文献速递运动医学关节外科

无锚钉经骨隧道与锚钉等效经骨隧道肩袖修复匹配队列研究无差异

Anchorless Arthroscopic Transosseous and Anchored Arthroscopic Transosseous Equivalent Rotator Cuff Repair Show No Differences in Structural Integrity or Patient-reported Outcomes in a Matched Cohort.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2020-01-01

回顾性匹配队列研究比较无锚钉经骨隧道(TO)与锚钉等效经骨隧道(TOE)关节镜下肩袖修复,每组50例匹配性别、年龄、吸烟和撕裂大小。术后1年和2年两组ASES评分、肩关节活动度、再撕裂率及手术时间均无显著差异。

要点

  • TO与TOE组术后1年和2年ASES评分及肩关节活动度无显著差异。
  • 两组平均手术时间无显著差异(TO 103±20分钟 vs TOE 99±20分钟)。

核心结论

  • TO与TOE关节镜下肩袖修复在活动度、ASES评分、再撕裂率和手术时间上无差异。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性匹配配对研究,单术者2011年12月至2016年7月共331例肩袖修复,按性别、年龄、吸烟状态和撕裂大小匹配每组50例。

主要发现

  • 术后1年ASES中位数TO 90 vs TOE 88(p=0.44),外旋50° vs 50°(p=0.58),前屈165° vs 165°(p=0.91),外展100° vs 90°(p=0.06)。
  • 术后2年ASES中位数TO 92 vs TOE 90(p=0.84),外旋60° vs 60°(p=0.74),前屈170° vs 170°(p=0.69),外展100° vs 100°(p=0.95)。
  • 平均手术时间TO 103±20分钟 vs TOE 99±20分钟(p=0.45)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 撕裂大小按Cofield分类:小<1 cm,中1-3 cm,大>3-5 cm,巨大>5 cm。

临床怎么用

  • 对于肩袖撕裂,TO与TOE两种关节镜修复技术均可选择,术后2年临床结局和结构完整性相似。

局限性

  • 回顾性研究设计,证据等级Level III,需随机对照试验确认相似性或确定更优方法。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Anchored transosseous equivalent suture-bridge technique (TOE) is widely used for arthroscopic rotator cuff repair. It is unknown how patient outcomes scores, ROM, and integrity of the rotator cuff after repair using this anchored technique compare with those after repair using an anchorless transosseous technique (TO). QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) What are the differences in patient-reported outcomes (American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons [ASES] score) and shoulder ROM between TO and TOE rotator cuff repair techniques at 1 and 2 years after surgery? (2) What is the difference in repair integrity as measured by the re-tear rate, assessed ultrasonographically at 1 year, between these two techniques? (3) What is the difference in procedure duration between the two techniques when performed by a surgeon familiar with each? METHODS: We reviewed 331 arthroscopic rotator cuff repairs performed by one surgeon from December 2011 to July 2016 in this retrospective, matched-pair study. Of these patients, 63% (208 of 331) underwent repair with standard anchored technique (anchors placed in a double-row, TOE manner) and 37% (123 of 331) underwent anchorless TO repair, with the same indications for surgery between groups. Forty-four percent (91 of 208) of patients in the TOE group and 61% (75 of 123) of patients in the TO group met the inclusion criteria. Eighty percent (73 of 91) of patients in the TOE group and 88% (66 of 75) in the TO group had minimum 2-year follow-up. We matched each group to a cohort of 50 patients by sex, age, smoking status, and tear size (by Cofield classification: small, < 1 cm; medium, 1-3 cm; large, > 3-5 cm; or massive, > 5 cm). The resulting cohorts did not differ in mean age (TO, 62 years [range 53-65 years]; TOE, 58 years [range 53-65 years]; p = 0.79), mean BMI value (TO, 30 [range 27-33]; TOE, 29 [range 27-35]; p = 0.97), or dominant arm involvement (TO, 80%; TOE, 78%; p = 0.81). The cohorts were followed for at least 2 years (median, 3.2 years [interquartile range (IQR) 2.2-4.3] for TO and 2.9 years [IQR 2.0-3.5 years] for TOE). ASES scores and ROM were evaluated before surgery and at follow-up visits and were recorded in a longitudinally maintained institutional database. Repair integrity was assessed using ultrasonography at 1 year, as is standard in our practice. For each tear-size group, we calculated the proportion of intact tendon repairs versus the proportion of re-tears. Duration of surgery was recorded for each patient. RESULTS: At 1 year, we observed no difference in median ASES scores (90 [IQR 92-98] for TO and 88 [IQR 72-98] for TOE; p = 0.44); external rotation (50° [IQR 45°-60°) for TO and 50° [IQR: 40°-60°] for TOE; p = 0.58); forward flexion (165° [IQR 160°-170°] for both groups; p = 0.91); or abduction (100° [IQR 90°-100°] for TO and 90° [IQR 90°-100°] for TOE; p = 0.06). Fourteen percent of shoulders (seven of 50) in each treatment group had evidence of re-tear at 1 year (p > 0.99): 0 of 2 small tears in each group, 0 of 7 medium tears in each group, five of 32 large tears in each group, and two of 9 massive tears in each group (all, p > 0.99). At 2 years, we found no differences in median ASES scores (92 [IQR 74-98)] for TO and 90 [IQR 80-100] for TOE; p = 0.84); external rotation (60° [IQR 50°-60°] for both groups; p = 0.74); forward flexion (170° [IQR 160°-170°] for both groups; p = 0.69); or abduction (100° [IQR 90°-100°] for both groups; p = 0.95). We found no differences between groups in mean ± SD procedure time, which was 103 ± 20 minutes for TO repair and 99 ± 20 minutes for TOE repair (p = 0.45). CONCLUSIONS: TO and TOE techniques for arthroscopic rotator cuff repair results in no differences in ROM, ASES scores, re-tear rates, and surgical time. Randomized control trials are needed to confirm these similarities or determine a superior method of repair. Future cost analyses may also help to determine the relative value of each technique. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Srikumaran U, Huish EG, Shi BY, et al. Anchorless Arthroscopic Transosseous and Anchored Arthroscopic Transosseous Equivalent Rotator Cuff Repair Show No Differences in Structural Integrity or Patient-reported Outcomes in a Matched Cohort. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2020. PMID: 32039957. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000001151

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。