手术与非手术治疗肩袖撕裂的配对分析
研究对全层肩袖撕裂患者进行倾向评分匹配,比较手术修复与非手术治疗的结局。年轻、症状持续时间短和手术修复与更好的结局独立相关。
要点
- 最终随访手术组WORCnorm、ASES、SANE和疼痛VAS均显著优于非手术组(p<0.001)。
- 年轻、症状持续时间短和手术修复与更好结局独立相关。
核心结论
- 全层肩袖撕裂患者无论非手术或手术修复,疼痛和功能评分均有改善。
- 但选择手术修复的患者报告结局评分改善更大、疼痛更轻。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性队列中回顾性评估18岁以上MRI确诊全层肩袖撕裂患者,患者自行选择手术修复或非手术。
- 采用倾向评分匹配按年龄、性别、症状持续时间、FCI、撕裂大小、损伤机制和萎缩程度配对。
- 证据等级为治疗性III级。
主要发现
- 最终随访时手术组WORCnorm为81.4(95%CI 76.9, 85.9),非手术组为68.8(95%CI 63.7, 74.0)。
- 最终随访时手术组ASES为86.1(95%CI 82.4, 90.3),非手术组为76.2(95%CI 72.4, 80.9)。
- 最终随访时手术组SANE为77.5(95%CI 70.6, 82.5),非手术组为66.9(95%CI 61.0, 72.2)。
- 最终随访时手术组疼痛VAS为14.4(95%CI 10.2, 20.2),非手术组为27.8(95%CI 22.5, 33.5)。
- 所有结局指标在最终随访时手术组均显著优于非手术组(p<0.001)。
临床怎么用
- 全层肩袖撕裂患者可考虑手术修复以获更大结局评分改善和疼痛减轻,但需结合年龄和症状持续时间个体化决策。
局限性
- 原文未述局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Rotator cuff disease is a major medical and economic burden due to a growing aging population, but management of rotator cuff tears remains controversial. We hypothesized that there is no difference in outcomes between patients who undergo rotator cuff repair and matched patients treated nonoperatively. METHODS: After institutional review board approval, a prospective cohort of patients over 18 years of age who had a full-thickness rotator cuff tear seen on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) were retrospectively evaluated. After clinical evaluation, each patient elected to undergo either rotator cuff repair or nonsurgical treatment. Demographic information was collected at enrollment, and self-reported outcome measures (the Normalized Western Ontario Rotator Cuff Index [WORCnorm], American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons score [ASES], Single Assessment Numerical Evaluation [SANE], and pain score on a visual analog scale [VAS]) were collected at baseline and at 6, 12, and >24 months. The Functional Comorbidity Index (FCI) was used to assess health status at enrollment. The size and degree of atrophy of the rotator cuff tear were classified on MRI. Propensity score analysis was used to create rotator cuff repair and nonsurgical groups matched by age, sex, symptom duration, FCI, tear size, injury mechanism, and atrophy. The Student t test, chi-square test, and regression analysis were used to compare the treatment groups. RESULTS: One hundred and seven patients in each group were available for analysis after propensity score matching. There were no differences between the groups with regard to demographics or rotator cuff tear characteristics. For all outcome measures at the time of final follow-up, the rotator cuff repair group had significantly better outcomes than the nonsurgical treatment group (p < 0.001). At the time of final follow-up, the mean outcome scores (and 95% confidence interval) for the surgical repair and nonsurgical treatment groups were, respectively, 81.4 (76.9, 85.9) and 68.8 (63.7, 74.0) for the WORCnorm, 86.1 (82.4, 90.3) and 76.2 (72.4, 80.9) for the ASES, 77.5 (70.6, 82.5) and 66.9 (61.0, 72.2) for the SANE, and 14.4 (10.2, 20.2) and 27.8 (22.5, 33.5) for the pain VAS. In the longitudinal regression analysis, better outcomes were independently associated with younger age, shorter symptom duration, and rotator cuff repair. CONCLUSIONS: Patients with a full-thickness rotator cuff tear reported improvement in pain and functional outcome scores with nonoperative treatment or surgical repair. However, patients who were offered and chose rotator cuff repair reported greater improvement in outcome scores and reduced pain compared with those who chose nonoperative treatment. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic Level III. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.
引用
- Ramme AJ, Robbins CB, Patel KA, et al. Surgical Versus Nonsurgical Management of Rotator Cuff Tears: A Matched-Pair Analysis. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2019. PMID: 31577683. doi:10.2106/JBJS.18.01473
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。