全膝关节置换术中股骨假体旋转参考轴的准确性:基于2128例股骨CT的研究
基于2128例股骨CT扫描,比较Whiteside线、sTEA、aTEA、PCA+3°ER、沟线及FTA与sTEA的偏差。PCA+3°ER最准确但个体间变异最大;无单一轴兼具高准确性与低变异,推荐联合3种轴(PCA+3°ER、Whiteside或沟线、aTEA)判断股骨假体旋转。
要点
- PCA+3°ER与sTEA平均偏差0.60°±1.64°,最准确但个体间变异最大。
- PCA-sTEA角平均2.40°,女性2.64°±1.74°显著高于男性2.18°±1.52°(p<0.001)。
- 联合Whiteside线、aTEA与PCA+3°ER三轴与sTEA平均偏差1.80°±0.70°。
核心结论
- 没有任何单一参考轴能同时具备高准确性和低变异性来标记股骨假体旋转。
- 推荐联合使用PCA+3°ER、Whiteside或沟线、aTEA三种方法以最大化准确性和性别、种族通用性。
研究设计与样本
- 基于Stryker Orthopaedic Modeling and Analytics(SOMA)数据库的2128例完整股骨CT扫描。
- 按已发表指南构建Whiteside线、aTEA、PCA+3°ER、沟线和FTA,并与sTEA比较。
主要发现
- PCA+3°ER与sTEA平均偏差0.60°±1.64°,最准确但个体间变异最大。
- PCA-sTEA角平均2.40°,女性(2.64°±1.74°)显著高于男性(2.18°±1.52°;p<0.001)。
- Whiteside线与sTEA平均偏差1.90°±1.38°,沟线1.94°±1.49°,两者不随性别或种族显著变化。
- FTA与sTEA平均偏差2.04°±1.50°,aTEA最不准确,平均偏差2.05°±1.33°。
- 联合Whiteside线、aTEA和PCA+3°ER三轴与sTEA平均偏差1.80°±0.70°。
关键数值与推荐
- sTEA被广泛视为股骨远端旋转的金标准参考轴,但术中观察者内和观察者间可靠性低。
- PCA+3°ER与sTEA平均偏差0.60°±1.64°;PCA-sTEA角平均2.40°,接近3°经验法则。
- 女性PCA-sTEA角2.64°±1.74°显著高于男性2.18°±1.52°(p<0.001)。
- 联合三轴(PCA+3°ER、Whiteside或沟线、aTEA)与sTEA平均偏差1.80°±0.70°。
临床怎么用
- 全膝关节置换术中判断股骨假体旋转时,推荐联合使用PCA+3°ER、Whiteside或沟线、aTEA三种参考轴。
- 联合策略有助于兼顾准确性和性别、种族通用性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Many reference axes are used to evaluate rotation of the femoral component during total knee arthroplasty, including the Whiteside line, surgical transepicondylar axis (sTEA), anatomical transepicondylar axis (aTEA), posterior condylar axis externally rotated 3° (PCA+3°ER), sulcus line, and femoral transverse axis (FTA). There is no consensus about which of these axes is most accurate. METHODS: The Stryker Orthopaedic Modeling and Analytics (SOMA) database was used to identify 2,128 entire-femur computed tomography (CT) scans. The Whiteside line, aTEA, PCA+3°ER, sulcus line, and FTA were constructed according to published guidelines. Every axis was compared with the sTEA, which is widely regarded as the gold standard reference axis for rotation of the distal part of the femur but has low intraobserver and interobserver reliability intraoperatively. RESULTS: The PCA+3°ER differed from the sTEA by a mean (and standard deviation) of 0.60° ± 1.64°; it was the most accurate but also had the highest degree of intersubject variability. The mean PCA-sTEA angle was 2.40°, close to the accepted "rule of thumb" of 3°. This value was significantly higher in women (2.64° ± 1.74°) than in men (2.18° ± 1.52°; p < 0.001). The Whiteside line differed from the sTEA by a mean of 1.90° ± 1.38°, and the sulcus line differed from the sTEA by a mean of 1.94° ± 1.49°; neither of these values varied significantly with sex or ethnicity. The FTA differed from the sTEA by a mean of 2.04° ± 1.50°. Least accurate was the aTEA, which differed from the sTEA by a mean of 2.05° ± 1.33°. The combination of 3 axes that are readily available intraoperatively (the Whiteside line, aTEA, and PCA+3°ER) differed from the sTEA by a mean of 1.80° ± 0.70°. CONCLUSIONS: In the largest study of its kind, analysis of CT scans of 2,128 femora revealed that no 1 axis could serve as a marker of femoral component rotation with both high accuracy and low variability. Utilizing a combination of 3 methods (PCA+3°ER, the Whiteside or sulcus line, and aTEA) to maximize accuracy and sex and ethnic generalizability when positioning the femoral component is recommended. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: A large-scale study using a CT-based biomorphometric database demonstrated that use of a combination of 3 axes (PCA+3°ER, the Whiteside or sulcus line, and aTEA) was the optimal strategy for judging femoral component rotation.
引用
- Jang ES, Connors-Ehlert R, LiArno S, et al. Accuracy of Reference Axes for Femoral Component Rotation in Total Knee Arthroplasty: Computed Tomography-Based Study of 2,128 Femora. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2019. PMID: 31800427. doi:10.2106/JBJS.19.00438
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。