前交叉韧带重建术后个体侧跳落地时全身运动策略异常但膝关节稳健性正常:有限螺旋轴分析
本研究采用有限螺旋轴分析,对比32例前交叉韧带重建(ACLR)患者与32名匹配对照在侧跳落地时的动态膝关节稳健性及全身运动策略。结果发现ACLR组膝关节稳健性未受影响,但伤侧腿落地时躯干、髋、膝运动策略改变,且膝屈肌力量存在12%的长期缺陷。
要点
- ACLR后侧跳落地时膝关节稳健性未受损,但躯干、髋、膝运动策略改变。
- 伤侧腿落地时ACLR组躯干、髋、膝屈曲增加,髋屈力矩增大而膝屈力矩减小。
- ACLR组跳跃和力量表现可接受(伤健侧比>90%),但膝屈肌力量缺陷12%。
核心结论
- ACLR后侧跳落地时膝关节稳健性未受影响,但存在躯干、髋、膝运动策略改变及膝屈肌力量长期缺陷。
研究设计与样本
- 控制性实验室研究,纳入32例ACLR患者(中位术后16.0个月,采用腘绳肌腱移植)和32名匹配的无症状对照。
- 使用8摄像头运动捕捉系统和2块同步测力台计算标准化反弹侧跳落地时的关节角度和力矩。
- 采用有限螺旋轴方法量化动态膝关节稳健性,以10°瞬时螺旋旋转间隔内膝关节运动偏离屈伸的程度表示(相对额状面和/或横断面运动越大,稳健性越低)。
主要发现
- 两组及双腿在初始接触后第一个10°运动间隔内膝关节稳健性最低,随后逐渐稳定。
- ACLR组伤侧腿落地时,与对侧腿和/或对照组相比,躯干、髋、膝屈曲显著增大,髋屈力矩增大,膝屈力矩减小,膝内旋角度更小而力矩更大。
- ACLR组跳跃和力量表现(伤健侧比>90%)较低但可接受,膝屈肌力量缺陷12%。
临床怎么用
- ACLR后侧跳落地评估应关注全身运动策略而非仅膝关节。
- 两组落地后即刻膝关节稳健性最低,训练中应针对此阶段以降低损伤风险。
- ACLR后需关注膝屈肌力量缺陷(12%)并进行针对性训练。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Atypical knee joint biomechanics after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) are common. It is, however, unclear whether knee robustness (ability to tolerate perturbation and maintain joint configuration) and whole body movement strategies are compromised after ACLR. PURPOSE: To investigate landing control after ACLR with regard to dynamic knee robustness and whole body movement strategies during sports-mimicking side hops, and to evaluate functional performance of hop tests and knee strength. STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: An 8-camera motion capture system and 2 synchronized force plates were used to calculate joint angles and moments during standardized rebound side-hop landings performed by 32 individuals with an ACL-reconstructed knee (ACLR group; median, 16.0 months after reconstruction with hamstring tendon graft [interquartile range, 35.2 months]) and 32 matched asymptomatic controls (CTRL). Dynamic knee robustness was quantified using a finite helical axis approach, providing discrete values quantifying divergence of knee joint movements from flexion-extension (higher relative frontal and/or transverse plane motion equaled lower robustness) during momentary helical rotation intervals of 10°. Multivariate analyses of movement strategies included trunk, hip, and knee angles at initial contact and during landing and hip and knee peak moments during landing, comparing ACLR and CTRL, as well as legs within groups. RESULTS: Knee robustness was lower for the first 10° motion interval after initial contact and then successively stabilized for both groups and legs. When landing with the injured leg, the ACLR group, as compared with the contralateral leg and/or CTRL, demonstrated significantly greater flexion of the trunk, hip, and knee; greater hip flexion moment; less knee flexion moment; and smaller angle but greater moment of knee internal rotation. The ACLR group also had lower but acceptable hop and strength performances (ratios to noninjured leg >90%) except for knee flexion strength (12% deficit). CONCLUSION: Knee robustness was not affected by ACLR during side-hop landings, but alterations in movement strategies were seen for the trunk, hip, and knee, as well as long-term deficits in knee flexion strength. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Knee robustness is lowest immediately after landing for both the ACLR group and the CTRL and should be targeted in training to reduce knee injury risk. Assessment of movement strategies during side-hop landings after ACLR should consider a whole body approach.
引用
- Markström JL, Grip H, Schelin L, et al. Individuals With an Anterior Cruciate Ligament-Reconstructed Knee Display Atypical Whole Body Movement Strategies but Normal Knee Robustness During Side-Hop Landings: A Finite Helical Axis Analysis. Am J Sports Med. 2020. PMID: 32168459. doi:10.1177/0363546520910428
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。