肱骨近端头劈裂骨折手术治疗后的临床与影像学结局
该回顾性研究纳入30例肱骨近端头劈裂骨折患者,平均随访49个月,比较ORIF、RTSA和半肩置换的结局。ORIF并发症率88%、翻修率29%、临床失败率50%;RTSA并发症率75%、失败率25%,并发症多与结节问题相关;半肩置换失败率100%。RTSA可能为老年头劈裂骨折最可预测的治疗选择。
要点
- ORIF术后并发症率88%,翻修率29%,临床失败率50%。
- RTSA并发症率75%,临床失败率25%,并发症多与结节问题相关。
- 半肩置换临床失败率100%,RTSA可能为老年患者最可预测选择。
核心结论
- ORIF治疗头劈裂骨折并发症率和翻修率高。
- RTSA临床结局和并发症率与ORIF相当,并发症多与结节问题相关且本组未需翻修。
- RTSA可能为老年头劈裂骨折最可预测的治疗选择。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,45例头劈裂骨折中纳入30例(67%),平均随访49±18个月(范围12至83个月)。
- 24例接受ORIF,4例接受RTSA,2例接受半肩置换。
- 评估SSV、SST、Constant评分及双平面X线片,分析骨折模式、复位质量、并发症、翻修和临床失败(校正Constant评分<40)。
主要发现
- 总体并发症率83%(ORIF 21/24 [88%];RTSA 3/4 [75%];半肩置换1/2 [50%])。
- ORIF最常见并发症为肱骨头骨坏死(42%)、小结节畸形愈合(33%)和螺钉突出(29%);RTSA并发症均与结节问题相关。
- ORIF翻修7/24(29%),RTSA和半肩置换无翻修;4例(17%)初次ORIF后转为RTSA,3例(12.5%)因螺钉穿出取钉。
- 总体临床失败率50%(ORIF 12/24 [50%];RTSA 1/4 [25%];半肩置换2/2 [100%])。
- 术前因素与临床失败无显著关联;需翻修者SSV(p=0.014)、SST(p=0.028)和校正Constant评分(p=0.069)更差。
关键数值与推荐
- 临床失败定义为校正Constant评分<40,总体失败率50%。
- ORIF并发症率88%、翻修率29%、失败率50%。
- RTSA并发症率75%、失败率25%、无翻修。
- 半肩置换并发症率50%、失败率100%、无翻修。
- 证据等级:治疗性IV级。
临床怎么用
- ORIF治疗头劈裂骨折需注意高并发症率和翻修率。
- RTSA并发症多与结节问题相关,本组未需翻修。
- RTSA可能为老年头劈裂骨折最可预测的治疗选择。
局限性
- 原文未述局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Head-split fractures are a subgroup of proximal humeral fractures in which the fracture line affects the articular surface. Limited data are available regarding outcomes and risk factors for failure following surgical treatment of this rare fracture type. METHODS: Of 45 patients with head-split fractures identified, a total of 30 (67%) were included in this retrospective study, with a mean follow-up of 49 ± 18 months (range, 12 to 83 months). Of those 30, 24 were treated with open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF), 4 with reverse total shoulder arthroplasty (RTSA), and 2 with hemiarthroplasty. Subjective Shoulder Value, Simple Shoulder Test, Constant score, and biplanar radiographs were assessed. Fracture pattern, quality of reduction, eventual complications, revision procedures, and clinical failure (adjusted Constant score < 40) were analyzed, and risk factors for failure were calculated. RESULTS: The overall complication rate was 83% (ORIF: 21 of 24 [88%]; RTSA: 3 of 4 [75%]; and hemiarthroplasty: 1 of 2 [50%]). The most common complications following ORIF were humeral head osteonecrosis (42%), malunion of the lesser tuberosity (33%), and screw protrusion (29%), whereas all complications following RTSA were related to tuberosity problems. Revision was performed in 7 of 24 (29%) of initial ORIF patients, and no revisions were performed in RTSA or hemiarthroplasty patients. Four patients (17%) who underwent primary ORIF underwent conversion to RTSA, and 3 patients (12.5%) had screw removal due to penetration. The overall clinical failure rate was 50% (ORIF: 12 of 24 [50%]; RTSA: 1 of 4 [25%]; and hemiarthroplasty: 2 of 2 [100%]). No significant association was found between preoperative factors and clinical failure. ORIF and primary RTSA showed higher average clinical outcome scores than primary hemiarthroplasty and secondary RTSA. In general, patients who required revision had worse Subjective Shoulder Value (p = 0.014), Simple Shoulder Test (p = 0.028), and adjusted Constant scores (p = 0.069). CONCLUSIONS: Head-split fractures of the humerus treated with ORIF showed high complication and revision rates. RTSA resulted in comparable clinical outcomes and complication rates; however, the complications associated with RTSA were mostly related to tuberosity problems, which in this small series did not require revision. Therefore, RTSA may be the most predictable treatment option for head-split fractures in elderly patients. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic Level IV. See Instructions for Authors for a complete list of levels of evidence.
引用
- Peters PM, Plachel F, Danzinger V, et al. Clinical and Radiographic Outcomes After Surgical Treatment of Proximal Humeral Fractures with Head-Split Component. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2020. PMID: 31596803. doi:10.2106/JBJS.19.00320
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。