三种股骨假体在Sawbone模型中假体周围骨折风险的生物力学比较
该研究在复合Sawbone股骨模型中比较Exeter V40、CPT与DePuy C-Stem三种骨水泥型股骨柄扭转到骨折时的生物力学表现,每组26根Sawbone分为3组。CPT与C-Stem的失败旋转角度和失败扭矩均显著低于Exeter,Exeter失败时能量释放率显著更高并导致更多粉碎性骨折;CPT与C-Stem虽更早骨折但为简单骨折型。
要点
- CPT与C-Stem的失败旋转角度和扭矩均显著低于Exeter(P < .01)。
- Exeter失败时能量释放率显著高于CPT与C-Stem,骨折更粉碎。
- CPT与C-Stem虽更早骨折,但骨折形态为简单型、粉碎较少。
核心结论
- CPT与C-Stem植入的股骨虽更早骨折,但呈简单骨折型、粉碎较少。
- 假体设计差异使CPT植入股骨在失效临界点应力高于Exeter与DePuy,可能是CPT假体假体周围骨折风险增加的reason。
研究设计与样本
- 在复合Sawbone模型中比较Exeter V40、CPT与DePuy C-Stem三种骨水泥型股骨柄假体周围骨折的生物力学。
- 26根Sawbone分为3组,分别以Stryker Exeter、Zimmer CPT或DePuy C-Stem骨水泥固定后扭转到骨折。
主要发现
- 与Exeter相比,CPT与C-Stem植入的Sawbone模型在统计学显著更低的旋转角度下发生假体周围骨折(20.1°和26.7° vs 33.6°,P < .01)。
- 与Exeter相比,CPT与C-Stem植入的Sawbone模型在统计学显著更低的扭矩下发生假体周围骨折(124 Nm和143 Nm vs 174 Nm,P < .01)。
- Exeter失败时能量释放率显著高于CPT与C-Stem(61.2 Nm vs 21.8 Nm和38.6 Nm,P < .01),导致更多粉碎性骨折。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The increasing use of orthopedic total hip arthroplasty implants has led to a consequent rise in the incidence of associated periprosthetic fractures (PPFs). Analysis of the National Joint Registry data showed the choice of cemented hip stem influenced the risk of a PPF occurring. However, the effect of implant design in relation to the risk of PPFs has not been investigated. METHODS: The main objective is to compare the biomechanics of PPFs as a failure of the Exeter V40, CPT, and DePuy C-Stem stems in a composite Sawbone model to identify whether a difference in the risk of fracture exists between them. Twenty-six Sawbones were divided into 3 groups, cemented with the Stryker Exeter, Zimmer CPT, or DePuy C-Stem and then torqued to fracture. RESULTS: When compared with the Exeter, the CPT- and C-Stem-implanted Sawbone models would sustain PPFs at a statistically significantly lower rotation to failure (20.1° and 26.7° vs 33.6°, P < .01) and torque to failure (124 Nm and 143 Nm vs 174 Nm, P < .01) values. The energy release rate at failure for the Exeter was significantly higher than that for the CPT and C-Stem (61.2 Nm vs 21.8 Nm and 38.6 Nm, P < .01), which led to more comminution. CONCLUSION: The CPT- and C-Stem-implanted femurs, although fracturing earlier, fractured in a simple pattern with less comminution. The differences in stem design mean higher stress at the critical point of failure in the CPT implanted femur compared with the Exeter and DePuy, which is likely the reason behind the observed increased risk of PPFs with the CPT implant.
引用
- Windell L, Kulkarni A, Alabort E, et al. Biomechanical Comparison of Periprosthetic Femoral Fracture Risk in Three Femoral Components in a Sawbone Model. J Arthroplasty. 2020. PMID: 32826144. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2020.07.061
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。