三维打印手持模型能否提高外科医生识别桡骨远端关节内骨折特征的可靠性?
研究连续纳入20例关节内桡骨远端骨折,10名外科医生分别用常规影像和附加三维打印手持模型评估骨折特征、AO/OTA分型及信心。附加三维模型未改善各骨折特征评估的组间可靠性、分型一致性或医生信心。
要点
- 三维打印手持模型未改善桡骨远端关节内骨折特征评估的组间可靠性。
- 附加三维模型未改善AO/OTA分型的一致性。
- 附加三维模型未改善医生评估整体骨折构型的信心。
核心结论
- 附加三维模型未改善外科医生评估关节内桡骨远端骨折特征和分型的组间可靠性。
- 作者认为进一步研究应评估三维打印手持模型对教学外科住院医师和医学学员的附加价值,以明确三维打印在桡骨远端骨折诊疗中的未来角色。
研究设计与样本
- 连续纳入2018年5月至2018年11月期间在一家一级创伤中心治疗的20例关节内桡骨远端骨折。
- 10名常规治疗桡骨远端骨折的参与者中,7名为骨科创伤外科医生,3名为上肢外科医生,完成住院医师培训后经验为1至25年。
- 骨折评估两次,间隔1个月;首次使用X线片及二维和三维CT图像(常规评估),第二次在此基础上附加三维打印手持模型(三维打印手持模型评估)。
- 采用多评估者Fleiss kappa确定评估骨折特征和分型的组间可靠性,采用配对t检验评估对整体骨折分型评估的信心。
- 证据等级为II级,诊断性研究。
主要发现
- 掌侧缘:常规kappa 0.19(95%CI 0.06至0.32) vs 三维手持模型kappa 0.23(95%CI 0.11至0.36),kappa差值0.04(95%CI -0.14至0.22),p=0.66。
- die punch:常规kappa 0.38(95%CI 0.15至0.61) vs 三维手持模型kappa 0.50(95%CI 0.23至0.78),kappa差值0.12(95%CI -0.23至0.47),p=0.52。
- 掌侧月骨面:常规kappa 0.31(95%CI 0.14至0.49) vs 三维手持模型kappa 0.48(95%CI 0.23至0.72),kappa差值0.17(95%CI -0.12至0.46),p=0.26。
- 背侧粉碎:常规kappa 0.36(95%CI 0.13至0.58) vs 三维手持模型kappa 0.31(95%CI 0.11至0.51),kappa差值-0.05(95%CI -0.34至0.24),p=0.74。
- 台阶>2 mm:常规kappa 0.55(95%CI 0.29至0.82) vs 三维手持模型kappa 0.58(95%CI 0.31至0.85),kappa差值0.03(95%CI -0.34至0.40),p=0.87;间隙>2 mm:常规kappa 0.59(95%CI 0.39至0.79) vs 三维手持模型kappa 0.69(95%CI 0.50至0.89),kappa差值0.10(95%CI -0.17至0.37),p=0.48。
关键数值与推荐
- 评估的特定骨折特征包括:掌侧缘骨折、die punch、掌侧月骨面、背侧粉碎、台阶>2 mm和间隙>2 mm。
- 骨折分型采用AO/骨科创伤协会(OTA)分型方案。
- 对整体骨折分型评估的信心采用0至10分量表(0=完全无信心至10=非常有信心)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: For fracture care, radiographs and two-dimensional (2-D) and three-dimensional (3-D) CT are primarily used for preoperative planning and postoperative evaluation. Intraarticular distal radius fractures are technically challenging to treat, and meticulous preoperative planning is paramount to improve the patient's outcome. Three-dimensionally printed handheld models might improve the surgeon's interpretation of specific fracture characteristics and patterns preoperatively and could therefore be clinically valuable; however, the additional value of 3-D printed handheld models for fractures of the distal radius, a high-volume and commonly complex fracture due to its intraarticular configuration, has yet to be determined. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Does the reliability of assessing specific fracture characteristics that guide surgical decision-making for distal radius fractures improve with 3-D printed handheld models? (2) Does surgeon agreement on the overall fracture classification improve with 3-D printed handheld models? (3) Does the surgeon's confidence improve when assessing the overall fracture configuration with an additional 3-D model? METHODS: We consecutively included 20 intraarticular distal radius fractures treated at a Level 1 trauma center between May 2018 and November 2018. Ten surgeons evaluated the presence or absence of specific fracture characteristics (volar rim fracture, die punch, volar lunate facet, dorsal comminution, step-off > 2 mm, and gap > 2 mm), fracture classification according to the AO/Orthopaedic Trauma Association (OTA) classification scheme, and their confidence in assessing the overall fracture according to the classification scheme, rated on a scale from 0 to 10 (0 = not at all confident to 10 = very confident). Of 10 participants regularly treating distal radius fractures, seven were orthopaedic trauma surgeons and three upper limb surgeons with experience levels ranging from 1 to 25 years after completion of residency training. Fractures were assessed twice, with 1 month between each assessment. Initially, fractures were assessed using radiographs and 2-D and 3-D CT images (conventional assessment); the second time, the evaluation was based on radiographs and 2-D and 3-D CT images with an additional 3-D handheld model (3-D printed handheld model assessment). On both occasions, fracture characteristics were evaluated upon a surgeon's own interpretation, without specific instruction before assessment. We provided a sheet demonstrating the AO/OTA classification scheme before evaluation on each session. Multi-rater Fleiss's kappa was used to determine intersurgeon reliability for assessing fracture characteristics and classification. Confidence regarding assessment of the overall fracture classification was assessed using a paired t-test. RESULTS: We found that 3-D printed models of intraarticular distal radius fractures led to no change in kappa values for the reliability of all characteristics: volar rim (conventional kappa 0.19 [95% CI 0.06 to 0.32], kappa for 3-D handheld model 0.23 [95% CI 0.11 to 0.36], difference of kappas 0.04 [95% CI -0.14 to 0.22]; p = 0.66), die punch (conventional kappa 0.38 [95% CI 0.15 to 0.61], kappa for 3-D handheld model 0.50 [95% CI 0.23 to 0.78], difference of kappas 0.12 [95% CI -0.23 to 0.47]; p = 0.52), volar lunate facet (conventional kappa 0.31 [95% CI 0.14 to 0.49], kappa for 3-D handheld model 0.48 [95% CI 0.23 to 0.72], difference of kappas 0.17 [95% CI -0.12 to 0.46]; p = 0.26), dorsal comminution (conventional kappa 0.36 [95% CI 0.13 to 0.58], kappa for 3-D handheld model 0.31 [95% CI 0.11 to 0.51], difference of kappas -0.05 [95% CI -0.34 to 0.24]; p = 0.74), step-off > 2 mm (conventional kappa 0.55 [95% CI 0.29 to 0.82], kappa for 3-D handheld model 0.58 [95% CI 0.31 to 0.85], difference of kappas 0.03 [95% CI -0.34 to 0.40]; p = 0.87), gap > 2 mm (conventional kappa 0.59 [95% CI 0.39 to 0.79], kappa for 3-D handheld model 0.69 [95% CI 0.50 to 0.89], difference of kappas 0.10 [95% CI -0.17 to 0.37]; p = 0.48). Although there appeared to be categorical improvement in kappa values for some fracture characteristics, overlapping CIs indicated no change. Fracture classification did not improve (conventional diagnostics: kappa 0.27 [95% CI 0.14 to 0.39], conventional diagnostics with an additional 3-D handheld model: kappa 0.25 [95% CI 0.15 to 0.35], difference of kappas: -0.02 [95% CI -0.18 to 0.14]; p = 0.81). There was no improvement in self-assessed confidence in terms of assessment of overall fracture configuration when a 3-D model was added to the evaluation process (conventional diagnostics 7.8 [SD 0.79 {95% CI 7.2 to 8.3}], 3-D handheld model 8.5 [SD 0.71 {95% CI 8.0 to 9.0}], difference of score: 0.7 [95% CI -1.69 to 0.16], p = 0.09). CONCLUSIONS: Intersurgeon reliability for evaluating the characteristics of and classifying intraarticular distal radius fractures did not improve with an additional 3-D model. Further studies should evaluate the added value of 3-D printed handheld models for teaching surgical residents and medical trainees to define the future role of 3-D printing in caring for fractures of the distal radius. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level II, diagnostic study.
引用
- Langerhuizen DWG, Doornberg JN, Janssen MMA, et al. Do 3-D Printed Handheld Models Improve Surgeon Reliability for Recognition of Intraarticular Distal Radius Fracture Characteristics? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2020. PMID: 32667759. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000001356
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。