重度膝骨关节炎放射学分类系统与确认软骨丢失的相关性
该前瞻性研究纳入300例因骨关节炎行单侧全膝关节置换术的患者,术中用16个感兴趣区记录全层软骨丢失(FTCL),并与五种术前放射学分类系统(KL、IKDC、Fairbank、Brandt、Ahlbäck)进行相关性分析。结果显示Ahlbäck和KL系统与确认的软骨丢失相关性最强,而IKDC系统观察者间信度最高。
要点
- Ahlbäck和KL系统与术中确认的软骨丢失相关性最强。
- IKDC系统观察者间信度最高,全膝ICC为0.68。
- 内侧间室骨赘对FTCL有高阳性预测值,外侧则无。
核心结论
- Ahlbäck和KL系统与全膝关节置换术中确认的软骨丢失相关性最高。
- IKDC系统观察者间信度最佳,且与内外侧间室FTCL相关性良好,但在更严重疾病中区分度较低。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究纳入300例因骨关节炎行单侧全膝关节置换术的连续患者,平均年龄69岁(范围44至91,标准差9.5),女性178例(59%)。
- 两名盲法检查者独立使用五种常用系统(Kellgren-Lawrence、IKDC、Fairbank、Brandt、Ahlbäck)对术前X线片进行分级,采用组内相关系数(ICC)评估观察者间一致性。
- 术中记录前交叉韧带(ACL)状态及16个感兴趣区全层软骨丢失(FTCL)的存在,采用Spearman相关系数分析放射学分类与FTCL的相关性。
主要发现
- 膝关节平均有6.8个FTCL区域(标准差3.1),最常见于内侧。
- FTCL最常见模式为内侧±髌股(143/300,48%)和三间室(89/300,30%)。
- ACL状态与FTCL模式相关(p=0.023)。
- 所有放射学分类系统均显示中等ICC,IKDC最高:全膝0.68(95%CI 0.60至0.74);内侧间室0.84(95%CI 0.80至0.87);外侧间室0.79(95%CI 0.73至0.83)。
- 与FTCL的相关性Ahlbäck最强(Spearman rho 0.27至0.39),KL次之(0.30至0.33),所有系统均为中等相关;Ahlbäck评分在重度膝骨关节炎中区分度最高。
关键数值与推荐
- IKDC观察者间ICC:全膝0.68(95%CI 0.60至0.74),内侧间室0.84(95%CI 0.80至0.87),外侧间室0.79(95%CI 0.73至0.83)。
- 与FTCL的Spearman相关系数:Ahlbäck rho 0.27至0.39,KL 0.30至0.33。
- FTCL模式:内侧±髌股143/300(48%),三间室89/300(30%)。
- ACL状态与FTCL模式相关p=0.023。
临床怎么用
- 在重度膝骨关节炎评估中,可优先使用Ahlbäck或KL系统以更好地反映软骨丢失程度。
- 若需观察者间一致性的评估,IKDC系统信度最佳,尤其适用于内外侧间室。
- 内侧间室骨赘对FTCL有高阳性预测值,可提示软骨丢失,但外侧间室骨赘无此预测价值。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性内容。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: Although knee osteoarthritis (OA) is diagnosed and monitored radiologically, actual full-thickness cartilage loss (FTCL) has rarely been correlated with radiological classification. This study aims to analyze which classification system correlates best with FTCL and to assess their reliability. METHODS: A prospective study of 300 consecutive patients undergoing unilateral total knee arthroplasty (TKA) for OA (mean age 69 years (44 to 91; standard deviation (SD) 9.5), 178 (59%) female). Two blinded examiners independently graded preoperative radiographs using five common systems: Kellgren-Lawrence (KL); International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC); Fairbank; Brandt; and Ahlbäck. Interobserver agreement was assessed using the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC). Intraoperatively, anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) status and the presence of FTCL in 16 regions of interest were recorded. Radiological classification and FTCL were correlated using the Spearman correlation coefficient. RESULTS: Knees had a mean of 6.8 regions of FTCL (SD 3.1), most common medially. The commonest patterns of FTCL were medial ± patellofemoral (143/300, 48%) and tricompartmental (89/300, 30%). ACL status was associated with pattern of FTCL (p = 0.023). All radiological classification systems demonstrated moderate ICC, but this was highest for the IKDC: whole knee 0.68 (95% confidence interval (CI) 0.60 to 0.74); medial compartment 0.84 (95% CI 0.80 to 0.87); and lateral compartment 0.79 (95% CI 0.73 to 0.83). Correlation with actual FTCL was strongest for Ahlbäck (Spearman rho 0.27 to 0.39) and KL (0.30 to 0.33) systems, although all systems demonstrated medium correlation. The Ahlbäck score was the most discriminating in severe knee OA. Osteophyte presence in the medial compartment had high positive predictive value (PPV) for FTCL, but not in the lateral compartment. CONCLUSION: The Ahlbäck and KL systems had the highest correlation with confirmed cartilage loss at TKA. However, the IKDC system displayed the best interobserver reliability, with favourable correlation with FTCL in medial and lateral compartments, although it was less discriminating in more severe disease. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2020;102-B(3):301-309.
引用
- Keenan OJF, Holland G, Maempel JF, et al. Correlations between radiological classification systems and confirmed cartilage loss in severe knee osteoarthritis. Bone Joint J. 2020. PMID: 32114823. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.102B3.BJJ-2019-0337.R1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。