自体骨软骨移植与背侧闭合楔形跖骨截骨术治疗运动员Freiberg病的随机对照研究(3年随访)
该随机对照试验将27例Freiberg病运动员分至背侧闭合楔形跖骨截骨术组(14例)或自体骨软骨移植组(13例),平均随访46个月。自体骨软骨移植组在术后1年和3年的AOFAS-LMI评分均优于截骨术组(P<.001),但差异未达临床意义;自体骨软骨移植组恢复训练和完全运动时间更早(P<.001和P<.05)。作者结论为两种术式效果相当,自体骨软骨移植安全有效。
要点
- 自体骨软骨移植组术后1年AOFAS-LMI评分89.9±7.1、3年92±6.9,均高于截骨术组的81.8±6.6和84.4±5.6(P<.001),但差异未达临床意义。
- 自体骨软骨移植组开始训练时间为6±1周、完全恢复运动为10±2.5周,均早于截骨术组的8±1.5周和13±2.5周(P<.001和P<.05)。
- 截骨术组跖骨平均短缩1.9±0.5 mm,自体骨软骨移植组平均延长0.2±0.1 mm。
核心结论
- 作者结论为自体骨软骨移植与背侧闭合楔形跖骨截骨术效果相当,临床结果可接受、并发症率极低且可早期恢复运动,使自体骨软骨移植成为运动员Freiberg病的安全、有效且最佳治疗。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照试验,证据等级2级;2008年至2013年间连续纳入27例Freiberg病患者,随机分至背侧闭合楔形跖骨截骨术组(14例)或自体骨软骨移植组(13例)。
- 平均随访46个月(范围36-60个月)。
主要发现
- 背侧闭合楔形跖骨截骨术组AOFAS-LMI评分术前63.4±14.4、术后1年81.8±6.6、术后3年84.4±5.6;自体骨软骨移植组分别为62.8±14、89.9±7.1、92±6.9(P<.001)。
- AOFAS-LMI评分在术后1年和3年 favoring 自体骨软骨移植组的差异达到统计学显著但未达临床意义。
- 视觉模拟量表-足踝评分在背侧闭合楔形跖骨截骨术组从48.1±11.5改善至91.8±9.5,在自体骨软骨移植组从49.9±10.9改善至95.4±4.4。
- 背侧闭合楔形跖骨截骨术组跖骨平均短缩1.9±0.5 mm,自体骨软骨移植组平均延长0.2±0.1 mm。
- 自体骨软骨移植组开始训练时间6±1周(P<.001)、完全恢复运动时间10±2.5周(P<.05),背侧闭合楔形跖骨截骨术组分别为8±1.5周和13±2.5周。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为自体骨软骨移植是运动员Freiberg病的安全、有效且最佳治疗。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Dorsiflexion closing wedge metatarsal osteotomy (DCWMO) has been considered the traditional treatment of Freiberg disease. Several case reports presented osteochondral autologous transplantation (OAT) as an alternative treatment. PURPOSE/HYPOTHESIS: The purpose was to compare the results of DCWMO versus OAT for the treatment of Freiberg infraction in an athletic population. It was hypothesized that OAT was superior to DCWMO regarding functional outcomes, pain, and the time that the athletes returned to training and to previous sport level. STUDY DESIGN: Randomized controlled trial; Level of evidence, 2. METHODS: Between 2008 and 2013, 27 consecutive patients with Freiberg disease were randomly assigned to either the DCWMO group (14 patients) or the OAT group (13 patients). The primary outcomes collected were as follows: postoperative complications, range of motion of the metatarsophalangeal joint, length of the metatarsal, function of the foot (measured with the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society-lesser metatarsophalangeal-interphalangeal [AOFAS-LMI] score), and pain (assessed with the visual analog scale-foot and ankle score). RESULTS: Mean follow-up was 46 months (range, 36-60 months). The mean ± SD AOFAS-LMI score in the DCWMO group was 63.4 ± 14.4 preoperatively, 81.8 ± 6.6 at 1 year postoperatively, and 84.4 ± 5.6 at 3 years postoperatively, while in the OAT group, it was 62.8 ± 14, 89.9 ± 7.1, and 92 ± 6.9, respectively (P < .001). The differences in the AOFAS-LMI scores favoring the OAT group at 1 and 3 years reached statistical but not clinical significance. The mean visual analog scale-foot and ankle score was improved significantly from 48.1 ± 11.5 to 91.8 ± 9.5 in the DCWMO group and from 49.9 ± 10.9 to 95.4 ± 4.4 in the OAT group. There was a shortening of the metatarsals by a mean 1.9 ± 0.5 mm in the DCWMO group, as opposed to a metatarsal lengthening of 0.2 ± 0.1 mm in the OAT group. In the OAT group, patients were able to start training at 6 ± 1 weeks (P < .001) and return to full sport action at 10 ± 2.5 weeks (P < .05), while in the DCWMO group, the time was 8 ± 1.5 and 13 ± 2.5 weeks, respectively. CONCLUSION: The authors concluded that OAT is equal to DCWMO. Acceptable clinical results were reported, as well as very low morbidity and early return to sport activities. That makes the OAT procedure a safe, effective, and optimal treatment for an athletic population experiencing Freiberg infraction.
引用
- Georgiannos D, Tsikopoulos K, Kitridis D, et al. Osteochondral Autologous Transplantation Versus Dorsal Closing Wedge Metatarsal Osteotomy for the Treatment of Freiberg Infraction in Athletes: A Randomized Controlled Study With 3-Year Follow-up. Am J Sports Med. 2019. PMID: 31298927. doi:10.1177/0363546519859549
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。