颈间盘置换与融合术后十年就业状况对比
基于FDA IDE随机试验及上市后研究,比较BRYAN颈间盘置换(CDA)与单节段颈椎前路椎间盘切除融合(ACDF)患者术后10年就业状况。CDA组6周复工率49.2%高于ACDF组39.4%(P=0.046),6个月后两组相似;2年后ACDF组就业率下降约10%而CDA组未降,10年时CDA组76.2%对ACDF组64.1%(P=0.057),但因随访丢失率极高差异未能确认。
要点
- CDA组术后6周复工率显著高于ACDF组(49.2% vs 39.4%,P=0.046)。
- 术后6个月两组就业可能性相似,2年后ACDF组就业率下降约10%。
- 10年就业率CDA组76.2%对ACDF组64.1%(P=0.057),高随访丢失率使差异无法确认。
核心结论
- CDA组术后6周复工率高于ACDF组,但6个月时两组无差异。
- 2年后CDA组就业率呈非显著较高趋势,但因随访丢失率极高未能确认。
研究设计与样本
- 基于FDA IDE随机对照试验及上市后扩展研究,比较BRYAN颈间盘置换与单节段ACDF的就业数据。
- 术后定期随访至10年,评估两组患者就业状态。
主要发现
- 术前就业比例两组相当。
- CDA组6周复工率49.2%,ACDF组39.4%(P=0.046)。
- 术后6个月和2年两组就业可能性相似。
- 2年后各时间点ACDF组就业率下降约10%,CDA组未降。
- 10年时CDA组就业率76.2%,ACDF组64.1%(P=0.057)。
关键数值与推荐
- CDA组10年就业影响因素包括术前工作状态、年龄和SF-36精神成分评分;ACDF组未发现显著术前因素。
- 两组复工时间均受术前工作状态影响;ACDF组还受10年随访时达65岁、术前臂痛和NDI评分显著影响。
临床怎么用
- 对于期望早期复工的患者,CDA可能在6周内提供更高的复工率,但需结合长期随访不确定性综合评估。
局限性
- 随访丢失率极高,导致2年后就业率差异无法确认。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY DESIGN: An analysis of employment status data up to 10 years following the Federal Drug Administration (FDA) Investigational Device Exemption (IDE) randomized trial and extension as post-approval study comparing BRYAN cervical disc (Medtronic, Minneapolis, MN) arthroplasty (CDA) versus single-level anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) was performed. OBJECTIVE: Ten-year experience with the BRYAN disc arthroplasty trial provides opportunity to report patient employment data. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: The long-term consequences of arthroplasty remain incomplete, including the occurrence of occupational compromise. METHODS: Patients' employment status were measured at regular intervals in both groups up to 10 years. RESULTS: The preoperative employment status proportion was comparable between investigational (BRYAN CDA) and control (ACDF) groups. In the investigational group, 49.2% returned to work at 6 weeks compared with 39.4% of the control group (P = 0.046). At 6 months and 2 years postoperatively, there was a similar likelihood of active employment in both groups. After 2 years at all time points, 10% drop-off seen in control group employment, but not in investigational group. At 10 years, 76.2% CDA patients were employed to 64.1% ACDF patients (P = 0.057). Preoperative variables influencing work status at 10 years following CDA included: preoperative work status, age, and SF-36 Mental Component Score (SF-36 MCS); whereas, no significant preoperative factor identified with ACDF. Time to return to work was influenced in both groups by preoperative work status; and in the ACDF group: reaching age 65 at 10-year visit, preoperative arm pain and NDI score had significant influences. CONCLUSION: More patients returned to work at 6 weeks after CDA compared with ACDF, although there was no difference by 6 months. After 2 years, a nonsignificant trend toward higher employment rates in the arthroplasty group was evident, but this difference could not be validated due to the very high rate of loss of patients to the follow-up. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 2.
引用
- Badve SA, Florman JE, Levi AD, et al. Employment Status for the First Decade Following Randomization to Cervical Disc Arthroplasty Versus Fusion. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2020. PMID: 32453224. doi:10.1097/BRS.0000000000003565
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。