虚拟现实训练提升全髋关节置换术受训者表现:一项随机对照试验
该观察者盲法1:1随机对照试验纳入24名无前路全髋关节置换术(THA)经验的外科受训者,12人接受六周虚拟现实(VR)训练,12人仅接受常规准备材料,随后均完成尸体THA。VR组在手术操作评估(PBA)中位等级、关键步骤完成数、髋臼假体方位准确性和手术速度上均优于对照组。
要点
- VR训练组PBA中位等级为3a级,对照组为2a级,表明VR训练提升手术操作水平。
- VR训练组完成关键步骤数比对照组多33%(平均22步 vs 12步)。
- VR训练组假体方位平均误差4°,对照组16°,准确性提高12°;手术时间平均42分钟 vs 51分钟,快18%。
核心结论
- VR训练所获得的THA程序性知识和精神运动技能可迁移至尸体操作表现。
- 基础准备材料对受训者学习新技术的价值有限。
- VR训练使受训者在学习曲线上进阶更远,实现高精度假体方位和更高效的手术。
研究设计与样本
- 观察者盲法1:1随机对照试验,共纳入24名外科受训者(7名女性,17名男性;平均年龄29岁(28至31岁))。
- 受训者均无前路THA经验,12人完成六周VR训练程序,另12人仅接受常规准备材料。
- 所有受训者随后完成尸体THA,由两名髋关节外科医生独立评估。
主要发现
- VR训练组PBA中位等级为3a级(操作需极少指导或干预),对照组为2a级(操作大部分或全部需指导)。
- VR训练组完成关键步骤数比对照组多33%(平均22步(标准差3) vs 12步(标准差3))。
- VR训练组假体方位平均误差4°(标准差6°),对照组16°(标准差17°),准确性提高12°。
- VR训练组手术时间平均42分钟(标准差7),对照组51分钟(标准差9),速度快18%。
临床怎么用
- VR训练可作为传统外科培训的补充,帮助受训者安全获取关节置换手术技能。
- 对于学习复杂开放手术的新手,基础准备材料效果有限,可优先考虑VR模拟训练。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: Arthroplasty skills need to be acquired safely during training, yet operative experience is increasingly hard to acquire by trainees. Virtual reality (VR) training using headsets and motion-tracked controllers can simulate complex open procedures in a fully immersive operating theatre. The present study aimed to determine if trainees trained using VR perform better than those using conventional preparation for performing total hip arthroplasty (THA). PATIENTS AND METHODS: A total of 24 surgical trainees (seven female, 17 male; mean age 29 years (28 to 31)) volunteered to participate in this observer-blinded 1:1 randomized controlled trial. They had no prior experience of anterior approach THA. Of these 24 trainees, 12 completed a six-week VR training programme in a simulation laboratory, while the other 12 received only conventional preparatory materials for learning THA. All trainees then performed a cadaveric THA, assessed independently by two hip surgeons. The primary outcome was technical and non-technical surgical performance measured by a THA-specific procedure-based assessment (PBA). Secondary outcomes were step completion measured by a task-specific checklist, error in acetabular component orientation, and procedure duration. RESULTS: VR-trained surgeons performed at a higher level than controls, with a median PBA of Level 3a (procedure performed with minimal guidance or intervention) versus Level 2a (guidance required for most/all of the procedure or part performed). VR-trained surgeons completed 33% more key steps than controls (mean 22 (sd 3) vs 12 (sd 3)), were 12° more accurate in component orientation (mean error 4° (sd 6°) vs 16° (sd 17°)), and were 18% faster (mean 42 minutes (sd 7) vs 51 minutes (sd 9)). CONCLUSION: Procedural knowledge and psychomotor skills for THA learned in VR were transferred to cadaveric performance. Basic preparatory materials had limited value for trainees learning a new technique. VR training advanced trainees further up the learning curve, enabling highly precise component orientation and more efficient surgery. VR could augment traditional surgical training to improve how surgeons learn complex open procedures. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2019;101-B:1585-1592.
引用
- Logishetty K, Rudran B, Cobb JP, et al. Virtual reality training improves trainee performance in total hip arthroplasty: a randomized controlled trial. Bone Joint J. 2019. PMID: 31786991. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.101B12.BJJ-2019-0643.R1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。