髋部骨折分型与手术类型记录解读:对研究和国家审计的启示
在17个中心随机抽取903例髋部骨折病例,由专家根据AO系统复核骨折分型及手术类型,并与WHiTE队列研究及NHFD国家审计数据比较一致性。结果显示囊外骨折亚型一致性差,仅当分类合并为「囊外骨折」时多数中心达中等以上一致性;囊内骨折亚型一致性中等,合并后达「基本一致」;手术类型和关节置换类型一致性较高;NHFD中至少5.2%病例存在「高度不可能」的手术与分型组合。
要点
- 详细骨折分型(如囊外亚型)在国家层面数据中一致性不佳,合并为「囊外」等大类后一致性改善。
- 内固定手术类型和关节置换类型(半髋/全髋)报告一致性较高(接近「完美」或「基本一致」)。
- NHFD中至少5.2%病例记录了与分型「高度不可能」的手术组合。
核心结论
- 全国范围收集骨折分型数据的复杂性损害了详细分型系统报告的准确性,手术类型数据也呈现类似趋势。
- 未来的数据采集、报告和解读必须考虑到这一点。
研究设计与样本
- 在17个中心,由专家外科医生随机抽取本中心病例,根据AO系统复核骨折分型及手术类型。
- 将复核结果与WHiTE队列研究收集的数据比较一致性,并探索NHFD中手术类型与骨折分型的「高度不可能」组合比例。
主要发现
- 共复核903例记录。
- 囊外骨折亚型一致性差,大多数中心未超过「fair」一致性;合并为「囊外骨折」单选项后,仅4个中心未达至少「moderate」一致性。
- 囊内骨折亚型一致性仅「moderate」,合并为「囊内」后改善至「substantial」。
- 转子下骨折类型报告较好,达「substantial」一致性。
- 内固定手术一致性接近「perfect」;关节置换报告为「半髋关节置换」和「全髋关节置换」时达「perfect」或「substantial」一致性。
关键数值与推荐
- 囊外骨折亚型:大多数中心一致性未超过「fair」;合并为「囊外骨折」后,仅4个中心未达至少「moderate」一致性。
- 囊内骨折亚型:一致性「moderate」;合并为「囊内」后达「substantial」。
- 转子下骨折类型:一致性「substantial」。
- 内固定手术:一致性接近「perfect」。
- 关节置换类型(半髋/全髋):一致性「perfect」或「substantial」。
临床怎么用
- 未来的研究及国家审计在数据采集、报告和解读时需考虑骨折分型与手术类型记录准确性的局限。
局限性
- 原文未述局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: This study explores data quality in operation type and fracture classification recorded as part of a large research study and a national audit with an independent review. PATIENTS AND METHODS: At 17 centres, an expert surgeon reviewed a randomly selected subset of cases from their centre with regard to fracture classification using the AO system and type of operation performed. Agreement for these variables was then compared with the data collected during conduct of the World Hip Trauma Evaluation (WHiTE) cohort study. Both types of surgery and fracture classification were collapsed to identify the level of detail of reporting that achieved meaningful agreement. In the National Hip Fracture Database (NHFD), the types of operation and fracture classification were explored to identify the proportion of "highly improbable" combinations. RESULTS: The records were reviewed for 903 cases. Agreement for the subtypes of extracapsular fracture was poor; most centres achieved no better than "fair" agreement. When the classification was collapsed to a single option for "extracapsular" fracture, only four centres failed to have at least "moderate" agreement. There was only "moderate" agreement for the subtypes of intracapsular fracture, which improved to "substantial" when collapsed to "intracapsular". Subtrochanteric fracture types were well reported with "substantial" agreement. There was near "perfect" agreement for internal fixation procedures. "Perfect" or "substantial" agreement was achieved when the type of arthroplasty surgery was reported at the level of "hemiarthroplasty" and "total hip replacement". When reviewing data submitted to the NHFD, a minimum of 5.2% of cases contained "highly improbable" procedures for the stated fracture classification. CONCLUSION: The complexity of collecting fracture classification data at a national scale compromises the accuracy with which detailed classification systems can be reported. Data around type of surgery performed show similar tendencies. Data capture, reporting, and interpretation in future studies must take this into account. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2019;101-B:1292-1299.
引用
- Masters J, Metcalfe D, Parsons NR, et al. Interpreting and reporting fracture classification and operation type in hip fracture: implications for research studies and routine national audits. Bone Joint J. 2019. PMID: 31564146. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.101B10.BJJ-2019-0213.R1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。