单髁膝关节置换是否影响胫骨骨应变?固定与活动平台设计配对尸体比较
本研究在五对新鲜冰冻全腿尸体标本上模拟下蹲运动,比较活动平台与固定平台单髁膝关节置换(UKA)前后胫骨近端皮质骨应变。两种设计均较原生膝增加骨应变,但活动平台在胫骨内侧平台前外侧区更接近原生膝应变值。
要点
- 活动平台UKA在胫骨旋转及前后、内外侧平移上更接近原生膝运动学。
- 固定与活动平台UKA均增加胫骨前内侧和后侧骨应变,但前外侧区活动平台更接近原生。
- 两种设计在胫骨前内侧和后侧应变增加程度相当,运动学与应变行为无明显关联。
核心结论
- 在体外尸体研究中,活动平台和固定平台UKA均较原生膝增加胫骨骨应变。
- 胫骨内侧平台前外侧区,活动平台UKA后骨应变更接近原生膝,固定平台增加最明显。
- 两种设计在前内侧和后侧胫骨应变增加程度相当,运动学与应变行为之间无明显关联。
研究设计与样本
- 采用五对新鲜冰冻全腿尸体标本(四男一女,年龄64至87岁),在运动学装置上模拟下蹲运动。
- 对股四头肌和腘绳肌施加力,红外摄像系统追踪胫骨和股骨标记点。
- 在胫骨内侧皮质前、后预设位置粘贴堆叠应变片花测量皮质骨应变。
- 配对植入活动平台(UKAMB)和固定平台(UKAFB)假体,通过线性混合模型直接比较同一供体左右膝。
主要发现
- UKAMB在胫骨旋转及前后、内外侧平移方面更接近原生运动学。
- 前内侧区最大主应变峰值:原生膝311 µε ± 190,UKAFB 551 µε ± 381(Cohen's d=1.3),UKAMB 596 µε ± 564(d=1.5)。
- 后侧区最大主应变峰值:原生膝321 µε ± 147,UKAFB 505 µε ± 511(d=1.3),UKAMB 633 µε ± 424(d=2.1)。
- 胫骨内侧平台前外侧区:原生膝563 µε ± 234,UKAFB 1010 µε ± 787(d=1.9),UKAMB 613 µε ± 395(d=0.2)。
关键数值与推荐
- 前内侧区UKAFB和UKAMB的效应量分别为1.3和1.5。
- 后侧区UKAFB和UKAMB的效应量分别为1.3和2.1。
- 前外侧区UKAFB效应量为1.9,UKAMB为0.2。
临床怎么用
- 活动平台UKA在胫骨前外侧区骨应变更接近原生膝,可能有助于减少与异常应变相关的不明原因疼痛。
- 固定平台UKA在前外侧区骨应变增加最明显,临床选择时需考虑该区域应变变化。
- 两种设计在前内侧和后侧应变增加相当,术后疼痛评估需结合具体区域。
局限性
- 本研究为体外尸体研究,样本量较小(五对标本)。
- 模拟下蹲运动不能完全代表体内生理负荷。
- 观察到的皮质应变差异是否与患者不明原因疼痛相关需进一步临床研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Unexplained pain in the medial proximal tibia frequently leads to revision after unicondylar knee arthroplasty (UKA). As one of the most important factors for osteogenic adaptive response, increased bone strain following UKA has been suggested as a possible cause. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: In this study we: (1) performed a cadaver-based kinematic analysis on paired cadaveric specimens before and after mobile-bearing and fixed-bearing UKA; and (2) simultaneously characterized the strain distribution in the anterior and posterior proximal tibia during squatting. METHODS: Five pairs of fresh, frozen full-leg cadaver specimens (four male, one female, 64 years to 87 years) were subjected to a dynamic squatting motion on a kinematic rig to simulate joint loading for a large ROM. Forces were applied to the quadriceps and hamstrings during the simulation while an infrared camera system tracked the location of reflective markers attached to the tibia and femur. Tibial cortical bone strain was measured with stacked strain gauge rosettes attached at predefined anterior and posterior positions on the medial cortex. Pairwise implantation of mobile-bearing (UKAMB) and fixed-bearing implants (UKAFB) allowed a direct comparison of right and left knees from the same donor through a linear mixed model. RESULTS: UKAMB more closely replicated native kinematics in terms of tibial rotation and in AP and mediolateral translation. Maximum principal bone strain values were consistently increased compared with native (anteromedial, mean [± SD] peak strain: 311 µε ± 190 and posterior, mean peak strain: 321 µε ± 147) with both designs in the anteromedial (UKAFB, mean peak strain: 551 µε ± 381, Cohen's d effect size 1.3 and UKAMB, mean peak strain: 596 µε ± 564, Cohen's d effect size 1.5) and posterior (UKAFB, mean peak strain: 505 µε ± 511, Cohen's d effect size 1.3 and UKAMB, mean peak strain: 633 µε ± 424, Cohen's d effect size 2.1) region. However, in the anterolateral region of the medial tibial bone, UKAFB demonstrated the overall largest increase in strain (mean peak strain: 1010 µε ± 787, Cohen's d effect size 1.9), while UKAMB (613 µε ± 395, Cohen's d effect size 0.2) closely replicated values of the native knee (563 µε ± 234). CONCLUSION: In this in vitro cadaver study both UKAMB and UKAFB led to an increase in bone strain in comparison with the native knee. However, in the anterolateral region of the medial tibial plateau, proximal tibial bone strain was lower after UKAMB and UKAFB. Both UKAMB and UKAFB lead to comparable increases in anteromedial and posterior tibial strain in comparison with the native knee. In the anterolateral region of the medial tibial plateau UKA, proximal tibial bone strain was closer to the native knee after UKAMB than after UKAFB. In an attempt to link kinematics and strain behavior of these designs there seemed to be no obvious relation. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Further clinical research may be able to discern whether the observed differences in cortical strain after UKA is associated with unexplained pain in patients and whether the observed differences in cortical bone strain between mobile-bearing and fixed unicondylar designs results in a further difference in unexplained pain.
引用
- Peersman G, Taylan O, Slane J, et al. Does Unicondylar Knee Arthroplasty Affect Tibial Bone Strain? A Paired Cadaveric Comparison of Fixed- and Mobile-bearing Designs. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2020. PMID: 32168072. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000001169
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。