前交叉韧带重建术后重返赛场评估间隔:约2个月可获临床重要力量增益
本研究为横断面/病例对照研究(证据等级3),纳入293例前交叉韧带重建术后患者(平均年龄23.2±10.1岁,术后6.4±0.9个月),按评估月份分层比较主观功能与等速肌力。结果显示术后5-6个月患者的主观功能与伸膝肌力低于6-7个月和8-9个月组,且约需1.97个月间隔才能达到有临床意义的对称性改善阈值。
要点
- 术后5-6个月评估者的IKDC主观评分与伸膝肌力低于6-7个月和8-9个月组。
- 伸膝力矩增加0.22 N·m/kg、对称性增加5.75%可判别主观功能改善。
- 两次评估间隔约1.97个月可达到有临床意义的对称性改善阈值。
核心结论
- 术后5-6个月患者的主观功能与股四头肌功能低于更晚时间点,提示9个月时仍可能存在可改善的缺陷。
- 约2个月间隔可观察到有临床意义的力量改善,建议给予患者足够时间再行重返赛场评估。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面/病例对照研究,证据等级3,纳入293例ACLR术后患者(平均年龄23.2±10.1岁,女性142例,术后6.4±0.9个月)。
- 按评估月份分层:5-6个月(n=122)、6-7个月(n=102)、7-8个月(n=43)、8-9个月(n=26)。
- 40例患者(女性20例,年龄20.4±7.1岁)在初次就诊后2.14±0.78个月接受后续测试。
主要发现
- 伸膝力矩增加0.22 N·m/kg和对称性增加5.75%可判别主观功能改善(IKDC≥9分变化)。
- 两次评估间隔1.97个月可判别达到对称性阈值。
关键数值与推荐
- 主观功能改善定义为IKDC评分变化≥9分。
- 伸膝力矩增加0.22 N·m/kg和对称性增加5.75%为判别主观改善的阈值。
- 两次评估间隔1.97个月为达到对称性阈值的判别时间。
临床怎么用
- ACLR术后重返赛场评估不宜过早,5-6个月时主观功能与肌力常未达最佳。
- 建议两次重返赛场评估间隔约2个月,以观察有临床意义的力量改善。
- 可采用伸膝力矩增加0.22 N·m/kg、对称性增加5.75%作为评估主观功能改善的参考阈值。
局限性
- 横断面/病例对照设计,证据等级3,不能确立因果关系。
- 后续测试样本量较小(40例),阈值需更大队列验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Pass rates for return-to-play evaluations are alarmingly low for patients after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR). Since timing of return to play is a complicated decision, it is important that patients be given optimal time to realize meaningful improvements in strength that warrant additional testing. PURPOSE: To (1) compare outcomes among patients assessed at different time points after ACLR, (2) determine strength gains indicative of improvements in subjective function, and (3) determine the amount of time necessary to achieve meaningful strength gains. STUDY DESIGN: Cross-sectional/case-control study; Level of evidence, 3. METHODS: A total of 293 patients participated in the study after ACLR (mean ± SD, 23.2 ± 10.1 years old; n = 142 female participants; 6.4 ± 0.9 months after ACLR). Participants were stratified on the month of their evaluation after ACLR: 5 to 6 months (n = 122), 6 to 7 months (n = 102), 7 to 8 months (n = 43), and 8 to 9 months (n = 26). The International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) subjective form and knee extensor and flexor torque and symmetry, as assessed through an isokinetic dynamometer, were compared among groups. Forty patients (20 female participants, 20.4 ± 7.1 years old) were referred for subsequent testing (2.14 ± 0.78 months after initial visit). Subjective improvement between visits was defined as a ≥9-point change of the IKDC score. Thresholds of knee extensor torque and symmetry indicative of subjective improvement and the time between assessments needed to achieve these strength improvements were determined. RESULTS: Patients between 5 and 6 months (IKDC, 79.7; interquartile range [IQR], 70.1-88.5) had lower subjective function compared to patients between 6 and 7 months (IKDC, 83.9; IQR, 74.5-92.0; P = .019) and 8 and 9 months after ACLR (IKDC, 89.1; IQR 75.8-92.3; P = .026). Patients between 5 and 6 months (1.41 N·m/kg; IQR, 1.16-1.73 N·m/kg]) had lower knee extensor torque compared to patients 6 and 7 months (1.59 N·m/kg; IQR, 1.23-1.95 N·m/kg; P = .013) and 7 and 8 months after ACLR (1.62 N·m/kg; IQR, 1.30-1.86 N·m/kg; P = .046). Patients between 5 and 6 months (66.4%; IQR, 54.2-78.6) had lower symmetry compared to patients between 6 and 7 months (71.8%; IQR,61.1-82.9; P = .019) and 8 and 9 months afterACLR (75.2%; IQR, 66.6-87.7; P = .014). Of the 40 patients that completed follow-up assessments, an increase in knee extensor torque of 0.22 N·m/kg and symmetry of 5.75% discriminated patients that achieved subjective improvement. A period of 1.97 months between assessments discriminated those that achieved the established symmetry threshold. CONCLUSION: Patients demonstrate increasing subjective and quadriceps function when tested at later time points from surgery; however, the observed values are low, suggesting that at 9 months patients are demonstrating deficits that may be improving. Approximately 2 months is needed to observe clinically meaningful improvements.
引用
- Bodkin SG, Rutherford MH, Diduch DR, et al. How Much Time Is Needed Between Serial "Return to Play" Assessments to Achieve Clinically Important Strength Gains in Patients Recovering From Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction? Am J Sports Med. 2019. PMID: 31756121. doi:10.1177/0363546519886291
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。