金属对金属与陶瓷对金属全髋关节置换术国际多中心双盲随机对照早期结果
该前瞻性多中心随机对照试验(M2A-38,NCT00754520)纳入211例全髋关节置换患者,比较陶瓷对金属(CoM)与金属对金属(MoM)假体的非劣效性。结果显示两组功能评分和影像学参数无显著差异,CoM组钴离子水平较低(P<.01),但铬离子在3年后升高,且CoM组因金属碎屑不良反应的翻修略少。结论认为CoM临床表现与MoM相同,但金属离子在3年后升高且翻修增加,不支持进一步探索或使用。
要点
- CoM组各时间点钴离子水平均低于MoM组(P<.01)。
- 铬离子水平CoM组3年内显著较低,但5年时升高。
- 两组功能评分和影像学参数各时间点均无显著差异。
核心结论
- CoM假体的功能结局和影像学参数与MoM相同。
- CoM假体3年后金属离子升高,且因金属碎屑不良反应的翻修增加。
- CoM难以看到临床应用价值,不支持进一步探索或使用。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性、多中心、多术者、双盲、随机对照试验(M2A-38,NCT00754520),纳入211例患者,2009至2011年招募。
- 患者随机分配至陶瓷或金属组,部分患者每年检测全血金属离子,所有患者每年进行影像学和临床评估。
- 因对MoM假体失败的担忧,招募提前终止。
主要发现
- 患者人口学、影像学参数或功能结局在任何时间点均无显著差异。
- CoM组各时间点钴离子水平较低(P<.01)。
- 铬离子水平CoM组至3年显著较低,但5年时升高。
- CoM组因金属碎屑不良反应的翻修略少。
- 翻修物分析提示CoM组磨损模式与MoM组不同。
局限性
- 原文未述局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The aim of our prospective, multicenter, randomized, controlled trial (titled M2A-38 Ceramic-on-Metal RCT, NCT00754520) is to demonstrate noninferiority of a ceramic-on-metal (CoM) articulation compared with metal-on-metal (MoM) in total hip arthroplasty. The study arms are at 8 years since implantation, with metal ion and functional score analysis at 5 years. METHODS: We recruited 211 patients between 2009 and 2011. The patients were randomized to ceramic or metal. A cohort of these patients had whole blood metal ions performed yearly, and all patients underwent annual radiographic and clinical outcome assessment. All revisions were recorded and some explants were analyzed. Recruitment ceased earlier than planned owing to concerns raised with failure of MoM implants. RESULTS: No significant difference was seen in patient demographics, radiographic parameters, or functional outcomes at any time point. Lower cobalt ion levels were seen in the CoM group (P < .01) at all time points. Chromium levels were significantly lower in the CoM group up to 3 years, but raised at 5 years. There were slightly fewer revisions for adverse reaction to metal debris in the CoM group. Explant analysis suggested a different wear pattern to those seen in the MoM group. CONCLUSION: The results demonstrated that the CoM articulation behaved the same as the MoM in terms of functional outcome and radiographic parameters. The CoM coupling also demonstrates raised metal ions beyond 3 years and increasing revisions for adverse reaction to metal debris. It remains difficult to see a clinical application for CoM and further exploration or use is not warranted.
引用
- Higgins JE, Conn KS, Britton JM, et al. Early Results of Our International, Multicenter, Multisurgeon, Double-Blinded, Prospective, Randomized, Controlled Trial Comparing Metal-on-Metal With Ceramic-on-Metal in Total Hip Arthroplasty. J Arthroplasty. 2019. PMID: 31540737. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2019.08.002
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。