初次与翻修髋关节置换中股骨柄断裂的再探讨:Wrightington经验
该回顾性连续研究纳入2008至2018年间在三级单位手术处理的35例股骨柄断裂患者(35髋),评估失败模式与取出远端断裂柄的技术。主要失败机制为远端固定柄的悬臂弯曲疲劳;取出技术包括钻孔2髋、皮质开窗13髋、延长转子截骨5髋和近端取出15髋。结论认为当代断裂柄钻孔技术难以成功,皮质开窗对抛光锥形柄最有效,延长转子截骨可在其他技术失败时使用。
要点
- 远端固定柄断裂主因是悬臂弯曲疲劳。
- 当代断裂柄行钻孔技术 unlikely 成功。
- 皮质开窗最适于取出抛光锥形断裂柄。
核心结论
- 当代断裂股骨柄行钻孔技术不太可能成功。
- 若初次手术曾行转子截骨,可再次用于辅助近端取出。
- 皮质开窗技术对抛光锥形断裂柄最成功,尤其在不计划行延长转子截骨时。
- 延长转子截骨可能在其他技术失败时必要。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性连续研究,纳入2008至2018年间手术处理的35例股骨柄断裂患者(35髋)。
- 患者平均年龄68岁(范围29-93),平均体质指数30(标准差3.8,范围22.5-39)。
- 进行详细影像学评估(Paprosky分型)并收集取出远端断裂柄的手术技术数据。
主要发现
- 35髋包括15髋抛光锥形骨水泥柄、10髋复合梁及其他柄、10髋翻修柄。
- 主要失败机制为远端固定柄的悬臂弯曲疲劳。
- 取出远端片段技术:钻孔2髋、皮质开窗13髋、延长转子截骨5髋、近端取出15髋。
临床怎么用
- 面对当代断裂柄,不宜首选钻孔技术。
- 若初次手术曾行转子截骨,可再利用以辅助近端取出。
- 皮质开窗适用于抛光锥形断裂柄,尤其不计划延长转子截骨时。
- 环钻可用于取出较长非骨水泥柄。
- 其他技术失败时可考虑延长转子截骨。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The aim of this study is to present our experience in managing fractured femoral stems over the last 10 years for both primary and revision stems at our tertiary unit focusing on modes of failure and operative techniques. METHODS: This is a retrospective consecutive study of all patients with fractured femoral stems that were operatively managed in our unit between 2008 and 2018. Detailed radiographic evaluation (Paprosky classification) was undertaken and data collected on operative techniques used to extract distal fractured stem fragments. RESULTS: Thirty-five patients (35 hips) were included (25 men/10 women) with average age at time of presentation of 68 years (range, 29-93). Average body mass index was 30 (standard deviation, 3.8; range, 22.5-39). There were variety of stems both contemporary and historical, primary and revision cases (15 hips polished tapered cemented stems, 10 hips composite beam and miscellaneous stems, and 10 revision hip stems). The predominant mechanism of failure was fatigue due to cantilever bending in distally fixed stems. Surgical techniques used to extract distal fragment were drilling technique in 2 hips, cortical window in 13 hips, extended trochanteric osteotomy (ETO) in 5 hips, and proximal extraction in 15 hips. CONCLUSION: When faced with a contemporary fractured stem, drilling techniques into the distal fragment are unlikely to succeed. If a trochanteric osteotomy had been used at time of index surgery, this could be used again to aid proximal extraction with conventional revision instrumentations. The cortical window technique is useful but surgically demanding technique that is most successful in extracting polished tapered fractured stems particularly when an ETO is not planned for femoral reconstruction. Use of trephines can be useful for removal of longer, uncemented stems. Finally, an ETO might be necessary when other techniques have failed.
引用
- Matar HE, Selvaratnam V, Board TN, et al. Fractured Femoral Stems in Primary and Revision Hip Arthroplasties Revisited: Wrightington Experience. J Arthroplasty. 2020. PMID: 32014380. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2020.01.020
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。