加拿大及七个加拿大省份的骨质疏松症评分卡
该评分卡评估加拿大及七个省份的骨质疏松症负担与管理,并比较各省护理路径差异。结果显示加拿大在风险算法应用和髋部骨折手术等待时间方面表现较好,但无骨折登记系统,多数省份未将骨质疏松症列为卫生优先事项,诊断、治疗及骨折联络服务可及性存在不公平。
要点
- 加拿大在风险评估算法应用和髋部骨折手术等待时间方面表现良好。
- 加拿大无已建立的骨折登记系统,且多数省份骨质疏松症非官方卫生优先事项。
- 多个省份无注册的骨折联络服务项目,诊断治疗可及性不一致且报销政策与临床指南不符。
核心结论
- 需要政府支持的行动计划来解决加拿大各省患者在诊断、治疗和骨折联络服务项目可及性方面的不公平。
- 进一步描述治疗差距和建立骨折登记系统是提供高质量骨质疏松症护理的关键下一步。
研究设计与样本
- 研究改编欧洲骨质疏松症评分卡(SCOPE),对加拿大及七个省份(不列颠哥伦比亚、阿尔伯塔、萨斯喀彻温、安大略、魁北克、新不伦瑞克和纽芬兰)的骨质疏松症指标进行评分。
- 数据来源于 comprehensive literature review 和与骨质疏松症专家的访谈,共对四个领域(疾病负担、政策框架、服务提供和服务利用)的20个要素进行评分。
- 每个要素评分为红色、黄色或绿色,分别表示高风险、中等风险或低风险;数据不足的要素评分为黑色。
主要发现
- 加拿大在骨质疏松症护理的若干要素上表现良好,包括风险评估算法的高使用率和髋部骨折手术等待时间极短。
- 加拿大没有已建立的骨折登记系统,关于高骨折风险个体仍未接受治疗的报告有限。
- 骨质疏松症在大多数省份不是官方卫生优先事项,政府支持的行动计划和其他骨质疏松症倡议主要局限于安大略和阿尔伯塔。
- 萨斯喀彻温、新不伦瑞克和纽芬兰等省份没有任何注册的骨折联络服务(FLS)项目。
- 诊断和治疗的可及性不一致,报销政策与临床指南不符。
关键数值与推荐
- 评分卡共评估20个要素,覆盖疾病负担、政策框架、服务提供和服务利用四个领域。
- 每个要素评分为红色(高风险)、黄色(中等风险)或绿色(低风险),数据不足评分为黑色。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
UNLABELLED: The scorecard evaluates the burden and management of osteoporosis in Canada and how care pathways differ across Canadian provinces. The results showed there are inequities in patients' access to diagnosis, treatment, and post-fracture care programs in Canada. Interventions are needed to close the osteoporosis treatment gap and minimize these inequities. INTRODUCTION: The purpose of this study was to develop a visual scorecard that assesses the burden of osteoporosis and its management within Canada and seven Canadian provinces. METHODS: We adapted the Scorecard for Osteoporosis in Europe (SCOPE) to score osteoporosis indicators for Canada and seven provinces (British Columbia, Alberta, Saskatchewan, Ontario, Quebec, New Brunswick, and Newfoundland). We obtained data from a comprehensive literature review and interviews with osteoporosis experts. We scored 20 elements across four domains: burden of disease, policy framework, service provision, and service uptake. Each element was scored as red, yellow, or green, indicating high, intermediate, or low risk, respectively. Elements with insufficient data were scored black. RESULTS: Canada performed well on several elements of osteoporosis care, including high uptake of risk assessment algorithms and minimal wait times for hip fracture surgery. However, there were no established fracture registries, and reporting on individuals with high fracture risk who remain untreated was limited. Furthermore, osteoporosis was not an official health priority in most provinces. Government-backed action plans and other osteoporosis initiatives were primarily confined to Ontario and Alberta. Several provinces (Saskatchewan, New Brunswick, Newfoundland) did not have any registered fracture liaison service (FLS) programs. Access to diagnosis and treatment was also inconsistent and reimbursement policies did not align with clinical guidelines. CONCLUSION: Government-backed action plans are needed to address provincial inequities in patients' access to diagnosis, treatment, and FLS programs in Canada. Further characterization of the treatment gap and the establishment of fracture registries are critical next steps in providing high-quality osteoporosis care.
引用
- Kendler DL, Adachi JD, Brown JP, et al. A scorecard for osteoporosis in Canada and seven Canadian provinces. Osteoporos Int. 2020. PMID: 32712739. doi:10.1007/s00198-020-05554-2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。