髋关节学会外科医生关于直接前入路全髋关节置换术的调查
该调查向髋关节学会全部112名活跃和资深会员发送在线问卷,71人回复;仅22.5%(16/71)认为循证医学证明直接前入路(DAA)相比其他入路获益显著大于风险,77.5%(55/71)认为DAA缺乏足够证据支持其使用。
要点
- 49.3%(35/71)的受访者过去或现在使用DAA,但其中42.9%(15/35)已放弃。
- 仅22.5%(16/71)认为循证医学证明DAA获益显著大于风险。
- 77.5%(55/71)认为DAA缺乏足够证据支持其使用。
核心结论
- 大多数髋关节学会外科医生认为直接前入路缺乏足够证据支持其使用。
研究设计与样本
- 在线问卷调查髋关节学会全部112名活跃和资深会员,71名会员回复。
主要发现
- 仅16.9%(12/71)的受访者在住院医师期间接受过通用前入路培训,49.3%(35/71)过去或现在临床使用DAA。
- 过去使用过DAA的受访者中42.9%(15/35)在调查时已放弃。
- 仅22.5%(16/71)的受访者认为循证医学证明DAA相比其他入路获益显著大于风险。
- 77.5%(55/71)的髋关节学会外科医生认为DAA缺乏足够证据支持其使用。
关键数值与推荐
- 文献综述发现仅三项随访超过一年的前瞻性随机临床试验比较DAA与其他入路。
- 两项随机试验仅显示术后早期轻微获益,其中一项显示中期结果较差。
- 多数短期随访比较研究显示DAA手术时间更长、失血量更多,许多三个月比较研究显示使用专用牵引床的DAA并发症率更高。
- 并发症包括伤口愈合问题、股外侧皮神经损伤、股骨假体松动和股骨骨折。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: To establish whether there was a consensus among the members of the Hip Society (HS) on the role of direct anterior approach (DAA) contemporary primary total hip arthroplasty (THA). METHODS: An online survey was sent to all 112 active and senior members of the HS, to which 71 members responded. The survey was constructed to determine whether they believed that evidence-based medicine proves, in modern clinical practice, that the DAA has significant benefits compared to risks when contrasted with other approaches. In addition, they were asked if they currently used the DAA. RESULTS: While only 16.9% (12/71) of respondents had been trained in a generic anterior approach during residency, 49.3% (35/71) had used the DAA in their clinical practice in the past or were using it at the present time. Unexpectedly, 42.9% (15/35) of respondents who had used the DAA in the past had abandoned it by the time of this survey. Only 22.5% (16/71) of all respondents believed that evidence-based medicine proves that the DAA has significant benefits compared to risks in contrast to other approaches. CONCLUSION: A comprehensive literature review found only three prospective randomized clinical trials (RCT) comparing the DAA with another approach with greater than one-year follow-up. Two showed minor benefits within the early postoperative period only, and one of those showed poorer mid-term results. Most of the published comparison studies with short follow-up show longer surgical times and greater blood loss for the DAA, and many three-month comparison studies show higher complication rates for the DAA using a proprietary traction table. The complications included problems with wound healing, lateral femoral cutaneous nerve injury, femoral component loosening, and femoral fractures. Because of the lack of evidence from RCTs showing superiority of the DAA over other approaches and reports of higher complications, the opinion of a large majority (77.5%; 55/71) of HS surgeons was that the DAA lacks sufficient evidence to warrant its use. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2020;102-B(7 Supple B):57-61.
引用
- Woolson ST. A survey of Hip Society surgeons concerning the direct anterior approach total hip arthroplasty. Bone Joint J. 2020. PMID: 32600202. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.102B7.BJJ-2019-1493.R1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。