文献速递脊柱外科小儿骨科

智能手机护士筛查脊柱侧弯与脊柱外科医生使用脊柱侧凸测量计诊断的准确性比较

A Practical Study of Diagnostic Accuracy: Scoliosis Screenings of Middle School Students by a Trained Nurse With a Smartphone Versus a Spine Surgeon With a Scoliometer.
PubMed 文献 · Spine (Phila Pa 1976) · 2020-01-01

横断面研究纳入2702名七年级学生,先由骨科培训护士用智能手机筛查,约半年后多数学生接受胸部X线检查,疑似者转诊至脊柱侧弯门诊由经验丰富的脊柱外科医生进行前屈试验和脊柱侧凸测量计躯干旋转角分析,并以全脊柱X线Cobb法为金标准。护士初筛与脊柱外科医生复测的一致性在Cobb角<10°时低(κ=0.128),在Cobb角>10°时中等(κ=0.349);ROC分析提示两种方法诊断能力相似,但Cobb角切点调整为15°时后者诊断能力明显更优;智能手机筛查总体灵敏度不可接受。结论认为智能手机辅助脊柱侧弯筛查有风险。

要点

  • 护士智能手机初筛与脊柱外科医生脊柱侧凸测量计复测的一致性在Cobb角<10°时低(κ=0.128),在Cobb角>10°时中等(κ=0.349)。
  • ROC分析提示两种方法诊断脊柱侧弯的能力相似,但Cobb角切点调整为15°时脊柱外科医生方法诊断能力明显更优。
  • 智能手机筛查识别脊柱侧弯的总体灵敏度不可接受,研究结论认为该筛查方式有风险。

核心结论

  • 智能手机辅助的脊柱侧弯筛查有风险,其总体灵敏度不可接受。

研究设计与样本

  • 横断面研究,纳入10所中学的2702名七年级学生(平均年龄13.56岁,范围13-15岁)。
  • 先由骨科培训护士用智能手机进行初筛,约半年后多数学生接受胸部X线检查作为强制体检的一部分。
  • 初筛或胸部X线疑似者转诊至脊柱侧弯门诊,由经验丰富的脊柱外科医生进行单盲前屈试验和脊柱侧凸测量计躯干旋转角分析,最终以全脊柱X线Cobb法为金标准。

主要发现

  • 护士初筛与脊柱外科医生复测的一致性在Cobb角<10°时低(κ=0.128 [0.04-0.22],P=0.035),在Cobb角>10°时中等(κ=0.349 [0.19-0.50],P<0.001)。
  • ROC曲线分析提示两种方法诊断脊柱侧弯的能力相似。
  • 当Cobb角切点调整为15°时,脊柱外科医生方法诊断能力明显优于护士智能手机筛查。
  • 智能手机筛查识别脊柱侧弯的总体灵敏度不可接受。

关键数值与推荐

  • Cobb角切点为15°时,脊柱外科医生方法诊断能力明显优于护士智能手机筛查。

临床怎么用

  • 原文结论认为智能手机辅助脊柱侧弯筛查有风险,其总体灵敏度不可接受。

局限性

  • 原文未述局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

STUDY DESIGN: Cross-sectional. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to assess the accuracy of smartphone-aided diagnosis of scoliosis by a trained nurse compared with scoliometer-based diagnosis by a spine surgeon. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Many assessments have been developed to estimate the reliability of smartphone-aided measurements in diagnosing scoliosis. However, clinical studies assessing the accuracy of smartphone-aided diagnosis with radiographs or scoliometers are scarce. METHODS: A total of 2702 grade 7 students (mean age 13.56 yrs, range 13-15) at 10 middle schools were first screened with a smartphone by a trained nurse from the orthopedics department. Approximately half a year later, most of the students underwent a chest x-ray examination as part of a compulsory medical examination. Students with suspicious findings in either the first screen or the chest x-ray were recommended to a scoliosis clinic for single-blind tests, such as a forward bending test (FBT) and an analysis of the angle of trunk rotation (ATR) with a scoliometer, performed by an experienced spine surgeon. Finally, the Cobb method was conducted with full-spine radiographs to serve as the gold standard. RESULTS: The agreement between the first screening by the nurse and the second test by the spine surgeon was low in cases with a Cobb angle <10° (κ = 0.128 [0.04-0.22], P = 0.035) and fair in cases with a Cobb angle >10° (κ = 0.349 [0.19-0.50], P < 0.001). The results of receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis also suggested that these two tests were similar in their ability to diagnose scoliosis. However, when the Cobb angle cutoff was adjusted to 15°, the latter had markedly better diagnostic ability than the former. Overall, the sensitivity of the smartphone screening was not acceptable for recognizing scoliosis. CONCLUSION: This study revealed that smartphone-aided screening for scoliosis is risky. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 3.

来源:Spine (Phila Pa 1976),查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Chen C, Yu R, Xu W, et al. A Practical Study of Diagnostic Accuracy: Scoliosis Screenings of Middle School Students by a Trained Nurse With a Smartphone Versus a Spine Surgeon With a Scoliometer. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2020. PMID: 31568349. doi:10.1097/BRS.0000000000003256

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。