9至11岁先天性脊柱侧凸患儿:生长友好手术与后路脊柱融合术孰优?
该回顾性对照研究比较了9至11岁长节段先天性脊柱侧凸患儿接受生长友好手术(12例)与一期后路脊柱融合术(24例)的效果。结果显示后路融合组矫正率更高(46% vs 34%),并发症更少(4/24 vs 7/12),且部分生活质量评分更优,而肺功能无组间差异。
要点
- 后路脊柱融合术矫正率更高(46% vs 34%,p<0.001)。
- 生长友好手术并发症比例更高(7/12 vs 4/24,p=0.03)。
- 两组肺功能无差异,部分生活质量评分 favoring 后路融合。
核心结论
- 对于9至11岁长节段先天性脊柱侧凸且预期固定区域生长潜力有限的患者,后路脊柱融合术可能更优。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性对照研究,纳入2009至2017年单中心9至11岁、三放射软骨开放、随访至骨骼成熟(Risser≥4)的先天性脊柱侧凸患者。
- 生长友好手术组12例(中位年龄9.3岁),后路脊柱融合组按年龄、性别、病理、主弯大小及顶椎位置2:1匹配24例(中位年龄9.8岁)。
主要发现
- 后路融合组末次随访矫正幅度中位数46%(范围28-70)高于生长友好组的34%(范围9-58),中位数差11%(p<0.001)。
- 生长友好组并发症比例7/12高于后路融合组的4/24(p=0.03)。
- 两组肺功能测试无差异。
- 24项早发性脊柱侧凸问卷父母影响评分生长友好组中位60(44-83)低于后路融合组71(55-87),中位数差13(p=0.001)。
- 经济负担评分生长友好组中位44(30-55)低于后路融合组62(53-75),中位数差16(p<0.001);SRS-22自我形象评分生长友好组中位3.8(3.2-4.3)低于后路融合组4.4(4.1-4.6),中位数差0.5(p=0.006)。
关键数值与推荐
- 生长友好手术一般指征:三放射软骨开放、主弯>40°、上下端椎涉及至少8个节段。
- 一期后路脊柱融合术一般指征:主弯>40°、胸椎高度>18 cm。
- 并发症采用手术并发症分级系统评估,包括感染、内固定相关及力线相关并发症。
临床怎么用
- 对于9至11岁长节段先天性脊柱侧凸且预期固定区域生长潜力有限者,可优先考虑一期后路脊柱融合术以获更好矫正并减少并发症。
- 决策时需权衡生长友好手术的多次延长手术负担及其对生活质量的影响。
局限性
- 回顾性研究,生长友好组样本量较小(12例)。
- 证据等级为III级治疗性研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The distraction-based growth-friendly technique has become a mainstay of treatment for young children with long-spanned congenital scoliosis. However, in patients who are 9 years to 11 years old, the choice is much less clear, and posterior spinal fusion is also a potential option. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: Comparing growth-friendly scoliosis surgery and posterior spinal fusion, which technique (1) provides greater correction of spinal deformity, (2) is associated with more surgical complications, and (3) results in greater improvement in pulmonary function tests, health-related quality of life scores, other patient-reported outcomes? METHODS: Between 2009 and 2017, one spinal center performed 212 spinal interventions for scoliosis in patients aged between 9 years and 11 years old and who had open triradiate cartilage, including 40 patients with growth-friendly approaches (34 with growing-rod technique and six with a vertical expandable prosthetic titanium rib) and 172 with one-stage posterior spinal fusion, respectively. During this period, our general indications for using growth-friendly surgery were patients with open triradiate cartilage, major curve higher than 40°, and upper and lower end vertebrae involving at least eight segments. Twelve patients with a median (range) age of 9.3 years (9 to 11) treated with growth-friendly surgery met the following inclusion criteria: (1) had at least two lengthening procedures before definitive spinal fusion along with 2 years of follow-up after definitive spinal fusion; (2) had been followed until skeletal maturity (Risser grade ≥ 4); and (3) with complete radiographic and clinical data (health-related quality of life (HRQoL) and pulmonary function test results) preoperatively and at the latest follow-up. A group of patients between 9 years and 11 years old and underwent one-stage posterior spinal fusion was selected from our database of patients with congenital scoliosis. Our general indications for using one-stage posterior spinal fusion were patients with a major curve greater than 40°, and with thoracic height higher than 18 cm. Sixty-two patients who had open triradiate cartilage and had been followed until skeletal maturity (Risser grade ≥ 4) were accounted for. In this retrospective, controlled study, we matched patients in the posterior spinal fusion group to those 12 patients who had growth-friendly surgery by age, sex, pathologic findings, major curve size, and location of the apex of the major curve (2:1 matching provided 24 patients in the control group). The median (range) age was 9.8 years (9 to 11). We then compared the groups in terms of magnitude of correction and postoperative complications. Surgical complications, including infection, implant-related complications, and alignment-related complications were evaluated and classified using the surgical complications grading system. Pulmonary function tests and HRQoL were also compared between groups. Pulmonary function tests were performed at the same center with a spirometer. HRQoL were assessed by questionnaire, including the 24-item Early-onset Scoliosis questionnaire for parent-reported outcomes and the Scoliosis Research Society-22 questionnaire for patient-reported outcomes. All patients involved in this study gave their informed consent. RESULTS: The posterior spinal fusion group achieved a greater correction magnitude at the latest follow-up (median [range] 46% [28 to 70] versus median 34% [9 to 58], difference of medians = 11%; p < 0.001) than the growth-friendly group. A higher proportion of patients in the growth-friendly group had complications than in the posterior spinal fusion group (7 of 12 versus 4 of 24; p = 0.03). There were no between-group differences in terms of pulmonary function tests. Few differences were found between the groups in terms of 24-item Early-onset Scoliosis parental impact (median [range] 60 [44 to 83] for the growth-friendly group versus median 71 [55 to 87] for the posterior spinal fusion group, difference of medians = 13; p = 0.001), financial burden (median 44 [30 to 55] for the growth-friendly group versus median 62 [53 to 75] for the posterior spinal fusion group, difference of medians = 16; p < 0.001) and the Scoliosis Research Society-22 self-image scores (median 3.8 [3.2 to 4.3] for the growth-friendly group versus median 4.4 [4.1 to 4.6] for the posterior spinal fusion group, difference of medians = 0.5; p = 0.006) at the latest follow-up, and those differences that were observed all favored the posterior spinal fusion group. CONCLUSIONS: In light of the superior deformity correction and fewer observed complications with posterior spinal fusion, and the absence of important differences in validated outcomes scores or pulmonary function tests, posterior spinal fusion might be a better choice for 9- to 11-year-old children with long-spanned congenital scoliosis and limited growth potential in the intended instrumentation area. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.
引用
- Xu L, Sun X, Du C, et al. Is Growth-friendly Surgical Treatment Superior to One-stage Posterior Spinal Fusion in 9- to 11-year-old Children with Congenital Scoliosis? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2020. PMID: 32568886. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000001377
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。