患者报告结局指标用于指导髋膝关节置换转诊
该研究利用英国222933例膝关节置换和209760例髋关节置换患者的现有数据,基于术前牛津膝关节评分(OKS)或牛津髋关节评分(OHS),建立个体术后获得有意义改善的概率模型。有意义的改善定义为OHS提高≥8分、OKS提高≥7分。结果显示,术前评分高于膝关节41分、髋关节40分的患者不太可能从手术中获得有意义改善;结论认为,按作者定义,术前OKS高于41分、OHS高于40分的患者不应常规转诊至二级医疗考虑关节置换。
要点
- 术前OKS高于41分或OHS高于40分的患者不太可能从关节置换中获得有意义改善。
- 有意义的改善定义为OHS提高≥8分、OKS提高≥7分。
- 较低评分下获得改善的概率升高,膝关节最高达88%,髋关节最高达95%。
核心结论
- 按作者对有意义改善的定义,术前OKS高于41分、OHS高于40分的患者不应常规转诊至二级医疗考虑关节置换。
- 采用更低的阈值会逐步增加被转诊者获得有意义获益的概率,但会排除部分有获益潜力的患者。
- 该发现有助于支持基层医疗中转诊至二级医疗的复杂共同决策,以及二级医疗中有经验的临床医生为考虑膝或髋关节置换的患者提供咨询,但不应单独使用。
研究设计与样本
- 利用英国222933例膝关节置换和209760例髋关节置换患者的现有数据,基于术前OKS或OHS建模个体术后获得有意义改善的概率。
- 有意义的改善定义为OHS提高≥8分、OKS提高≥7分。
主要发现
- 术前评分上限阈值(高于此阈值患者不太可能获得任何有意义改善)为膝关节41分、髋关节40分。
- 在较低评分下,获得改善的概率升高,膝关节最高达88%,髋关节最高达95%。
关键数值与推荐
- 有意义的改善:OHS提高≥8分,OKS提高≥7分。
- 术前评分上限阈值:膝关节OKS 41分,髋关节OHS 40分。
- 获得改善的最大概率:膝关节88%,髋关节95%。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,术前OKS高于41分、OHS高于40分的患者不应常规转诊至二级医疗考虑关节置换。
- 作者认为,采用更低阈值会逐步增加被转诊者获得有意义获益的概率,但会排除部分有获益潜力的患者。
- 作者认为,该发现有助于支持基层医疗中转诊至二级医疗的复杂共同决策,以及二级医疗中有经验的临床医生为考虑膝或髋关节置换的患者提供咨询,但不应单独使用。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: To calculate how the likelihood of obtaining measurable benefit from hip or knee arthroplasty varies with preoperative patient-reported scores. METHODS: Existing UK data from 222,933 knee and 209,760 hip arthroplasty patients were used to model an individual's probability of gaining meaningful improvement after surgery based on their preoperative Oxford Knee or Hip Score (OKS/OHS). A clinically meaningful improvement after arthroplasty was defined as ≥ 8 point improvement in OHS, and ≥ 7 in OKS. RESULTS: The upper preoperative score threshold, above which patients are unlikely to achieve any meaningful improvement from surgery, is 41 for knees and 40 for hips. At lower scores, the probability of improvement increased towards a maximum of 88% (knee) and 95% for (hips). CONCLUSION: By our definition of meaningful improvement, patients with preoperative scores above 41 (OKS) and 40 (OHS) should not be routinely referred to secondary care for possible arthroplasty. Using lower thresholds would incrementally increase the probability of meaningful benefit for those referred but will exclude some patients with potential to benefit. The findings are useful to support the complex shared decision-making process in primary care for referral to secondary care; and in secondary care for experienced clinicians counselling patients considering knee or hip arthroplasty, but should not be used in isolation. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2020;102-B(7):941-949.
引用
- Price AJ, Kang S, Cook JA, et al. The use of patient-reported outcome measures to guide referral for hip and knee arthroplasty. Bone Joint J. 2020. PMID: 32600142. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.102B7.BJJ-2019-0102.R2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。