不同模块化全膝关节翻修假体柄联合骨缺损的体外生物力学比较研究
研究用35根人股骨制作F2a或F3型股骨远端骨缺损,比较不同长度和类型翻修柄(含锥形套)的初始稳定性。结果显示各组相对位移均<40 μm;小缺损中骨水泥长柄与短柄拔出力相似(4583 N vs 4650 N),约为非骨水泥柄(2221 N)的两倍;大缺损中短骨水泥柄加锥形套拔出力最高(5500 N)。
要点
- 所有测试柄的相对位移均<40 μm,初始稳定性良好。
- 小骨缺损中骨水泥长柄与短柄拔出力相似,未见长柄优势。
- 大骨缺损中短骨水泥柄加锥形套拔出力最高(5500 N)。
核心结论
- 所有测试柄均显示较小的相对位移(<40 μm)。
- 在小骨缺损中,骨水泥长柄相比骨水泥短柄无优势。
- 使用锥形套或解剖型锥形柄联合混合骨水泥固定即使对大骨缺损似乎也提供良好稳定性。
- 使用短骨水泥柄(伴或不伴锥形套)可能是全膝关节翻修中对应骨缺损时具有高骨保留潜力的合适选择。
研究设计与样本
- 体外生物力学研究,使用35根人股骨。
- 第1-3组制作Anderson骨科研究所分型F2a型股骨远端骨缺损,第4-6组制作F3型骨缺损。
- 骨水泥固定旋转铰链股骨假体联合不同柄:100 mm或160 mm全长柄、混合骨水泥锥形套、或100 mm定制解剖型锥形柄。
- 按步态下体内负荷加载,测量相对位移评估初始稳定性,并行拔出测试获取构建物初始稳定性参数。
主要发现
- 所有组相对位移均较小且相似(<40 μm)。
- 小缺损中,骨水泥长柄拔出力4583 N与短柄4650 N相似,约为非骨水泥柄2221 N的两倍。
- 大缺损中,短骨水泥柄加锥形套拔出力最高(5500 N)。
- 长非骨水泥柄3324 N与解剖型锥形柄3990 N拔出力相似。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,使用锥形套或解剖型锥形柄联合混合骨水泥固定即使对大骨缺损似乎也提供良好稳定性。
- 作者认为,使用短骨水泥柄(伴或不伴锥形套)可能是全膝关节翻修中对应骨缺损时具有高骨保留潜力的合适选择。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The aim of this study is to investigate the effects of different stem lengths and types including cones on primary stability in revision total knee arthroplasty with different femoral bone defects and fixation methods in order to maximize bone preservation. It is hypothesized that longer stems provide little additional mechanical stability. METHODS: Thirty-five human femurs were investigated. A distal bone defect, Anderson Orthopedic Research Institute classification (s. 33) type-F2a, was created in group 1-3 and type-F3 in group 4-6. A cemented, rotating hinge femoral component was combined with different stems (100 and 160 mm total or hybrid cemented cones, or a 100-mm custom-made anatomical cone stem). The femora were loaded according to in vivo loading during gait. Relative movements were measured to investigate primary stability. Pull-out testing was used to obtain a parameter for the primary stability of the construct. RESULTS: Relative movements were small and similar in all groups (<40 μm). For small defect, the pull-out forces of cemented long (4583 N) and short stems (4650 N) were similar and about twice as high as those of uncemented stems (2221 N). For large defects, short cemented stems with cones showed the highest pull-out forces (5500 N). Long uncemented stems (3324 N) and anatomical cone stems (3990 N) showed similar pull-out forces. CONCLUSION: All tested stems showed small relative movements. Long cemented stems show no advantages to short cemented stems in small bone defects. The use of cones or an anatomical cone stem with hybrid cementation seems to offer good stability even for larger bone defects. The use of a short cemented stem (with or without cone) may be a suitable choice with a high potential for bone preservation in total knee arthroplasty revision with respective bone defects.
引用
- Guttowski D, Polster V, Huber G, et al. Comparative Biomechanical In Vitro Study of Different Modular Total Knee Arthroplasty Revision Stems With Bone Defects. J Arthroplasty. 2020. PMID: 32654944. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2020.06.035
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。