EDTA冲洗在大鼠膝关节内植入物污染模型中减少细菌感染的效果
该研究在大鼠膝关节内植入物污染模型中比较了1 mM EDTA溶液与生理盐水、苯扎氯铵和聚维酮碘冲洗减少细菌感染的效果。结果显示EDTA冲洗后关节培养阳性比例低于其他三种冲洗液,且对软骨细胞、成骨细胞和滑膜成纤维细胞无毒性,未引起低钙血症和关节纤维化。
要点
- 在金葡菌和大肠杆菌污染的关节内植入物模型中,1 mM EDTA冲洗后培养阳性关节比例低于生理盐水、苯扎氯铵和聚维酮碘。
- EDTA冲洗对软骨细胞、成骨细胞和滑膜成纤维细胞的存活率与生理盐水无差异。
- EDTA冲洗未引起低钙血症,30份组织学样本中未见关节纤维化。
核心结论
- 在大鼠膝关节内植入物细菌污染模型中,1 mmol/L EDTA溶液术中冲洗在预防手术部位感染方面优于生理盐水、0.03%苯扎氯铵和0.3%聚维酮碘,且未观察到驻留细胞死亡、关节纤维化和低钙血症等不良反应。
研究设计与样本
- 研究建立大鼠膝关节关节内植入物污染模型,雌性Sprague-Dawley大鼠每个处理组n=30,行膝关节切开并植入股骨髓内导丝,导丝有1 mm关节内暴露。
- 植入导丝分别接种金黄色葡萄球菌或大肠杆菌模拟细菌污染,1小时后用生理盐水、苯扎氯铵、聚维酮碘或1 mM EDTA溶液冲洗伤口和植入物。
- 1周后处死动物,取股骨远端、关节囊和植入导丝行标准细菌培养,并比较各冲洗组的培养阳性关节比例。
主要发现
- 金黄色葡萄球菌接种时,EDTA冲洗组培养阳性关节比例为37%(11/30),低于生理盐水组的70%(21/30;p=0.019)、苯扎氯铵组的83%(25/30;p<0.001)和聚维酮碘组的83%(25/30;p<0.001)。
- 大肠杆菌接种时,EDTA冲洗组培养阳性关节比例为13%(4/30),低于生理盐水组的60%(18/30;p<0.001)、苯扎氯铵组的77%(23/30;p<0.001)和聚维酮碘组的80%(24/30;p<0.001)。
- 生理盐水组与EDTA组在软骨细胞存活率(生理盐水:98%±18%;EDTA:105%±18%;p=0.127)、成骨细胞(生理盐水:102±19%,EDTA:103%±14%;p=0.835)和滑膜成纤维细胞(生理盐水:101%±21%,EDTA:110%±13%;p=0.073)方面无差异。
关键数值与推荐
- EDTA冲洗前后血钙水平分别为2.21±0.32 mmol/L和2.23±0.34 mmol/L(p=0.822),未导致低钙血症。
- 30份组织学样本中未观察到关节纤维化。
- EDTA溶液浓度为1 mM;苯扎氯铵浓度为0.03%;聚维酮碘浓度为0.3%。
临床怎么用
- 若其他动物模型证实EDTA溶液的有效性和安全性,则有必要开展临床试验,以确定EDTA冲洗液相较传统冲洗液是否能降低患者假体周围关节感染风险。
局限性
- 研究为大鼠模型,未来需在其他动物模型(如狗和山羊)中重复验证 findings;原文未报告其他局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: To mitigate the possibility of infection after arthroplasty, intraoperative irrigation is essential to remove contaminating bacteria. Previous studies have demonstrated that irrigation with an EDTA solution before wound closure is superior to irrigation with normal saline in removing contaminating bacteria in a rat model of open fractures. However, the effectiveness of an EDTA solution in a model with a contaminated intra-articular implant remains unclear. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Does irrigation with an EDTA solution decrease the proportion of culture-positive joints compared with normal saline, benzalkonium chloride, and povidone iodine? (2) Is an EDTA solution toxic to cells resident in joints including chondrocytes, osteoblasts, and synovial fibroblasts? (3) Does irrigation with an EDTA solution have adverse effects including arthrofibrosis and hypocalcemia? METHODS: We first established a model of contaminated intra-articular implants. Female Sprague-Dawley rats (n = 30 for each treatment group) underwent knee arthrotomy and implantation of a femoral intramedullary wire with 1 mm of intra-articular communication. To simulate bacterial contamination, the inserted wire was inoculated with either Staphylococcus aureus or Escherichia coli. After 1 hour, the wound and implant were irrigated with normal saline, benzalkonium chloride, povidone iodine, or an EDTA solution (1 mM). The animals were euthanized 1 week later, and the distal femur, knee capsule, and implanted wire were harvested for bacterial culture using standard techniques. In this study, we used a well-established animal model of an intra-articular implant and inoculated the implant to simulate the clinical setting of intraoperative contamination. The proportion of culture-positive joints in normal saline, benzalkonium chloride, povidone-iodine, and EDTA groups were compared. The viable cell numbers (chondrocytes, osteoblasts, and synovial fibroblasts) were counted and compared after treatment with either solution. Measurement of blood calcium level and histological examination of the joint were performed to rule out hypocalcemia and arthrofibrosis after EDTA irrigation. RESULTS: With S. aureus inoculation, EDTA irrigation resulted in fewer culture-positive joints than normal saline (37% [11 of 30] versus 70% [21 of 30]; p = 0.019), benzalkonium chloride (83% [25 of 30]; p < 0.001), and povidone iodine (83% [25 of 30]; p < 0.001) irrigation. Likewise, infection rates for implant inoculation with E. coli were also lower in the EDTA irrigation group (13% [four of 30]) than in the normal saline (60% [18 of 30]; p < 0.001), benzalkonium chloride (77% [23 of 30]; p < 0.001), and povidone iodine (80% [24 of 30]; p < 0.001) groups. Between normal saline control and EDTA, there were no differences in cell viability in chondrocytes (normal saline: 98% ± 18%; EDTA: 105% ± 18%; p = 0.127), osteoblasts (normal saline: 102 ± 19%, EDTA: 103 ± 14%; p = 0.835), and synovial fibroblasts (normal saline: 101% ± 21%, EDTA: 110% ± 13%; p = 0.073). EDTA irrigation did not result in hypocalcemia (before irrigation: 2.21 ± 0.32 mmol/L, after irrigation: 2.23 ± 0.34 mmol/L; p = 0.822); and we observed no arthrofibrosis in 30 histologic samples. CONCLUSIONS: In a rat model of a bacteria-contaminated intra-articular implants, intraoperative irrigation with 1 mmol/L of an EDTA solution was superior to normal saline, 0.03% benzalkonium chloride, and 0.3% povidone iodine in preventing surgical-site infection and caused no adverse effects including death of resident cells, arthrofibrosis, and hypocalcemia. Future studies should seek to replicate our findings in other animal models, perhaps such as dog and goat. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: If other animal models substantiate the efficacy and safety of the EDTA solution, clinical trials would be warranted to determine whether the use of an EDTA irrigation solution might reduce the risk of periprosthetic joint infections in patients compared with traditional irrigation solutions.
引用
- Zhu H, Bao B, Wei H, et al. Is EDTA Irrigation Effective in Reducing Bacterial Infection in a Rat Model of Contaminated Intra-articular Knee Implants? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2020. PMID: 32012144. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000001119
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。