前交叉韧带股骨隧道位置:221名国际高手术量ACL医生预期与实际位置的分析
该对照实验室研究纳入221名国际高手术量前交叉韧带(ACL)医生,在尸体膝关节标本上比较其预期与实际股骨隧道位置。结果显示经前内侧(AM)入路观察者比经前外侧(AL)入路者更接近预期位置;使用ACL标尺或透视定位者距离预期位置更近,而使用偏移瞄准器或估测者距离更远;钻取技术对距离无影响。
要点
- 经AM入路观察股骨髁间窝侧壁的医生,其隧道位置距预期位置平均9.5,优于AL入路的15.1。
- 使用透视定位者距预期位置最近(平均4.3),使用ACL标尺者平均8.1,均优于偏移瞄准器(14.5)和估测(12.9)。
- 钻取技术(AM入路、经胫骨或由外向内)不影响预期与实际位置的距离。
核心结论
- 经AM入路观察股骨附着点者比经AL入路者更接近预期隧道位置。
- 使用透视定位股骨隧道者距预期位置最近,使用估测或偏移瞄准器者距预期位置最远。
研究设计与样本
- 对照实验室研究,纳入221名国际高手术量ACL医生,在尸体膝关节标本上标记预期股骨隧道位置,随后关节镜下演示实际隧道位置并用透视捕获。
主要发现
- 经AM入路观察者距预期位置平均9.5,经AL入路者平均15.1(P < .0001)。
- 使用偏移瞄准器者平均距离14.5,估测者12.9,ACL标尺者8.1(P < .0001),透视者4.3(P < .0001)。
- 经胫骨钻取者实际位置在髁间窝中更高(P < .042)。
关键数值与推荐
- 按观察入路:AM入路平均距离9.5,AL入路15.1(P < .0001)。
- 按定位策略:偏移瞄准器14.5,估测12.9,ACL标尺8.1(P < .0001),透视4.3(P < .0001)。
- 钻取技术对预期与实际位置距离无显著影响,但经胫骨钻取者实际位置更高(P < .042)。
临床怎么用
- 建议经AM入路观察股骨隧道位置以提高准确性。
- 即使高手术量医生也宜用透视或可塑形ACL标尺验证隧道位置,尤其原股骨残端不可见或翻修病例可优先使用透视。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Femoral tunnels that are not anatomically placed within the native anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) footprint during ACL reconstruction are associated with residual instability, graft rupture, and poor clinical outcomes. Although surgeons may intend to place their femoral tunnels within the native ACL attachment, this is not always achieved. This study assesses the variation between intended and achieved femoral tunnel positions in a large cohort of experienced ACL surgeons. HYPOTHESIS: The accuracy with which experienced ACL surgeons achieve their intended femoral tunnel position is dependent on viewing portal, localization strategy, and drilling technique. STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: A total of 221 surgeons indicated their intended femoral tunnel location on a true lateral radiograph of a cadaveric knee specimen and a scaled photograph. Each surgeon then arthroscopically demonstrated the femoral tunnel on the specimen. The position was captured using fluoroscopy. The Euclidean distance (the straight-line distance between 2 points) between the intended and achieved tunnel positions, referenced to a grid applied to the lateral femoral condyle, was compared. Data were analyzed according to surgeons' viewing portal (anteromedial [AM] or anterolateral [AL]), tunnel localization strategy (offset aimer, estimation from landmarks, ACL ruler, or C-arm fluoroscopy), and stated drilling technique (transtibial, AM portal, or outside-in). RESULTS: Surgeons who viewed the lateral intercondylar notch wall through the AM portal were closer (mean distance, 9.5) to their intended position than those who viewed through the AL portal (mean distance, 15.1; P < .0001). By localization strategy, the mean distance between achieved and intended tunnel positions was greater for surgeons who used an offset aimer (14.5) and estimated the femoral tunnel position (12.9) than for those using a malleable ACL ruler (8.1; P < .0001) and fluoroscopy (4.3; P < .0001). Surgeons' preferred drilling technique (AM portal, transtibial, or outside-in) had no effect on distance between intended and achieved positions. However, the mean achieved position was higher in the intercondylar notch for those using transtibial drilling (P < .042). CONCLUSION: Surgeons using the AM portal to view the femoral attachment site were closer to their intended tunnel position than those who viewed it with the arthroscope in the AL portal. Surgeons who used fluoroscopy to localize femoral tunnel position were the closest to their intended position. Those who used estimation or an offset aimer had the farthest distance between achieved and intended tunnel positions. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Although accurate tunnel placement can be achieved using any method, given the disparity between intended and achieved tunnel positions, it may be advisable, even for high-volume surgeons, to verify the placement of their tunnels using either fluoroscopy or a malleable ACL ruler to ensure that they achieve their intended position. Fluoroscopy may be particularly useful for cases where the native femoral stump is no longer visible and for revisions. Viewing through the AM portal is recommended to aid accuracy of tunnel placement.
引用
- Robinson J, Inderhaug E, Harlem T, et al. Anterior Cruciate Ligament Femoral Tunnel Placement: An Analysis of the Intended Versus Achieved Position for 221 International High-Volume ACL Surgeons. Am J Sports Med. 2020. PMID: 32182091. doi:10.1177/0363546520906158
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。