全髋关节置换固定技术十年变迁:非骨水泥悖论再审视
该研究汇总了2010至2017年十个国家关节登记数据,发现初次全髋关节置换中非骨水泥固定使用率在不同国家间差异很大(24%至71%),且变化趋势不一。在75岁以上患者中,多数登记显示骨水泥固定的翻修风险低于非骨水泥固定。
要点
- 各国非骨水泥固定使用率差异显著,从瑞典24%到丹麦71%。
- 75岁以上患者中,多数登记显示骨水泥固定翻修风险更低。
- 芬兰75岁以上患者非骨水泥使用率从2010年43%降至2017年24%。
核心结论
- 研究结果应反馈于医疗政策,引导医生选择正确的植入物固定方式,尤其对75岁以上患者,以降低翻修风险并提高初次全髋关节置换的长期生存率。
- 股骨柄固定可能是老年患者最重要的翻修风险因素,未来研究应探讨这一方面。
研究设计与样本
- 研究提取了2010至2017年间以英文或斯堪的纳维亚语言发表、报告数据至少3年的国家髋关节置换登记年度报告,纳入澳大利亚、丹麦、英格兰-威尔士、芬兰、荷兰、新西兰、罗马尼亚、挪威、瑞典和瑞士。
- 数据直接取自登记库,未进行再分析,翻修风险以风险比、每100组件年发生率或Kaplan-Meier估计值呈现,未跨登记库合并数据。
主要发现
- 初次全髋关节置换中非骨水泥固定的当前使用率在瑞典为24%,在丹麦为71%。
- 挪威、丹麦和瑞典报告非骨水泥固定使用增加,而英格兰-威尔士、澳大利亚、新西兰和芬兰报告减少。
- 在75岁以上患者中,荷兰、瑞典、新西兰和英格兰-威尔士的非骨水泥固定使用稳定,丹麦和澳大利亚仍在增加,芬兰从2010年的43%降至2017年的24%。
- 与未骨水泥固定相比,除芬兰登记库中最年长男性外,所有调查登记库中75岁以上患者使用骨水泥固定的翻修风险更低;在芬兰该组中,骨水泥与非骨水泥固定之间无差异。
临床怎么用
- 医疗政策可利用这些发现作为当前全髋关节置换实践的反馈,引导外科医生选择正确的植入物固定方式。
- 对75岁以上患者,选择骨水泥固定可能降低翻修风险,但需结合各国登记数据的具体趋势。
局限性
- 研究基于登记库数据,未进行再分析,且未跨登记库合并数据,可能限制结论的普遍性。
- 证据等级为III级,治疗性研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Despite existing studies favoring cemented fixation for patients older than 75 years, a trend toward increased use of uncemented fixation has been described in a 2013 study that used arthroplasty registry data from 2006 to 2010. Updated summarized data are needed beyond 2010 to investigate contemporary trends in the usage of uncemented fixation, especially in patients older than 75 years, and to draw attention to a potential continuing conflict between trends in fixation choice and reported revision risk. Thus, healthcare policy and practice can change and surgeons can make better implant fixation choices. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Has the percentage of primary THAs performed with uncemented fixation changed since 2010? (2) Has the percentage of primary THAs performed in patients older than 75 years performed with uncemented fixation changed since 2010? (3) After stratifying by age, which fixation strategy (cemented versus uncemented and hybrid versus uncemented) is associated with the lowest risk of revision? METHODS: National annual reports from hip arthroplasty registers were identified, and data were extracted from registers published in English or a Scandinavian language, with at least 3 years of reported data in the period from 2010 to 2017. These included Australia, Denmark, England-Wales, Finland, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Romania, Norway, Sweden, and Switzerland, which are all countries with high completeness rates. Data regarding rates of revisions (all causes) related to fixation methods and secondary to different age groups, were taken directly from the registers and no re-analysis was done. The risk estimates were presented as either hazard ratios, rate per 100 component years or as Kaplan-Meier estimates of revision. The age groups compared for Denmark were younger than 50, 50-59, 60-69,70-79, and older than 80 years, and for Australia, New Zealand, England-Wales, and Finland, they were younger than 55, 55-64, 65-74, and older than 75 years. No data were pooled across the registers. RESULTS: The current use of uncemented fixation in primary THAs varies between 24% (Sweden) and 71% (Denmark). Increasing use of uncemented fixation has been reported in Norway, Denmark, and Sweden, whereas decreasing use of uncemented fixation has been reported in England-Wales, Australia, New Zealand, and Finland. Examining the group of patients older than 75 years, we found that the use of uncemented fixation has been stable in Netherlands, Sweden, New Zealand, and England-Wales. The use of uncemented fixation is still increasing in Denmark and Australia. In Finland, the use of uncemented fixation has decreased (from 43 % to 24 %) from 2010 to 2017. When compared with uncemented fixation, the risk of revision for hips using cemented fixation was lower in patients older than 75 years for all registers surveyed, except for the oldest males in the Finnish register. In this group, no difference was found between cemented and uncemented fixation. CONCLUSION: Our findings should be used in healthcare policy as feedback on current THAs being performed so as to direct surgeons to choose the right implant fixation, especially in patients older than 75 years, thereby reducing revision risk and increasing the long-term survival of primary THAs. It appears that femoral stem fixation may be the most important revision risk factor in older patients, and future studies should examine this perspective. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.
引用
- Bunyoz KI, Malchau E, Malchau H, et al. Has the Use of Fixation Techniques in THA Changed in This Decade? The Uncemented Paradox Revisited. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2020. PMID: 31899744. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000001117
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。