计算机辅助手术与传统器械在全膝关节置换术中的结局比较:19,221例平均随访4.5年结果
基于新西兰关节登记系统2006至2018年19,221例全膝关节置换术数据,按高手术量医生是否常规使用计算机辅助手术分组比较。结果显示两组翻修率与牛津膝关节评分在6个月、5年及10年随访均无显著差异,而计算机辅助手术组手术时间平均延长10分钟。
要点
- 常规使用计算机辅助手术与传统器械的全膝关节置换术翻修率无显著差异。
- 两组牛津膝关节评分在6个月、5年及10年随访时均无显著差异。
- 有经验的医生使用计算机辅助手术时手术时间平均延长10分钟。
核心结论
- 本研究未发现支持全膝关节置换术常规使用计算机辅助手术的生存率或功能评分优势。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,数据来自新西兰关节登记系统,纳入2006至2018年19,221例全膝关节置换术,平均随访4.5年(范围0至12年)。
- 比较常规使用计算机辅助手术的高手术量医生与常规使用传统器械的高手术量医生所治疗的患者队列。
主要发现
- 每100假体年翻修率在常规计算机辅助手术组为0.437,常规传统器械组为0.440(p=0.724)。
- 65岁以下患者中,两组每100假体年翻修率分别为0.585与0.508(p=0.524)。
- 牛津膝关节评分在6个月时为38.88比38.52(p=0.172),5年时为42.26比41.77(p=0.206),10年时为41.59比41.74(p=0.893)。
- 使用计算机辅助手术超过50例的医生手术时间平均为92分钟,传统器械组为82分钟(p=0.012)。
临床怎么用
- 对于全膝关节置换术,计算机辅助手术并未显示出比传统器械更好的翻修率或功能结局,临床选择需权衡手术时间延长等因素。
局限性
- 研究为登记系统回顾性分析,可能存在选择偏倚,尽管按医生常规使用习惯分组以控制复杂病例偏好。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Studies have shown improved alignment in association with the use of computer-assisted surgery (CAS) as compared with conventional instrumentation during total knee arthroplasty (TKA) but have failed to show a consistent clinical benefit. The aim of the present study was to compare the revision rates and functional outcomes following TKA performed with either CAS or conventional instrumentation. Recognizing that selection bias may arise from the preferential use of CAS in difficult or complex cases, the implant survival data and postoperative functional scores were analyzed with reference to whether the surgeon routinely performed TKA with use of CAS or conventional instrumentation. METHODS: Revision rates and functional data in terms of the Oxford Knee Score (OKS) at 6 months, 5 years, and 10 years were obtained from the New Zealand Joint Registry (NZJR) for 19,221 TKAs performed from 2006 to 2018.These data were analyzed by comparing 2 cohorts of patients: those managed by high-volume surgeons who routinely used CAS ("routine CAS" surgeons) and those managed by high-volume surgeons who routinely used conventional instrumentation ("routine conventional" surgeons). The mean duration of follow-up was 4.5 years (range, 0 to 12 years). RESULTS: The revision rate per 100 component-years was 0.437 for the "routine CAS" surgeons, compared with 0.440 for the "routine conventional" surgeons (p = 0.724). For patients <65 years of age, the revision rate per 100 component-years was equivalent for the "routine CAS" and "routine conventional" surgeons (0.585 compared with 0.508; p = 0.524). The OKS scores were similar at 6 months (38.88 compared with 38.52; p = 0.172), 5 years (42.26 compared with 41.77; p = 0.206), and 10 years (41.59 compared with 41.74; p = 0.893) when comparing the 2 cohorts. Surgeons who had performed >50 TKAs with use of CAS took 10 minutes longer on average than those who used conventional instrumentation (92 compared with 82 minutes; p = 0.012). CONCLUSIONS: The present study demonstrated no difference in survivorship or functional outcome scores to support using CAS for TKA. Experienced surgeons using CAS had longer operative durations than comparable surgeons using conventional instrumentation. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic Level III. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.
引用
- Roberts TD, Frampton CM, Young SW, et al. Outcomes of Computer-Assisted Surgery Compared with Conventional Instrumentation in 19,221 Total Knee Arthroplasties: Results After a Mean of 4.5 Years of Follow-Up. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2020. PMID: 31977812. doi:10.2106/JBJS.19.00852
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。