骨质疏松性椎体骨折疼痛定位与实际骨折节段存在差异
该前瞻性观察研究纳入358例椎体骨折患者,比较患者报告的背痛、放射痛及体格检查(脊柱触诊压痛、轴向叩击痛)定位与全脊柱MRI确认的骨折节段的一致性。结果显示患者报告背痛与骨折节段一致性仅20.7%,而放射痛和轴向叩击痛阳性与骨折节段一致性较高,提示症状或体格检查定位骨折需谨慎。
要点
- 患者报告背痛定位与MRI骨折节段一致性低(20.7%,kappa=0.153)。
- 放射痛皮节与骨折节段高度一致(93.4%,kappa=0.924)。
- 轴向叩击痛阳性与骨折节段一致性高(96.4%,kappa=0.963)。
核心结论
- 放射痛或轴向叩击痛阳性有助于确定影像检查的脊柱范围。
- 对于疑似椎体骨折且存在患者报告背痛或触诊压痛阳性者,需全胸腰段MRI扫描。
- 使用症状或体格检查定位椎体骨折需谨慎。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性观察研究,纳入358例椎体骨折患者。
- 以全脊柱磁共振成像确认的骨折节段为参考标准。
- 分析患者报告背痛、放射痛、脊柱触诊压痛、轴向脊柱叩击痛定位与骨折节段的一致性。
主要发现
- 20.7%(74/358)患者报告背痛部位与骨折节段相同(kappa=0.153)。
- 21.2%(76/358)患者伴放射痛,其中93.4%(71/76)放射痛皮节与骨折节段共定位(kappa=0.924)。
- 55.0%(197/358)患者脊柱触诊压痛阳性,其中49.2%(97/197)压痛部位与骨折节段一致(kappa=0.435)。
- 23.2%(83/358)患者轴向脊柱叩击痛阳性,其中96.4%(80/83)叩击痛部位与骨折节段一致(kappa=0.963)。
关键数值与推荐
- 患者报告背痛与骨折节段一致率20.7%(kappa=0.153)。
- 放射痛皮节与骨折节段一致率93.4%(kappa=0.924)。
- 脊柱触诊压痛与骨折节段一致率49.2%(kappa=0.435)。
- 轴向脊柱叩击痛与骨折节段一致率96.4%(kappa=0.963)。
临床怎么用
- 放射痛或轴向叩击痛阳性可用于缩小影像检查的脊柱范围。
- 患者报告背痛或触诊压痛阳性时,应行全胸腰段MRI以避免遗漏骨折。
- 不应仅凭患者报告背痛或触诊压痛定位骨折节段。
局限性
- 原文未报告研究局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
UNLABELLED: Caution is necessary when using symptom or physical examination findings to localize the osteoporotic vertebral fractures (VFs) attributable to the discrepant colocalized relationship. INTRODUCTION: Whether the location of symptoms or physical examination findings delineates the appropriate spinal range for imaging has not been thoroughly investigated for VFs. The present study aims to analyze the consistency between the fractural vertebrae location and the location suggested by patient-reported pain or physical examination findings. METHODS: This observational study, following a prospective design, enrolled 358 patients with VFs. The locations of two symptoms (patient-reported back pain [P-RBP], radiating pain [RP]) and findings from two physical examinations (spinal palpation tenderness [SPT], axial spinal percussion pain [ASPP]) were used to locate the VF segments identified using whole-spine magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). The percentage of agreements and kappa coefficient were calculated. RESULTS: In 20.7% (74/358), the P-RBP site and VF segments were in the same location (kappa = 0.153); 21.2% (76/358) presented with concomitant RP in 93.4% (71/76) of whom the RP dermatome was colocalized with the VF segments (kappa = 0.924); 55.0% (197/358) and 23.2% (83/358) of patients presented with positive SPT and ASPP, respectively; and in 49.2% (97/197) and 96.4% (80/83) of patients with positive SPT (kappa = 0.435) and ASPP (kappa = 0.963), the positive finding and the VF segments were consistently colocalized. CONCLUSIONS: The positive finding of RP or ASPP is useful in determining the spinal range for imaging tests, while an MRI scan covering the whole thoracic and lumbar spine is necessary in VF-suspected patients with P-RBP or positive SPT, indicating that caution is necessary when using symptoms or physical examination findings to localize VFs.
引用
- Jin H, Ma X, Liu Y, et al. Back pain from painful osteoporotic vertebral fractures: discrepancy between the actual fracture location and the location suggested by patient-reported pain or physical examination findings. Osteoporos Int. 2020. PMID: 32346773. doi:10.1007/s00198-020-05434-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。