南部非洲本科肌肉骨骼课程的主题、技能与病例:本地与国际专家共识
本研究通过改良德尔菲共识法,由43名来自非洲、欧洲和北美的专家经3轮互动对南部非洲医学本科生骨科核心知识主题、临床病例和技能进行优先排序,共识定义为≥75%同意率。专家优先选出多发伤、跛行儿童和骨科急症等病例,技能优先为脱位与骨折的手法复位和固定,知识主题优先为骨科感染、常见骨折脱位治疗、转诊警示信号和背痛。
要点
- 专家优先选出的临床病例包括多发伤、跛行儿童和骨科急症。
- 优先技能为脱位与骨折的手法复位和固定。
- 优先知识主题包括骨科感染、常见骨折脱位治疗、转诊警示信号和背痛。
核心结论
- 涉及骨科创伤和感染的知识主题、技能和病例获得了最高的同意百分比优先排序。
- 骨折和脱位的急性初级保健排名较高。
- 不需要专科转诊的疾病的诊断和治疗也被优先考虑。
研究设计与样本
- 改良德尔菲共识研究,进行3轮交互式迭代沟通和专家对条目的优先排序。
- 43名参与者中大多数为来自南部非洲7个不同国家的骨科外科医生,28%为在初级或二级设施工作的全科医生或医生。
主要发现
- 专家优先选出多发伤、跛行儿童和骨科急症等病例。
- 优先技能为脱位与骨折的手法复位和固定。
- 最重要的知识主题包括骨科感染、常见骨折脱位治疗、转诊警示信号和背痛。
- 治疗紧急护理情况的手术技能被一些专家纳入,但排名较低。
关键数值与推荐
- 优先选择限于所有可能条目的50%。
- 每个条目的共识定义为同意百分比≥75%。
临床怎么用
- 本研究可为南部非洲的国家课程提供信息,并协助分配学生临床轮转。
局限性
- 原文未述局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Most patients with orthopaedic pathology in low to middle-income countries are treated by nonspecialists. A curriculum to prepare undergraduate medical students for this duty should reflect the local pathology and skills that are required to manage patients in a resource-restricted environment. The aim of this study was to establish and prioritize a list of core orthopaedic-related knowledge topics, clinical cases, and skills that are relevant to medical students in southern Africa and areas with a similar clinical context. METHODS: A modified Delphi consensus study was conducted with 3 interactive iterative rounds of communication and prioritization of items by experts from Africa, Europe, and North America. Preferred priorities were selected but were limited to 50% of all of the possible items. Percent agreement of ≥75% was defined as consensus on each of these items. RESULTS: Most of the 43 experts who participated were orthopaedic surgeons from 7 different countries in southern Africa, but 28% were general practitioners or doctors working in primary or secondary-level facilities. Experts prioritized cases such as patients with multiple injuries, a limping child, and orthopaedic emergencies. Prioritized skills were manipulation and immobilization of dislocations and fractures. The most important knowledge topics included orthopaedic infections, the treatment of common fractures and dislocations, any red flags alerting to specialist referral, and back pain. Surgical skills for the treatment of urgent care conditions were included by some experts who saw a specific need in their clinical practice, but these were ranked lower. CONCLUSIONS: A wide geographic, academic, and expertise-specific footprint of experts informed this international consensus through their various clinical and academic circumstances. Knowledge topics, skills, and cases concerning orthopaedic trauma and infection were prioritized by the highest percent agreement. Acute primary care for fractures and dislocations ranked high. Furthermore, the diagnosis and the treatment of conditions not requiring specialist referral were prioritized. This study can inform national curricula in southern Africa and assist in the allocation of student clinical rotations.
引用
- Held MFG, Laubscher M, Graham SM, et al. Topics, Skills, and Cases for an Undergraduate Musculoskeletal Curriculum in Southern Africa: A Consensus from Local and International Experts. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2020. PMID: 31596812. doi:10.2106/JBJS.19.00664
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。