移植物桥接与上关节囊重建治疗大至巨大肩袖撕裂的疗效比较:系统综述
该系统综述纳入23项研究(SCR组5项238例修复,GB组18项593例修复),比较移植物桥接(GB)与上关节囊重建(SCR)治疗大至巨大肩袖撕裂的疗效。GB组在Constant-Murley评分、ASES评分、疼痛VAS评分及主动外旋的平均改善值上均显著优于SCR组,而两组在主动前屈、内旋、外展及移植物愈合率上无显著差异,并发症率相近。结论提示GB可能是更优选择,但需更多高质量随机对照研究验证。
要点
- GB组在Constant-Murley评分、ASES评分、疼痛VAS及主动外旋的改善值上显著优于SCR组。
- 两组在主动前屈、内旋、外展及移植物愈合率上无统计学显著差异。
- 并发症率SCR组为0.84%(2/238),GB组为0.67%(4/593),两组相近。
核心结论
- GB术后临床和功能结果显著优于SCR,且并发症率相似。
- 现有中等质量证据提示GB可能是大至巨大肩袖撕裂的更好选择。
- 需要更多高质量随机对照研究进一步评估两种术式的相对获益。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,通过全面检索PubMed、Embase和Cochrane Library进行。
- 共纳入23项研究:SCR组5项研究238例修复,GB组18项研究593例修复。
- SCR组平均年龄61.6岁、平均随访18.0个月;GB组平均年龄63.3岁、平均随访40.1个月。
主要发现
- 两种术式整体均显示临床结果改善。
- GB组相比SCR组的Constant-Murley评分平均差值更高(41.9 vs 19.8)。
- GB组相比SCR组的ASES评分平均差值更高(39.3 vs 33.8)。
- GB组相比SCR组的疼痛VAS评分平均差值更高(4.4 vs 3.4)。
- GB组相比SCR组的主动外旋平均差值更高(15.3 vs 9.3)。
关键数值与推荐
- 主要结局为末次随访时的Constant-Murley评分。
- 次要结局包括ASES评分、疼痛VAS评分、主动肩关节活动度和移植物愈合率。
- 并发症率为安全性结局指标,SCR组0.84%(2/238),GB组0.67%(4/593)。
- 主动前屈、内旋、外展及移植物愈合率的平均差值组间无统计学显著差异(P < .05为显著性标准)。
临床怎么用
- 对于大至巨大肩袖撕裂,GB可能在临床和功能结果上优于SCR。
- 两种术式并发症率相似,安全性相当。
- 临床决策可参考GB的潜在优势,但需结合患者具体情况并认识到证据质量有限。
局限性
- 纳入证据质量为中等(fair-quality)。
- 缺乏高质量随机对照研究。
- SCR组与GB组的平均随访时间不一致(18.0个月 vs 40.1个月)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Graft bridging (GB) and superior capsule reconstruction (SCR) were developed to treat large to massive rotator cuff tears (RCTs); however, the outcome differences between GB and SCR remain unclear. PURPOSE: To systematically review and compare the outcomes of GB and SCR for large to massive RCT. STUDY DESIGN: Systematic review. METHODS: A systematic review was performed via a comprehensive search of PubMed, Embase, and the Cochrane Library. Studies of GB or SCR were included according to the inclusion and exclusion criteria. The primary outcome was Constant-Murley score at the final follow-up. Secondary outcomes included the American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons score, visual analog scale score for pain, active shoulder range of motion, and graft healing rate. Complication rate was the safety outcome measure. Outcomes were summarized into group SCR and group GB, and the results were compared statistically (P < .05). RESULTS: A total of 23 studies were included in this review: 238 repairs from the 5 studies in group SCR and 593 repairs from the 18 studies in group GB. For group SCR and group GB, the mean age was 61.6 and 63.3 years, and the mean follow-up was 18.0 and 40.1 months, respectively. Overall, both procedures demonstrated improvement of clinical outcomes. When compared with group SCR, group GB had significantly higher mean differences of the Constant-Murley score (41.9 vs 19.8), American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons score (39.3 vs 33.8), visual analog scale score for pain (4.4 vs 3.4), and active external rotation at side (15.3 vs 9.3). No statistically significant difference was detected in the mean difference of active forward flexion, internal rotation, abduction, and graft healing rate between the groups. The complication rates were 0.84% (2 of 238) in group SCR and 0.67% (4 of 593) in group GB. CONCLUSION: In general, GB showed significantly better clinical and functional outcomes postoperatively than SCR, with a similar complication rate. The available fair-quality evidence suggested that GB might be a better choice for large to massive RCT. More high-quality randomized controlled studies are required to further evaluate the relative benefits of the 2 procedures.
引用
- Lin J, Sun Y, Chen Q, et al. Outcome Comparison of Graft Bridging and Superior Capsule Reconstruction for Large to Massive Rotator Cuff Tears: A Systematic Review. Am J Sports Med. 2019. PMID: 31766858. doi:10.1177/0363546519889040
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。