骨科研究中的性别特异性分析现状
该研究回顾了2016年六种骨科期刊中712项临床研究,共涵盖24,607,597例患者,发现仅34%的研究将性别作为多因素统计模型变量,其中39%显示男女结局存在差异。研究强调需明确何时应进行性别特异性分析,以优化骨科个体化治疗。
要点
- 2016年六种骨科期刊中仅34%(241/712)的研究进行了性别特异性分析。
- 进行性别分析的研究中39%(93/241)显示男女结局存在差异。
- 关节置换杂志女性患者比例最高(60%),运动医学杂志最低(44%;p < 0.001)。
核心结论
- 超过三分之一的性别特异性分析显示男女结局存在差异,强调需确定何时此类分析是必要的。
- 目前尚不清楚应有多大比例的骨科研究包含性别特异性分析。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性文献分析,选取六种领先骨科期刊2016年偶数月发表的临床随机对照、队列和病例对照研究。
- 共纳入712项研究,涵盖24,607,597例患者,其中女性占55%(13,565,773/24,607,597)。
主要发现
- 仅34%(241/712)的研究将性别作为多因素统计模型变量。
- 进行性别分析的研究中39%(93/241)显示男女结局存在差异。
- 关节置换杂志女性患者比例最高(60%,9,251,068/15,557,187),运动医学杂志最低(44%,1,027,857/2,357,139;p < 0.001)。
- 骨科亚专科期刊女性患者比例(54%)高于综合骨科期刊(50%;p = 0.04)。
关键数值与推荐
- 纳入标准:2016年偶数月发表的临床随机对照、队列和病例对照研究,且研究人群包含女性。
- 性别特异性分析定义为性别作为多因素统计模型中的变量。
临床怎么用
- 研究者应在个体研究层面把握机会进行适当的性别分析,以确保满足男女健康需求。
- 避免进行不必要或不适当的性别分析。
- 未来研究应确定何时需要性别特异性分析以改善男女骨科损伤的管理。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Orthopaedic studies have reported the prevalence of injuries and outcomes after treatment in men and women patients, and although these differences have been recognized, few studies have evaluated for gender-specific injury patterns, disease progression, and treatment outcomes. A thorough understanding of gender-related differences is important to better individualize treatment and improve outcomes. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: In this study, we sought (1) to determine the proportion of studies published in six orthopaedic journals that provided sex- or gender-specific analyses in 2016 and whether a difference was found in outcomes between men and women and (2) to evaluate whether this proportion varied across several orthopaedic subspecialty journals or between general orthopaedic journals and subspecialty journals. METHODS: Six leading orthopaedic surgery journals were selected for review, including two general orthopaedic journals (Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery and Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research®) and four subspecialty journals (American Journal of Sports Medicine, Journal of Arthroplasty, Journal of Shoulder and Elbow Surgery, and Spine). Journal issues published in the even-numbered months of 2016 were reviewed for clinical randomized controlled, cohort, and case-control studies in which women were a part of the study population. A total of 712 studies evaluating 24,607,597 patients met the criteria and were included in our review of publications from 2016. The selected studies were stratified based on whether gender was a variable in a multifactorial statistical model. Outcomes of interest included the proportion of patients who were women and the presence or absence of a gender-specific analysis. These endpoints were compared between journals. RESULTS: Overall, 55% (13,565,773 of 24,607,597) of patients analyzed in these studies were women. Only 34% (241 of 712) of the studies published in 2016 included gender as variable in a multifactorial statistical model. Of these, 39% (93 of 241) demonstrated a difference in the outcomes between patients who were men and women. The Journal of Arthroplasty had the greatest percentage of patients who were women (60%, 9,251,068 of 15,557,187) and the American Journal of Sports Medicine had the lowest (44%, 1,027,857 of 2,357,139; p < 0.001). Orthopaedic subspecialty journals tended to include a greater percentage of women (54%) than did general orthopaedic journals (50%; p = 0.04). CONCLUSION: Currently, it is unclear what percentage of published orthopaedic studies should include a gender-specific analysis. In the current study, more than one-third of publications that performed a gender-specific analysis demonstrated a difference in outcomes between men and women, thereby emphasizing the need to determine when such an analysis is warranted. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Future studies should aim to determine when a gender-specific analysis is necessary to improve the management of orthopaedic injuries in men and women. It is important for investigators at the individual-study level to look for every opportunity to ensure that both men's and women's health needs are met by performing appropriate by-sex and by-gender analyses, but not to perform them when they are unnecessary or inappropriate.
引用
- Gianakos AL, George N, Pinninti A, et al. Sex- and Gender-specific Analysis in Orthopaedic Studies. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2020. PMID: 32281769. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000001172
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。