文献速递关节外科

翻修全髋关节服务线的障碍:基于确定性财务模型的外科医生视角

Barriers to Revision Total Hip Service Lines: A Surgeon's Perspective Through a Deterministic Financial Model.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2020-01-01

该研究通过确定性财务模型,比较初次与翻修全髋关节置换术(THA)按每分钟和每日计算的相对价值单位(RVU)补偿。结果显示翻修THA各亚型每分钟RVU均低于初次THA,且专职翻修医生每日潜在RVU损失显著,提示现行CMS报销模式不利于翻修THA服务线发展。

要点

  • 翻修THA各亚型每分钟RVU均低于初次THA,股骨翻修缺陷最大。
  • 专职翻修医生每日潜在RVU较初次服务线损失26%至55%。
  • 现行报销模式可能限制患者获得翻修THA专家服务。

核心结论

  • 基于RVU比较,专职翻修THA服务线可能损失28%至55%的RVU收入,现行CMS报销模式对关节置换外科医生不可行并限制患者获得翻修专家。

研究设计与样本

  • 确定性财务模型,基于2016年1月至2018年6月某学术医疗机构所有初次或翻修THA患者的回顾性数据。
  • 患者按手术分为初次THA、头衬更换、髋臼组件翻修、股骨组件翻修、股骨髋臼联合翻修五组,后两模型加入混合翻修组。
  • 计算各组平均手术时间,并依据2018年CMS分配的RVU费用表赋值,构建三种模型比较RVU。

主要发现

  • 与初次THA相比,按每分钟RVU,头衬更换缺陷4%,髋臼组件翻修缺陷29%,股骨组件翻修缺陷32%,全翻修缺陷27%。
  • 与单手术室初次服务线相比,进行多种翻修THA的医生每日潜在RVU损失26%。
  • 与双手术室初次THA服务相比,翻修医生每日潜在RVU损失55%。

关键数值与推荐

  • 翻修THA约占所有THA的5%至10%。
  • 按每分钟RVU,头衬更换缺陷4%,髋臼翻修缺陷29%,股骨翻修缺陷32%,全翻修缺陷27%。
  • 单手术室比较每日RVU损失26%,双手术室比较每日RVU损失55%。
  • 专职翻修服务线可能损失28%至55%的RVU收入。

临床怎么用

  • 骨科智能体医生应知晓翻修THA的RVU补偿低于初次THA,在服务线规划中考虑财务可持续性。
  • 与医院管理层沟通时,可引用每分钟和每日RVU缺陷数据,争取对翻修THA服务的资源支持。
  • 向患者解释翻修THA专家可及性可能受报销模式影响。

局限性

  • 本研究为基于单中心回顾性数据的确定性财务模型,证据等级为III级经济与决策分析。
  • 模型仅基于RVU和手术时间,未涵盖其他财务或临床因素。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Revision THA represents approximately 5% to 10% of all THAs. Despite the complexity of these procedures, revision arthroplasty service lines are generally absent even at high-volume orthopaedic centers. We wanted to evaluate whether financial compensation is a barrier for the development of revision THA service lines as assessed by RVUs. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: Therefore, we asked: (1) Are physicians fairly compensated for revision THA on a per-minute basis compared with primary THA? (2) Are physicians fairly compensated for revision THA on a per-day basis compared with primary THA? METHODS: Our deterministic financial model was derived from retrospective data of all patients undergoing primary or revision THA between January 2016 and June 2018 at an academic healthcare organization. Patients were divided into five cohorts based on their surgical procedure: primary THA, head and liner exchange, acetabular component revision THA, femoral component revision THA, and combined femoral and acetabular component revision THA. Mean surgical times were calculated for each cohort, and each cohort was assigned a relative value unit (RVU) derived from the 2018 Center for Medicaid and Medicare assigned RVU fee schedule. Using a combination of mean surgical time and RVUs rewarded for each procedure, three models were developed to assess the financial incentive to perform THA services for each cohort. These models included: (1) RVUs earned per the mean surgical time, (2) RVUs earned for a single operating room for a full day of THAs, and (3) RVUs earned for two operating rooms for a full day of primary THAs versus a single rooms for a full day of revision THAs. A sixth cohort was added in the latter two models to more accurately reflect the variety in a typical surgical day. This consisted of a blend of revision THAs: one acetabular, one femoral, and one full revision. The RVUs generated in each model were compared across the cohorts. RESULTS: Compared with primary THA by RVU per minute, in revision THA, head and liner exchange demonstrated a 4% per minute deficit, acetabular component revision demonstrated a 29% deficit, femoral component revision demonstrated a 32% deficit, and full revision demonstrated a 27% deficit. Compared with primary service lines with one room, revision surgeons with a variety of revision THA surgeries lost 26% potential relative value units per day. Compared with a two-room primary THA service, revision surgeons lost 55% potential relative value units per day. CONCLUSIONS: In a comparison of relative value units of a typical two-room primary THA service line versus those of a dedicated revision THA service line, we found that revision specialists may lose between 28% and 55% of their RVU earnings. The current Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services reimbursement model is not viable for the arthroplasty surgeon and limits patient access to revision THA specialists. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, economic and decision analysis.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Feng JE, Anoushiravani AA, Schoof LH, et al. Barriers to Revision Total Hip Service Lines: A Surgeon's Perspective Through a Deterministic Financial Model. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2020. PMID: 32574471. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000001273

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。