α-防御素ELISA与侧流试验诊断假体周围感染孰优?前瞻性研究的系统评价与Meta分析
该系统评价与Meta分析仅纳入前瞻性研究,比较α-防御素(AD)ELISA与侧流(LF)试验诊断全关节置换术后假体周围感染(PJI)的效能。共纳入15项研究、1592例操作,结果显示两种试验在合并队列中的敏感性和特异性无差异;但ELISA在全髋关节置换(THA)中的敏感性低于全膝关节置换(TKA)。
要点
- AD ELISA与LF试验在合并THA和TKA队列中诊断PJI的敏感性和特异性无显著差异。
- AD ELISA诊断THA PJI的敏感性为70%,低于TKA的94%(p=0.008)。
- 两种试验特异性均很高(97%与96%),均可用于临床诊断PJI。
核心结论
- AD ELISA与AD LF试验均可用于临床实践,因两者对PJI诊断均具有高敏感性和极高特异性。
- AD ELISA诊断THA PJI的敏感性较低,需谨慎解读,因合并数据异质性高且该组仅纳入两项研究。
研究设计与样本
- 遵循PRISMA指南的系统评价与Meta分析,仅纳入前瞻性研究。
- 共纳入15项研究(AD ELISA 4项;AD LF 11项),涉及1592例操作。
- THA和TKA亚组数据可提取1163例操作(ELISA THA 123例;LF THA 257例;ELISA TKA 228例;LF TKA 555例)。
- 以MSIS标准作为PJI判定标准,采用QUADAS-2评估质量,研究质量总体良好。
- 异质性中至高度,采用双变量随机效应模型,敏感性及特异性比较使用z检验和Meta回归分析。
主要发现
- 合并队列中AD ELISA与AD LF诊断PJI的敏感性分别为90%与86%(p=0.43),特异性分别为97%与96%(p=0.39),均无差异。
- AD ELISA诊断THA与TKA PJI的敏感性分别为70%与94%(p=0.008),存在差异。
- AD LF诊断THA与TKA PJI的敏感性分别为80%与87%(p=0.20),无差异。
- 两个亚组中特异性均无差异。
关键数值与推荐
- PJI判定采用肌肉骨骼感染学会(MSIS)标准。
- AD ELISA合并敏感性90%、特异性97%;AD LF合并敏感性86%、特异性96%。
- AD ELISA在THA中敏感性70%、在TKA中敏感性94%(p=0.008)。
- AD LF在THA中敏感性80%、在TKA中敏感性87%(p=0.20)。
临床怎么用
- AD ELISA和AD LF试验均可用于全关节置换术后疼痛患者的PJI诊断检查。
- 临床解读AD ELISA诊断THA PJI的阴性结果时需谨慎,因其敏感性可能较低。
局限性
- 异质性中至高度。
- AD ELISA用于THA PJI诊断的合并数据仅来自两项研究。
- 最常见偏倚来源为患者选择(如纳入和排除标准不明确)及流程与时机(如穿刺地点和时间不确定)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Periprosthetic joint infection (PJI) following total joint arthroplasty is a serious complication that causes severe morbidity and adds a major financial burden to the healthcare system. Although there is plenty of research on the alpha-defensin (AD) test, a meta-analysis consisting of only prospective studies investigating AD's diagnostic efficacy has not been performed. Additionally, some important subgroups such as THA and TKA have not been separately analyzed, particularly regarding two commonly used versions of the AD test, the laboratory-based (ELISA) and lateral-flow (LF). QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Does the AD ELISA test perform better in the detection of PJI than the AD LF test, in terms of pooled sensitivity and specificity, when including prospective studies only? (2) Are there differences in sensitivity or specificity when using AD ELISA and AD LF tests for PJI diagnosis of THA or TKA PJI separately? METHODS: Following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines, we included prospective studies describing the use of either AD test in the workup of pain after total joint arthroplasty (primary or revision, but not after resection arthroplasty). Fifteen studies (AD ELISA: 4; AD LF: 11) were included, with 1592 procedures. Subgroup data on THA and TKA could be retrieved for 1163 procedures (ELISA THA: 123; LF THA: 257; ELISA TKA: 228; LF TKA: 555). Studies not describing THA or TKA, those not using Musculoskeletal Infection Society (MSIS) criteria as the standard for determining the presence or absence of PJI, those not clearly reporting data for the AD test for the total cohort, and those describing data published in another study were excluded. Studies were not excluded based on follow-up duration; the MSIS criteria could be used within a few weeks, when test results were available. Quality was assessed using the Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies-2 criteria. Study quality was generally good. The most frequent sources of bias were related to patient selection (such as unclear inclusion and exclusion criteria) and flow and timing (uncertainty in place and time of aspiration, for example). Heterogeneity was moderate to high; a bivariate random-effects model therefore was used. To answer both research questions, sensitivity and specificity were calculated for AD ELISA and LF test groups and THA and TKA subgroups, and were compared using z-test statistics and meta-regression analysis. RESULTS: No differences were found between the AD ELISA and the AD LF for PJI diagnosis in the pooled cohorts (THA and TKA combined), in terms of sensitivity (90% versus 86%; p = 0.43) and specificity (97% versus 96%; p = 0.39). Differences in sensitivity for PJI diagnosis were found between the THA and TKA groups for the AD ELISA test (70% versus 94%; p = 0.008); pooled AD LF test sensitivity did not differ between THA and TKA (80% versus 87%; p = 0.20). No differences in specificity were found in either subgroup. CONCLUSIONS: Both the AD ELISA and AD LF test can be used in clinical practice because both have high sensitivity and very high specificity for PJI diagnosis. The lower sensitivity found for diagnosis of PJI in THA for the AD ELISA test must be carefully interpreted because the pooled data were heterogenous and only two studies for this group were included. Future research should analyze TKAs and THAs separately to confirm or disprove this finding. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level II diagnostic study.
引用
- Kuiper JWP, Verberne SJ, Vos SJ, et al. Does the Alpha Defensin ELISA Test Perform Better Than the Alpha Defensin Lateral Flow Test for PJI Diagnosis? A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Prospective Studies. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2020. PMID: 32324670. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000001225
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。