创新设备未在全膝关节置换术后康复中提供更优结局:四臂随机临床试验结果
该四臂随机临床试验比较了363例初次单侧全膝关节置换术后患者接受四种康复干预(标准固定自行车、可调体重跑台、固定自行车联合模式化电神经肌肉刺激、跑台联合电刺激)的步行速度和KOOS评分。结果显示各干预组在入院、出院及随访时的步行速度和KOOS评分均无统计学或临床意义的差异。作者建议临床医生、支付方和政策制定者鼓励使用最便宜的干预措施,因为各干预措施提供相似的结局。
要点
- 四种术后康复干预在步行速度和KOOS评分上均无统计学或临床意义的差异。
- 各干预组在入院、出院及随访时的结局指标相似。
- 建议使用最便宜的干预措施,因为各干预措施提供相似结局。
核心结论
- 四种康复干预在步行速度和KOOS评分上无统计学或临床意义的差异。
- 临床医生、支付方和政策制定者应鼓励使用最便宜的干预措施,因为各干预措施提供相似结局。
研究设计与样本
- 膝关节置换康复结局研究是一项四臂随机临床试验,在15个门诊康复诊所开展。
- 研究纳入363例初次单侧全膝关节置换患者,每组90-92例。
- 四种干预分别为:固定卧式自行车(对照)、可调体重跑台、固定自行车联合模式化电神经肌肉刺激、跑台联合模式化电神经肌肉刺激。
- 结局指标为治疗出院时和随访时的步行速度和膝关节损伤与骨关节炎结局评分(KOOS)。
主要发现
- 参与者平均年龄约63岁,61%女性,67%白人,67%居家,平均体重指数31.6,61%有私人保险,32%有医疗保险。
- 各干预组在入院和出院时的步行速度相似。
- 各干预组在入院、出院和随访时的KOOS评分相似。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生、支付方和政策制定者可鼓励提供者和患者使用最便宜的干预措施,因为各干预措施提供相似结局。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Orthopedic surgeons face an increasing array of post-TKA (total knee arthroplasty) rehabilitation interventions that entail innovative equipment and devices, but their relative effectiveness remains unknown. The study compared patient outcomes among primary unilateral TKA patients participating in one of 4 post-TKA rehabilitation interventions-a standard-of-care intervention and 3 more recently developed physical therapy interventions. METHODS: The Knee Arthroplasty Rehabilitation Outcomes Study is a 4-arm randomized clinical trial conducted across 15 outpatient rehabilitation clinics. The trial evaluated 4 alternative interventions: (1) a stationary recumbent bike (control intervention); (2) a body weight-adjustable treadmill; (3) a recumbent bike and use of a patterned electrical neuromuscular stimulation device; and (4) a body weight-adjustable treadmill and a patterned electrical neuromuscular stimulation device. The study's outcome measures were patient walking speed and the Knee injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (KOOS) measured at therapy discharge and at follow-up. RESULTS: The study enrolled 363 TKA patients with 90-92 patients in each of the 4 study arms. Participants were similar across the 4 groups: They were about 63 years old, 61% female, 67% white, living at home, overweight (mean body mass index = 31.6), with mostly private insurance (61%) or Medicare (32%). Walking speed was similar at admission and discharge; KOOS scores were similar at admission, discharge, and follow-up across the 4 intervention groups. CONCLUSION: The study found no statistical or clinically meaningful differences across the 4 study arms in walking speed or KOOS outcomes. Clinicians, payers, and policy makers will want to encourage providers and patients to use the least expensive intervention since each provide similar outcomes. TRIAL REGISTRATION: NCT02426190; https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02426190?term=NCT02426190&cntry=US&rank=1.
引用
- DeJong G, Hsieh CJ, Vita MT, et al. Innovative Devices Did Not Provide Superior Total Knee Arthroplasty Outcomes in Post-Operative Rehabilitation: Results From a Four-Arm Randomized Clinical Trial. J Arthroplasty. 2020. PMID: 32360105. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2020.03.048
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。