挪威关节登记系统1997-2017年全髋关节置换陶瓷部件骨折频率分析
基于挪威关节登记系统1997至2017年146171例初次全髋关节置换数据,其中陶瓷对聚乙烯(CoP)31479例、陶瓷对陶瓷(CoC)5790例,分析陶瓷部件骨折翻修频率及相关因素。10年无陶瓷骨折翻修生存率CoP为99.9%、CoC为99.8%;CoC较CoP骨折风险更高(HR 3.6),氧化铝较氧化铝基复合(AMC)风险更高(调整HR 14.1)。
要点
- 陶瓷轴承骨折罕见,约千分之一,10年无骨折翻修生存率CoP 99.9%、CoC 99.8%。
- CoC较CoP骨折风险高(HR 3.6),氧化铝较AMC高(调整HR 14.1)。
- 男性、28mm头、短头颈长及CoC与陶瓷头骨折翻修风险增加相关。
核心结论
- 陶瓷髋关节轴承骨折罕见,约每1000例接受该轴承的患者中发生1例。
- 为降低风险,术者应避免<32mm股骨头及最短头颈长度,并知晓CoC和男性风险增加。
- AMC轴承风险低于氧化铝陶瓷,但其长期临床磨损性能尚需进一步研究。
研究设计与样本
- 基于挪威关节登记系统1997至2017年146171例初次全髋关节置换的登记研究,报告完整率初次97.3%、翻修93.3%。
- 其中CoP 31479例、CoC 5790例;陶瓷头包括氧化铝28143例、氧化锆1225例、AMC 7901例。
- 采用Kaplan-Meier计算无陶瓷骨折翻修生存率,Cox回归评估相关因素,Poisson回归比较氧化铝与AMC头骨折。
主要发现
- 10年无陶瓷骨折翻修生存率CoP为99.9%(95%CI 99.9-99.9),CoC为99.8%(95%CI 99.6-100),风险髋数分别为7467和1884。
- 陶瓷头骨折风险CoC较CoP高(HR 3.6,95%CI 1.7-7.6)。
- 氧化铝陶瓷头骨折风险高于AMC(调整HR 14.1,95%CI 4.2-47.0;p<0.001)。
- 与陶瓷头骨折翻修相关的因素包括男性(HR 5.2,95%CI 2.6-10.4;p<0.001)、CoC较CoP(HR 3.6,95%CI 1.7-7.6;p=0.001)、28mm较32mm头(HR 2.7,95%CI 1.1-6.4;p=0.02)、短较中等头颈长(HR 2.5,95%CI 1.1-5.3;p=0.03)。
- 50例因陶瓷骨折翻修患者中5例再翻修,5年无再翻修生存率86%(95%CI 74.4-98.0),再翻修原因包括感染2例、再次陶瓷头骨折2例、髋臼杯松动1例。
临床怎么用
- 选择陶瓷轴承时,应避免使用<32mm股骨头及最短头颈长度以降低骨折风险。
- 对男性及使用CoC关节面的患者,应充分告知陶瓷骨折风险相对增加。
- AMC轴承骨折风险低于氧化铝陶瓷,可优先考虑,但需关注其长期磨损性能。
局限性
- AMC轴承的长期临床磨损性能尚未被广泛研究,需进一步评估。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Ceramic bearings in THA have been used to reduce wear and, more recently, to avoid metals in the bearing because of the risk of metal ions adverse effects. Potential disadvantages to ceramic bearings are their brittleness and the ceramic fracture risk, which may lead to revision surgery. The frequency of revision for a fracture ceramic bearing, however, has not been thoroughly studied. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) What is the frequency of revision for a fractured ceramic bearing in ceramic-on-polyethylene (CoP) and ceramic-on-ceramic (CoC) THAs, and is there any difference between alumina ceramics and alumina matrix composites (AMC)? (2) What are the factors associated with this complication? (3) To what extent did the patients who underwent revision for a fractured ceramic bearing undergo subsequent revisions, and for what reason? METHODS: The Norwegian Arthroplasty Register has collected data on hip arthroplasty since 1987 and has a completeness of reporting of 97.3% for primary THAs and 93.3% for revision. From 1997 to 2017, 146,171 primary THAs were registered in the Norwegian Arthroplasty Register. Of these, 31,479 had a CoP articulation and 5790 had a CoC articulation. Two manufacturers produced ceramic heads; one produced 25,678 alumina heads and the other made 2465 alumina heads. All 7901 AMC heads were made by the same manufacturer. Patients who underwent CoP THA were a median (range) of 63 years old (11 to 98) and CoC THA were a median (range) 61 years old (17 to 95); 38% (11,833 of 31,479) of the patients who underwent CoP THA and 41% (2379 of 5790) of the patients who underwent CoC THA were males. Femoral heads made of alumina (n = 28,143), zirconia (n = 1225), and AMC (n = 7901) ceramics were used. To assess revision frequency, we identified patients who underwent revision because of fracture of a ceramic head and/or liner, and calculated the Kaplan-Meier survivorship free of revision for fracture in CoC and CoP articulations. Alumina ceramics and AMC were compared. In terms of factors potentially associated with revision, patient factors (age, sex, and diagnosis), type of articulation (CoP or CoC), femoral head size, and femoral head/neck length were evaluated with Cox regression models to evaluate any association with ceramic fracture and a Poisson regression to compare alumina and AMC head fractures. To evaluate subsequent revisions, hips that were revised for ceramic fracture were evaluated for any further revisions; Kaplan-Meier survivorship free of further revisions was calculated, and revision causes were identified. RESULTS: Survivorship free from revision for ceramic fracture was 99.9% (95% CI 99.9 to 99.9) for CoP bearings, and 99.8% (95% CI 99.6 to 100) for CoC bearings at 10 years, with 7467 and 1884 hips at risk in the two groups, respectively. The hazard ratio for ceramic head fracture was 3.6 (95% CI 1.7 to 7.6) for CoC compared with CoP. The risk of fracture was greater for alumina ceramics than for AMC heads (adjusted HR 14.1 [95% CI 4.2 to 47.0]; p < 0.001). Factors that were associated with revision for fracture of a ceramic head were male sex (HR 5.2 [95% CI 2.6 to 10.4]; p < 0.001), a CoC articulation compared with CoP (HR 3.6 [95% CI 1.7 to 7.6]; p = 0.001), a 28-mm femoral head compared with a 32-mm head (HR 2.7 [95% CI 1.1 to 6.4]; p = 0.02), and short head/neck length compared with a medium head/neck length (HR 2.5 [95% CI 1.1 to 5.3]; p = 0.03). Five of 50 patients undergoing revision for ceramic fracture underwent further revisions, resulting in a 5-year survivorship free from re-revision of 86% (95% CI 74.4 to 98.0). The reasons for re-revision were infection (n = 2), another ceramic head fracture (n = 2), and cup loosening (n = 1). CONCLUSIONS: Fracture of a ceramic THA bearing is rare and seems to affect about one in 1000 patients who receive such a bearing. To minimize the risk of this complication, surgeons should avoid small femoral heads (< 32 mm) and the shortest head/neck lengths. Surgeons should also know that the risk is increased in CoC articulations and in males. Bearings made of AMC appear to be at lower risk than those made from alumina ceramics. However, the long-term clinical wear performance of AMC bearings has not been extensively studied and should be studied further. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.
引用
- Hallan G, Fenstad AM, Furnes O, et al. What Is the Frequency of Fracture of Ceramic Components in THA? Results from the Norwegian Arthroplasty Register from 1997 to 2017. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2020. PMID: 32348085. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000001272
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。