膝关节肿瘤型旋转铰链假体早期机械失败:缓冲垫磨损是否导致过伸失败?
该研究回顾性分析87例膝关节周围肉瘤行肿瘤型假体置换患者,其中6例使用Zimmer Segmental旋转铰链假体,3例因假体断裂行翻修;断裂与缓冲垫磨损导致的后方不稳相关。翻修后MSTS评分从9分改善至25分(中位数),未翻修者MSTS评分为20分。
要点
- 6例Zimmer Segmental假体中3例因假体断裂行翻修,断裂与缓冲垫磨损导致后方不稳相关。
- 有后方不稳者翻修前MSTS评分中位数9分,翻修后6个月改善至25分。
- 未翻修者MSTS评分中位数20分,假体设计问题需更大注册系统验证。
核心结论
- Zimmer Segmental旋转铰链肿瘤型假体在6例中3例短期因假体断裂行翻修,缓冲垫断裂与衬套阻挡系统磨损导致的后方不稳相关。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析1987至2014年87例膝关节周围肉瘤行广泛切除与肿瘤型假体置换患者,剔除5例失访后82例中49例2006至2014年置换,其中6例使用Zimmer Segmental假体并作为本报告重点。
- 评估49例患者MSTS评分,Segmental假体中位随访65个月(范围24至85个月)。
主要发现
- 6例Segmental假体中3例体检有后方不稳和反复关节积液,另3例无过伸者表现为膝关节活动度受限。
- 3例患者共行6次翻修手术;Segmental假体6个月MSTS评分中位数15分(范围6至24)。
- 有后方不稳的3例MSTS评分中位数9分(范围6至15),翻修后6个月改善至中位数25分(范围19至30);未翻修者MSTS评分中位数20分(范围16至24)。
临床怎么用
- 使用Zimmer Segmental旋转铰链肿瘤型假体时需警惕缓冲垫磨损导致的后方不稳和假体断裂,短期随访出现关节积液或活动度受限应评估假体失败。
- 翻修可改善因后方不稳导致功能受损患者的MSTS评分。
局限性
- 样本量小(6例Segmental假体),为单中心回顾性研究,证据等级Level IV。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Tumor surgeons use a variety of endoprosthetic designs for reconstruction after bone tumor resection. However, functional results and implant survival have not been evaluated for each design. Because the outcomes and failure modes (for example, implant breakage, loosening) may differ between prosthetic design types, it is important to examine the problems associated with different designs. Because of experiences in our practice, we became concerned about a surprisingly high frequency of device breakage with one particular design, and we wished to report on that experience. QUESTION/PURPOSES: (1) In a small series of patients, what proportion of a particular design (Zimmer® Segmental [Zimmer Inc, Warsaw, IN, USA]) of rotating-hinge endoprosthesis experienced implant breakage at short-term follow-up? (2) What patient symptoms were associated with this finding? (3) What is the function as assessed by Musculoskeletal Tumor Society (MSTS) score with the use of this implant before and after revision? METHODS: We treated 87 patients in our tertiary center from 1987 to 2014 who had sarcomas around the knee with wide resection and reconstruction with tumoral endoprosthesis; five patients were lost to follow-up. In all, 33 of the remanining 82 prostheses, treated from 1987 to 2006, were reconstructed with fixed-hinge designs. From 2006 to 2014, 49 patients were reconstructed with a knee endoprosthesis, and 48 of them had a rotating-hinge prosthesis. In our center, we mostly used four designs: 16 of 49 patients were reconstructed with GMRS (Stryker Howmedica, Kalamazoo, MI, USA), seven received the LPS™ (DePuy Synthes, Warsaw, IN, USA), 20 of 49 had the METS (Stanmore, Hertfordshire, UK), and six of 49 received the Zimmer Segmental. The focus of this report is on the six patients with the Segmental. We retrospectively gathered clinical and radiologic data from these six patients' records and we assessed radiographic images. We evaluated function with the MSTS score of the 49 patients. The median follow-up duration of the Segmental prosthesis reconstruction was 65 months (range 24 to 85). RESULTS: Three of the six patients had posterior instability and recurrent joint effusion on physical examination. Three patients who did not have hyperextension presented with restricted knee ROM. Six revision procedures were performed in three patients. The median MSTS score at 6 months for the Segmental® prosthesis was 15 of 30 (range 6 to 24). The score in the three patients who had posterior instability was 9 of 30 (range 6 to 15) and it improved to median 25 of 30 (range 19 to 30) 6 months after revision. The patients with the Segmental® prosthesis who did not undergo revision had a median MSTS score of 20 (range 16 to 24). CONCLUSIONS: The Zimmer Segmental rotating-hinge tumoral prosthesis underwent revision for implant breakage at short term in three of six patients after tumor resection and reconstruction of the knee. Bumper breakage was associated with posterior instability that was related to wear of the bushing blocking system. We are unaware of reports of these issues by other observers or in other prosthetic designs, but we feel larger registries should be created to see if this failure mechanism has been observed by others. If so, this design needs to be improved or the blocking system should be avoided.Level of Evidence Level IV, therapeutic study.
引用
- Barrientos-Ruiz I, Ortiz-Cruz EJ, Peleteiro-Pensado M, et al. Early Mechanical Failure of a Tumoral Endoprosthesic Rotating Hinge in the Knee: Does Bumper Wear Contribute to Hyperextension Failure? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2019. PMID: 31764341. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000000949
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。