小中位数60 μm(范围30至80 μm)。
  • 观察者间评估硬膜内肿瘤侵犯等级的Fleiss κ系数:MMT组0.94,LM8组0.93;评估硬膜表面缺陷数的观察者间信度1.00。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Recent advances in multidisciplinary treatments for various cancers have extended the survival period of patients with spinal metastases. Radiotherapy has been widely used to treat spinal metastases; nevertheless, long-term survivors sometimes undergo more surgical intervention after radiotherapy because of local tumor relapse. Generally, intradural invasion of a spinal tumor seldom occurs because the dura mater serves as a tissue barrier against tumor infiltration. However, after radiation exposure, some spinal tumors invade the dura mater, resulting in leptomeningeal dissemination, intraoperative dural injury, or postoperative local recurrence. The mechanisms of how radiation might affect the dura have not been well-studied. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: To investigate how radiation affects the spinal meninges, we asked: (1) What is the effect of irradiation on the meningeal barrier's ability to protect against carcinoma infiltration? (2) What is the effect of irradiation on the meningeal barrier's ability to protect against sarcoma infiltration? (3) What is the effect of irradiation on dural microstructure observed by scanning electron microscopy (SEM)? (4) What is the effect of irradiation on dural microstructure observed by transmission electron microscopy (TEM)? METHODS: Eighty-four 10-week-old female ddY mice were randomly divided into eight groups: mouse mammary tumor (MMT) implantation 6 weeks after 0-Gy irradiation (nonirradiation) (n = 11), MMT implantation 6 weeks after 20-Gy irradiation (n = 10), MMT implantation 12 weeks after nonirradiation (n = 10), MMT implantation 12 weeks after 20-Gy irradiation (n = 11), mouse osteosarcoma (LM8) implantation 6 weeks after nonirradiation (n = 11), LM8 implantation 6 weeks after 20-Gy irradiation (n = 11), LM8 implantation 12 weeks after nonirradiation (n = 10), and LM8 implantation 12 weeks after 20-Gy irradiation (n = 10); female mice were used for a mammary tumor metastasis model and ddY mice, a closed-colony mice with genetic diversity, were selected to represent interhuman diversity. Mice in each group underwent surgery to generate a tumor-induced spinal cord compression model at either 6 weeks or 12 weeks after irradiation to assess changes in the meningeal barrier's ability to protect against tumor infiltration. During surgery, the mice were implanted with MMT (representative of a carcinoma) or LM8 tumor. When the mice became paraplegic because of spinal cord compression by the growing implanted tumor, they were euthanized and evaluated histologically. Four mice died from anesthesia and 10 mice per group were euthanized (MMT-implanted groups: MMT implantation occurred 6 weeks after nonirradiation [n = 10], 6 weeks after irradiation [n = 10], 12 weeks after nonirradiation [n = 10], and 12 weeks after irradiation [n = 10]; LM8-implanted groups: LM8 implantation performed 6 weeks after nonirradiation [n = 10], 6 weeks after irradiation [n = 10], 12 weeks after nonirradiation [n = 10], and 12 weeks after irradiation [n = 10]); 80 mice were evaluated. The spines of the euthanized mice were harvested; hematoxylin and eosin staining and Masson's trichrome staining slides were prepared for histologic assessment of each specimen. In the histologic assessment, intradural invasion of the implanted tumor was graded in each group by three observers blinded to the type of tumor, presence of irradiation, and the timing of the surgery. Grade 0 was defined as no intradural invasion with intact dura mater, Grade 1 was defined as intradural invasion with linear dural continuity, and Grade 2 was defined as intradural invasion with disruption of the dural continuity. Additionally, we euthanized 12 mice for a microstructural analysis of dura mater changes by two observers blinded to the presence of irradiation. Six mice (three mice in the 12 weeks after nonirradiation group and three mice in the 12 weeks after 20-Gy irradiation group) were quantitatively analyzed for defects on the dural surface with SEM. The other six mice (three mice in the 12 weeks after nonirradiation group and three mice in the 12 weeks after 20-Gy irradiation group) were analyzed for layer structure of collagen fibers constituting dura mater by TEM. In the SEM assessment, the number and size of defects on the dural surface on images (200 μm × 300 μm) at low magnification (× 2680) were evaluated. A total of 12 images (two per mouse) were evaluated for this assessment. The days from surgery to paraplegia were compared between each of the tumor groups using the Kruskal-Wallis test. The scores of intradural tumor invasion grades and the number of defects on dural surface per SEM image were compared between irradiation group and nonirradiation group using the Mann-Whitney U test. Interobserver reliabilities of assessing intradural tumor invasion grades and the number of dural defects on the dural surface were analyzed using Fleiss'κ coefficient. P values < 0.05 were considered statistically significant. RESULTS: There was no difference in the median (range) time to paraplegia among the MMT implantation 6 weeks after nonirradiation group, the 6 weeks after irradiation group, the 12 weeks after nonirradiation group, and the 12 weeks after irradiation group (16 days [14 to 17] versus 14 days [12 to 18] versus 16 days [14 to 17] versus 14 days [12 to 15]; χ2 = 4.7; p = 0.19). There was also no difference in the intradural invasion score between the MMT implantation 6 weeks after irradiation group and the 6 weeks after nonirradiation group (8 of 10 Grade 0 and 2 of 10 Grade 1 versus 10 of 10 Grade 0; p = 0.17). On the other hand, there was a higher intradural invasion score in the MMT implantation 12 weeks after irradiation group than the 12 weeks after nonirradiation group (5 of 10 Grade 0, 3 of 10 Grade 1 and 2 of 10 Grade 2 versus 10 of 10 Grade 0; p = 0.02). Interobserver reliability of assessing intradural tumor invasion grades in the MMT-implanted group was 0.94. There was no difference in the median (range) time to paraplegia among in the LM8 implantation 6 weeks after nonirradiation group, the 6 weeks after irradiation group, the 12 weeks after nonirradiation group, and the 12 weeks after irradiation group (12 days [9 to 13] versus 10 days [8 to 13] versus 11 days [8 to 13] versus 9 days [6 to 12]; χ2 = 2.4; p = 0.50). There was also no difference in the intradural invasion score between the LM8 implantation 6 weeks after irradiation group and the 6 weeks after nonirradiation group (7 of 10 Grade 0, 1 of 10 Grade 1 and 2 of 10 Grade 2 versus 8 of 10 Grade 0 and 2 of 10 Grade 1; p = 0.51), whereas there was a higher intradural invasion score in the LM8 implantation 12 weeks after irradiation group than the 12 weeks after nonirradiation group (3 of 10 Grade 0, 3 of 10 Grade 1 and 4 of 10 Grade 2 versus 8 of 10 Grade 0 and 2 of 10 Grade 1; p = 0.04). Interobserver reliability of assessing intradural tumor invasion grades in the LM8-implanted group was 0.93. In the microstructural analysis of the dura mater using SEM, irradiated mice had small defects on the dural surface at low magnification and degeneration of collagen fibers at high magnification. The median (range) number of defects on the dural surface per image in the irradiated mice was larger than that of nonirradiated mice (2 [1 to 3] versus 0; difference of medians, 2/image; p = 0.002) and the median size of defects was 60 μm (30 to 80). Interobserver reliability of assessing number of defects on the dural surface was 1.00. TEM revealed that nonirradiated mice demonstrated well-organized, multilayer structures, while irradiated mice demonstrated irregularly layered structures at low magnification. At high magnification, well-ordered cross-sections of collagen fibers were observed in the nonirradiated mice. However, disordered alignment of collagen fibers was observed in irradiated mice. CONCLUSION: Intradural tumor invasion and disruptions of the dural microstructure were observed in the meninges of mice after irradiation, indicating radiation-induced disruption of the meningeal barrier. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: We conclude that in this form of delivery, radiation is associated with disruption of the dural meningeal barrier, indicating a need to consider methods to avoid or limit Postradiation tumor relapse and spinal cord compression when treating spinal metastases so that patients do not experience intradural tumor invasion. Surgeons should be aware of the potential for intradural tumor invasion when they perform post-irradiation spinal surgery to minimize the risks for intraoperative dural injury and spinal cord injury. Further research in patients with irradiated spinal metastases is necessary to confirm that the same findings are observed in humans and to seek irradiation methods that prevent or minimize the disruption of meningeal barrier function.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Shimizu T, Demura S, Kato S, et al. Radiation Disrupts the Protective Function of the Spinal Meninges in a Mouse Model of Tumor-induced Spinal Cord Compression. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2021. PMID: 32858719. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000001449

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。