计算机辅助全关节置换术前规划影像偶然发现的频率、费用与临床意义
本研究回顾573例初次计算机辅助全关节置换患者,45.7%至少有一项偶然发现,仅1.0%需进一步检查、0.2%手术延迟;
要点
- 45.7%患者术前规划影像存在偶然发现,非肌肉骨骼类占9.3%。
- 仅1.0%需额外检查、0.2%手术延迟,临床干预需求低。
核心结论
- 计算机辅助全关节置换术前规划影像的偶然发现较常见,但需额外检查或延迟手术的比例很低。
- 随着影像辅助计算机辅助全关节置换使用增加,利益相关方需关注偶然发现带来的隐性费用。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,纳入573例接受初次计算机辅助全关节置换且需规划影像的患者。
- 偶然发现定义为报告中排除与计划关节置换相关发现的其它发现,次要结局为额外检查或手术延迟。
- 费用数据来自本机构网站,结合2016年全国住院样本的全关节置换手术量建模系统成本。
主要发现
- 262例(45.7%)至少有一项偶然发现,144例(25.1%)有两项,65例(11.3%)有三项。
- 最常见类型为肌肉骨骼(67.7%)、消化(19.5%)、心血管(4.9%)和生殖(4.7%),9.3%患者至少有一项非肌肉骨骼偶然发现。
- 全髋置换的肌肉骨骼和非肌肉骨骼偶然发现均比全膝置换更常见(67.9% vs 42.2%,P < .0001;15.4% vs 8.3%,P < .05)。
- 6例(1.0%)需进一步检查,1例(0.2%)需延迟手术。
临床怎么用
- 骨科智能体医生应知晓术前规划影像偶然发现的高发生率,但需干预比例低,可据此评估检查的必要性。
- 在推广影像辅助计算机辅助全关节置换时,应考虑偶然发现后续检查的隐性成本。
局限性
- 费用数据仅来自单家机构网站,可能影响成本模拟的泛化性。
- 研究为回顾性设计,偶然发现的报告可能受影像判读差异影响。
- 成本模拟基于2016年全国住院样本及假设的使用率,存在时间与假设偏差。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The frequency of incidental findings with computer-assisted total joint arthroplasty (CA TJA) preoperative imaging and their clinical significance are currently unknown. METHODS: We reviewed 573 patients who underwent primary CA TJA requiring planning imaging. Incidental findings were defined as reported findings excluding those related to the planned arthroplasty. Secondary outcomes were additional tests or a delay in surgery. Associated charges were obtained from our institution's website. Charge and incidence data were combined with TJA volumes obtained from the 2016 National Inpatient Sample to model costs to the healthcare system. RESULTS: Overall, 262 patients (45.7%) had at least 1 incidental finding, 144 patients (25.1%) had 2, and 65 (11.3%) had 3. The most common finding types were musculoskeletal (MSK, 67.7%), digestive (19.5%), cardiovascular (4.9%), and reproductive (4.7%). Also, 9.3% of patients had at least 1 non-MSK incidental finding. Both MSK and non-MSK incidental findings were more common with total hip arthroplasty compared to total knee arthroplasty (67.9% vs 42.2%, P < .0001, and 15.4% vs 8.3%, P < .05, respectively). Further testing was required in 6 cases (1.0%); 1 case required delay in surgery (0.2%). Using the 2016 volume of TJA procedures and assuming a 10%, 15%, and 25%, utilization rate of image-based CA TJA, the annual cost of additional testing was $2.7 million (95% confidence interval, $1.1-$6.3 million), $4.1 million ($1.6-$9.5 million), and $6.9 million (95% confidence interval, $2.7-$15.8 million), respectively. CONCLUSION: Incidental findings are relatively common on planning images. Stakeholders should be aware of the hidden costs of incidental findings given the increasing popularity of image-based CA TJA.
引用
- Hassebrock JD, Makovicka JL, Clarke HD, et al. Frequency, Cost, and Clinical Significance of Incidental Findings on Preoperative Planning Images for Computer-Assisted Total Joint Arthroplasty. J Arthroplasty. 2019. PMID: 31882348. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2019.11.030
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。